California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 17, 2001

Laguna Beach Unified School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 995-01 · Hearing Officer Van T. Vu

Laguna Beach Unified may finish a preschooler's reevaluation without parent consent, including home and preschool observations and staff interviews.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Laguna Beach Unified School District filed for hearing to complete a reevaluation of a five-year-old boy with autism. He attended a private preschool with a District-funded shadow aide and received 34 hours a week of in-home discrete trial therapy. The District wanted to update a limited 1999 assessment before his possible move to kindergarten. The parents first signed the assessment plan. They then limited when and how the District could observe him and barred staff from talking to his providers without the mother present. On April 10, 2001, they withdrew consent. Three parts of the evaluation were left: a preschool observation, a home-program observation, and interviews with his therapists and preschool staff.

The Hearing Officer denied the parents' mid-hearing request for a continuance to find a lawyer. On the merits, the Hearing Officer found that the District never had a meaningful chance to finish the assessment. Testimony from psychologist Dr. Paul Dores, special education director Mary Wuertz, and SELPA coordinator Sue Fallon showed the remaining parts were necessary. Therapy logbooks and existing records could not replace them. The evidence did not show that the assessments caused the boy's behavior to decline. A turnover of three home therapists happened at the same time. The parents also did not show that Dr. Dores was biased. The District could do three-hour observations and interviews without parent interference. Its request for a second observer at the home was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO handled a reassessment when parents consented and then withdrew consent. The district had to show that consent was lacking and that the assessment was necessary. The Hearing Officer then held that the district, not the parents, chooses qualified assessors and sets conditions such as length of observations and parent presence.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1. May the District complete its reevaluation of Student without his parents' consent?

    The parents withdrew consent after limiting the District's access. The home and preschool observations and the provider interviews were needed to develop the program, so the District may finish its reevaluation using assessors it chooses and without parent interference. Its request for a second home observer was denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order that district may assess without consent. District may observe the student for up to three hours in his in-home discrete trial program (Sue Fallon) and three hours at his preschool (Dr. Dores), and either Dr. Dores or Ms. Fallon may interview the home therapists, supervisor and preschool staff, with or without the parents present, at the District's discretion. The preschool observation must follow the preschool's own rules for observations. The request for a second District observer at the home observation was denied.
  • Parents ordered not to interfere with the observations or interviews and not to attend the preschool observation. If they are home during the home observation, they must stay at a distance and out of the student's view. Parents must make the student reasonably available to complete the transitional evaluation.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Gregory K. v. Longview School District (9th Cir. 1987); Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District (5th Cir. 1995); Vander Malle v. Ambach (2d Cir. 1983); Doe v. Phillips (N.D. Cal. 1994); SN 1549-99; Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(c); Cal. Educ. Code § 56381; 20 U.S.C. § 1414

People named in the decision

  • G. Robert Roice, education consultant representing District, Laguna Beach Unified School District
  • Mary Wuertz, director of special education; District witness, Laguna Beach Unified School District
  • Bob White, SELPA representative, South Orange County SELPA
  • Dr. Paul Alan Dores, private psychologist contracted by District to assess; District witness, Private practice
  • Susan (Sue) Fallon, coordinator of special education; District witness and assigned home observer, South Orange County SELPA
  • Jessica Postil, clinical director and home program supervisor; Student witness, Autism Spectrum Consultants
  • Vanessa Jones, home therapist; Student witness
  • Betty Lee, home therapist; Student witness
  • Melanie Ann Foshee, private speech-language therapist; Student witness
  • Caroline Cook, occupational therapist; Student witness
  • Sara Kummerfeldt, preschool director, Newport Coast Child Development Preschool
  • Jan Collings, adapted physical education specialist, Laguna Beach Unified School District
  • Sue Collins, District speech pathologist, Laguna Beach Unified School District
  • Dr. Ryan, vision therapist / optometrist
  • Karen Hogrebe, resource teacher, El Morro (Laguna Beach Unified School District)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Laguna Beach, California, on June 19 and 20, and July 9 and 10, 2001.

Petitioner Laguna Beach Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by education consultant G. Robert Roice. Also present on the District=s behalf were Mary Wuertz, director of special education, and Bob White, representative from the South Orange County SELPA.

Student STUDENT (STUDENT or Student) was represented by his parents, PARENTS. Family friends Kim Schwartz and Laurