California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 12, 1996
San Bruno Park Elementary School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 949-95 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson
San Bruno Park Elementary may reassess a 4-year-old with autism without parent consent, using its chosen psychologist, Dr. B.J. Freeman.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. The decision mentions an earlier parent-filed case (SN 150-95) taken off calendar after mediation, and a pending parent hearing request on placement and reimbursement.
Summary
San Bruno Park Elementary School District filed for due process after parents refused consent to a July 1995 assessment plan. The child is 4 years old and eligible for special education because of autistic-like behaviors. The District had last assessed her in October 1994. She had received 20 hours per week of private behavioral services from consultant Deborah Partain. In October 1995 her parents moved her into a 40-hour-per-week home program run by the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD). The parents argued that private and regional center evaluations already tracked her progress, and that a new assessment would disrupt her program. They also objected to the District's choice of Dr. B.J. Freeman, who has criticized the Lovaas method their program used.
The Hearing Officer held that state law allows reassessment before the three-year mark "if conditions warrant," meaning unusual circumstances. Those existed here. The child was very young, the District had not seen her for more than a year, her program had changed significantly from 20 to 40 hours a week, and the District proposed only a limited progress assessment. Citing Doe v. Phillips, the Hearing Officer ruled that the District need not rely on outside reports. On the choice of assessor, the law requires only qualified, trained assessors. It does not require one who favors the parents' preferred method. The Hearing Officer ordered the assessment by Dr. Freeman and directed the parents to make the child reasonably available.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO read "if conditions warrant" for early reassessment. A young child's major program change and long absence from district programs justified a limited reassessment without parent consent. It also shows SEHO holding that a district may choose any qualified assessor, even one who disagrees with the parents' preferred method.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedDistrict-filed: assess without consent
Issue 1a. Does the San Bruno Park Elementary School District have the right to assess STUDENT?
Conditions warranted a reassessment before the three-year mark: the student was young, had not been seen by the District for over a year, had just gone from a 20-hour to a 40-hour weekly program, and the proposed assessment was limited. The District did not have to rely on progress reports from private providers.
- District prevailedDistrict-filed: assess without consent
Issue 1b. If so, does the District have the right to determine who performs the assessment?
The law requires only that assessors be qualified and trained in the instruments they use. Nothing requires the District to pick an assessor who supports the parents' preferred method (Lovaas), so the District may use Dr. B.J. Freeman.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district may assess without consent. The District's request to have Dr. B.J. Freeman conduct an assessment under the assessment plan dated July 31, 1995 is granted. The plan covers observation, a parent interview, the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale and the Bayley Scales of Infant Development.
- Parents shall make the student reasonably available for the District to conduct the assessment.
Key authorities
Doe v. Phillips (N.D. Cal. 1994) 20 IDELR 1150; Education Code § 56381; Education Code § 56506(e); Education Code § 56320; Education Code § 56324(a); Education Code § 56507(d)
People named in the decision
- Deborah Partain, Private educational consultant who provided a one-to-one behavioral program (District witness), Private provider
- Kent Rezowalli, SELPA compliance coordinator (District witness), San Mateo County SELPA
- Dr. Jane Lubin, Director of special education (called as Student's witness), San Bruno Park Elementary School District
- Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh, Clinical director and private assessor (Student's witness), Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Dr. B.J. Freeman, Psychologist selected by District to conduct assessment, District-selected assessor
- Bryna Siegal, Psychologist proposed as candidate assessor; preferred by parents
- Edward Ritboe, Candidate assessor offered by District
- Richard Maceros, Candidate assessor offered by District
- Lori Ryan, Speech-language evaluator (February 1995 evaluation)
- Donna Dagenais, Speech-language therapist, Private provider
- Dr. Ivy Fischer, Student's physician who made the autism diagnosis, Private physician
- Golden Gate Regional Center, Regional center providing respite care and periodic evaluations, Regional center
- Poplar Center Early Child Development Program, Early childhood program the student attended June–November 1994, Private program
- Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), Private home behavioral (Lovaas-based) program, Private provider
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Redwood City, California, on February 22, 1996. In addition, one witness testified by telephone on February 23, 1996.
Petitioner San Bruno Park Elementary School District (District) was represented by Peter Finck, deputy county counsel. Kent Rezowalli, SELPA compliance coordinator was also present on behalf of the District. Respondent STUDENT was represented by Kathryn Dobel, attorney. Also present on STUDENT's behalf were her parents, FATHER and MOTHER.
The witnesses who testified at the hearing were as follows. On behalf of the District, Deborah Partain and Kent Rezowalli. On behalf of STUDENT, Dr. Jane Lubin, MOTHER, and Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the parties agreed to submit their closing arguments in written form. The closing arguments were received by the Hearing Office on March 4, 1996. The case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUE
Does the San Bruno Park Elementary School District have the right to assess STUDENT? If so, does the District have the right to determine who performs the assessment?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is four years old. She is eligible for special education because of a pervasive development disorder. Specifically, STUDENT has autistic-like behaviors.
STUDENT was accepted by the Golden Gate Regional Center in May 1994. Since May 1994, she has had respite care and regular evaluations (every six months) by psychologists on the Regional Center staff. In June 1994, STUDENT enrolled in the Poplar Center Early Child Development Program, where she remained until November 1994. In August 1994, STUDENT began receiving behavioral and educational services twenty hours per week from Deborah Partain, an educational consultant who works with children with autism and other pervasive development disorders. STUDENT continued working with Ms. Partain until October 1995.
In October 1994, a psychological evaluation of STUDENT was conducted at the SELPA's Early Childhood Education Assessment Center. Following completion of the evaluation, an individualized education plan (IEP) meeting was convened on December 16, 1994. At that meeting, the IEP team concluded that STUDENT was eligible for special education due to autistic-like behaviors. The IEP team recommended placement in a preschool special day class two days a week and adopted goals and objectives. In addition, the IEP team recommended that a speech and language evaluation be completed. STUDENT's parents agreed with the IEP team's recommendations but also requested that STUDENT be assigned a one-to-one aide. The IEP team agreed to review the necessity of a one-to-one aide at the next IEP meeting.
On February 14, 1995, Lori Ryan completed a speech and language evaluation and the IEP team again met. The team recommended forty minutes of speech and language services per week and continued placement in the preschool special day class two days a week. The IEP team refused to provide STUDENT with a one-to-one aide. In March 1995, STUDENT began receiving speech and language therapy from Donna Dagenais.
In February 1995, STUDENT's parents filed a request for a due process hearing on the issues of IEP, placement, and retroactive reimbursement. (SN 150-95) The parties met in mediation in June 1995 and agreed to take the hearing off calendar. During mediation, STUDENT's parents also agreed to provide the District with current progress reports from Ms. Partain and Ms. Dagenais. These reports were provided by the end of June.
On July 31, 1995, the District submitted an assessment plan to STUDENT's parents. The assessment plan calls for administration of the Vineland Adapative Behavior Scale to assess STUDENT's social/adaptive behavior and the Bayley Scales of Infant Development to assess STUDENT's intellectual development. In addition, the assessment calls for observation of STUDENT and indicates that the assessment will be conducted by a special education teacher and psychologist. STUDENT's parents refused to consent to the assessment.
On September 27, 1995, the District requested a due process hearing on the issue of assessment. The District offered four individuals -- B.J. Freeman, Bryna Siegal, Edward Ritboe, and Richard Maceros -- as candidates for conducting the assessment. However, by the time of the hearing, the District had decided that B.J. Freeman would be the individual conducting the assessment.
In October 1995, STUDENT was enrolled by her parents in the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD) program. The CARD program is a forty-hour-per-week home program. Subsequent to her enrolling at CARD, STUDENT was assessed by Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh, clinical director at CARD. Dr. Granpeesheh concluded that STUDENT's major delays were in the areas of expressive and receptive language. STUDENT showed a limited attention span and many self-stimulatory behaviors. In addition, STUDENT demonstrated a need in the area of self-help skills. STUDENT demonstrated age-appropriate gross and fine motor skills. Dr. Granpeesheh recommended numerous goals in the areas of gross and fine motor skills, self-help skills, speech and language skills, general knowledge and comprehension, and readiness.
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY
District Witnesses
Deborah Partain
Deborah Partain is an educational consultant who works with children with autism and other pervasive developmental disorders. Ms. Partain provided a intensive, one-to-one behavioral program for twenty hours per week to STUDENT from August 1994 through October 1995. Ms. Partain testified that when STUDENT enrolled in her program, Ms. Partain reviewed prior assessments and progress reports that had been conducted. Ms. Partain testified that if prior assessments and progress reports had not been available, she would have referred STUDENT for additional assessment. However, Ms. Partain testified that she accepted Dr. Ivy Fischer's(Footnote 1) diagnosis of autism and Ms. Dagenais observations of STUDENT.
Ms. Partain testified that during STUDENT's time with her, she conducted an informal assessment with STUDENT every three to four months to determine areas where STUDENT was either progressing or failing to progress. In addition, Ms. Partain testified that the Golden Gate Regional Center required a more formal assessment every four to six months. Ms. Partain testified that if she felt STUDENT needed a change in program, she may need another psychological evaluation. However, Ms. Partain testified that STUDENT was making sufficient progress in her program, and she did not see a need for another psychological evaluation.
Regarding the CARD program, Ms. Partain testified that it is a behavioral intervention program based on the Lovas method and is similar to her own program in that it is a one-to-one intensive behavioral program. Ms. Partain testified that the CARD program also has a similar curriculum, instructional format, and delivery system.
Kent Rezowalli
Kent Rezowalli is the compliance coordinator for the San Mateo County SELPA. Mr. Rezowalli testified that the District requested an assessment to assist it in developing an appropriate program for STUDENT. Mr. Rezowalli testified that the reports provided by Ms. Partain and Ms. Dagenais did not include recommendations for what kind of program STUDENT should be in.
Respondent's Witnesses
Jane Lubin
Jane Lubin is the director of special education for the District and has participated in each of STUDENT's IEP meetings. Dr. Lubin testified that the District wants Dr. B.J. Freeman to conduct an assessment of STUDENT. Dr. Lubin testified that the District does not dispute STUDENT's autism diagnosis and is not asking to do a comprehensive triennial assessment. Instead, the purpose of the proposed assessment is to establish how much progress STUDENT has made, because District personnel have not seen her since January 1995. To accomplish that purpose, the assessment would include observations, an interview with STUDENT's parents, and the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale and Bayley Scales of Infant Development. Dr. Lubin testified that no one from the District has observed STUDENT in her CARD program at home. Dr. Lubin also testified that the District has not received any progress reports regarding STUDENT since June 1995.
Regarding the different psychologists proposed for conducting the assessment, Dr. Lubin testified that she was unsure if Dr. Siegal could be impartial. Dr. Lubin testified that Dr. Freeman does not believe in the Lovas method, but does use other methods of intensive therapy. Dr. Lubin also testified that Dr. Freeman has observed the County's early childhood program but that Dr. Siegal has not.
MOTHER
MOTHER, STUDENT's mother, testified that STUDENT has been evaluated by three different doctors at the Golden Gate Regional Center and by Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh, clinical director for CARD. MOTHER testified that the District's assessment will have a detrimental effect on STUDENT because it will disrupt her educational program. In addition, MOTHER testified that another assessment is not warranted because it has not been three years since the last assessment, and the doctors who have recently evaluated and observed STUDENT all agree that she is in an appropriate placement. MOTHER testified that STUDENT has progressed in her current placement and does not need a new placement.
Regarding the assessor, MOTHER testified that Dr. Freeman is biased and that Dr. Siegal would be the best person to conduct the assessment. She testified that Dr. Diegal is objective and works locally and, therefore, can follow STUDENT's educational program.
Doreen Granpeesheh
Doreen Granpeesheh is the clinical director for CARD. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that CARD is a behavior modification program for children with autism and other pervasive personality disorders that is based on the Lovas method. As described by Dr. Granpeesheh, the Lovas method involves an evaluation to determine a child's behavioral excesses and educational deficiencies. Then "re-direction" and "extinction" are used to reduce behaviors, and the one-to-one discreet trial method is used to address the educational deficiencies.
Dr. Granpeesheh testified that in addition to reviewing prior records, she performed a new assessment of STUDENT when STUDENT enrolled in CARD to determine the baseline of the her skills. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that STUDENT should be evaluated every three to six months. This reevaluation should include an evaluation of the frequency of STUDENT's behaviors and an evaluation of her progress. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that there is no need for an additional assessment at this time. However, Dr. Granpeesheh testified that an assessment may provide additional information and another opinion regarding STUDENT's skills.
Regarding Dr. Freeman, Dr. Granpeesheh testified that Dr. Freeman has been critical of the Lovas method but that Dr. Freeman's own program is designed to provide similar services. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that if it were her decision she would not refer STUDENT to Dr. Freeman for an assessment, but would, instead, refer STUDENT to Dr. Siegal, Dr. Lovas, or Dr. Greisbach. Dr. Granpeesheh testified that Dr. Siegal is impartial and does not always recommend a forty hour per week discreet trial method program.
Finally, Dr. Granpeesheh testified that the change in STUDENT's program from twenty hours per week with Ms. Partain to forty hours per week in the CARD program is a significant change in program.
DISCUSSION
Education Code § 56381 provides that reassessments of students with exceptional needs must be conducted "at least every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant...." Prior written consent of the student's parent must be obtained before the local education agency may conduct an assessment of the student unless the District prevails in a special education due process hearing regarding the right to assess the student over the objection of the parent.(Footnote 2) California Education Code § 56506(e).
Petitioner's position is that the change in STUDENT's program from Ms. Partain to CARD in October 1995 was a substantial change in her educational program and, therefore, a reassessment is warranted. In addition, Petitioner points to the fact that District employees have not worked with or observed STUDENT since February 1995 and that the District has not conducted an evaluation of STUDENT since October 1994.
Respondent contends that the District is attempting to gain an expert opinion in preparation for the hearing requested by STUDENT's parents on the issues of placement and reimbursement, and that the change in STUDENT's program in October 1995 does not warrant a new assessment. Respondent contends that there has been no change in STUDENT's disability, goals and objectives, or program needs that would warrant conducting a new assessment. Respondent also points to the fact that Regional Center staff have continued to monitor STUDENT's progress as further evidence that the District does not need to conduct another assessment. Furthermore, Respondent contends that the District has consistently been offered the opportunity to observe STUDENT in her current program. Finally, Respondent contends that another assessment would force STUDENT to lose valuable time in her intensive educational program.
As noted above, special education law allows school districts to conduct assessments more frequently than every three years only "if conditions warrant." This phrase provides little guidance as to what "conditions" give a school district the right to conduct a reassessment earlier than the scheduled triennial reassessment. However, the phrase appears to refer to circumstances that are unusual or out-of-the-ordinary. For example, an additional assessment may be warranted when there is a substantial change in the student's academic performance or disabling condition.
In the present case, STUDENT has been regularly evaluated by the professionals who work with her. The District was provided with progress reports from Ms. Partain and Ms. Dagenais in June 1995. In addition, Dr. Granpeesheh conducted her own evaluation of STUDENT in December 1995. All of these reports are now available to the District and provide information regarding STUDENT's progress over the past year. In addition, the District has not raised any concerns regarding the accuracy of any of these reports. However, several factors weigh in favor of allowing the District to conduct its proposed assessment. First, as testified to by Dr. Granpeesheh, STUDENT has undergone a significant change in her program from 20 hours per week to 40 hours per week.
Second, the District is not asking to conduct a comprehensive triennial assessment. Instead, the District has asked to conduct a limited assessment for the purpose of determining how much progress STUDENT has made and where her abilities are at this time. The District's proposed assessment is similar in scope to an annual review of a student's progress in preparation for developing a new IEP.
Third, STUDENT is at an age when significant change can occur over a short period of time. The District has not had STUDENT in its own programs for more than a year and has not observed her in Ms. Partain's program or the CARD program. Furthermore, the District's only prior assessment of STUDENT occurred almost a year and a half ago.
Although the District has access to progress reports prepared by other individuals, the law does not require the District to rely on those reports and, instead, allows the District to develop its own information regarding STUDENT. The United States District Court confirmed a prior decision of the Hearing Office and held that when parents provide comprehensive independent assessments, the District does not need to rely on the independent assessments. Instead the District has a right to obtain its own assessment. Doe v. Phillips (N.D. Cal. 1994), 20 IDELR 1150. Similarly, although the parents in this case have provided progress reports to the District, the District has the right to conduct its own assessment to determine STUDENT's progress and abilities.
Based on STUDENT's age, the fact that STUDENT has been away from the District for more than a year and has recently had a significant change in her program, and the fact that the District is proposing to conduct an assessment limited to determining how much progress STUDENT has made and what her abilities are at this point, the Hearing Officer finds that unusual circumstances exist in the present case that warrant the District conducting the assessment it has proposed.
Regarding whether the District has the right to select an assessor of its own choosing, Education Code § 56320 provides that assessments of students with exceptional needs must be conducted by qualified persons. Section 56320(a)(3) requires that tests and assessment materials be administered by "trained personnel in conformance with the instructions provided by the producer of such tests...." Section 56320(g) requires that assessments be conducted by individuals knowledgeable of the student's disability. Finally, section 56324(a) provides that psychological assessments must be conducted by credentialed school psychologists "trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed."
Respondent contends that Dr. B.J. Freeman is not an appropriate assessor because she does not agree with the Lovas method of intensive services for children with autism. However, the only requirement of special education law is that assessors be qualified and trained in the use of the assessment instruments they use. Whether the District may choose Dr. Freeman as its assessor comes down to a question of whether the District must choose a professional who supports the teaching methodology proposed by the student's parents. There is no such provision in the law. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District may choose Dr. Freeman to conduct its proposed assessment.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Petitioner prevailed on the issue heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
ORDER
(1) San Bruno Park Elementary School District's request to conduct an assessment by Dr. B.J. Freeman pursuant to the assessment plan dated July 31, 1995 is granted.
(2) STUDENT's parents shall make STUDENT reasonably available for San Bruno Park Elementary School District to conduct the assessment.
DATED: March 12, 1996 ____________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Dr. Fischer is STUDENT's physician.
2. Section 56381 allows for a reassessment if the student's parent or teacher requests one. No evidence was presented to indicate that STUDENT's parents or teacher was requesting a reassessment. While the language of section 56381 does not provide any specific limitations on conducting a reassessment when the parent or teacher requests one, it is clear that a rule of reason would apply and the parent or teacher requesting a reassessment would have to demonstrate some change of circumstances justifying the reassessment.
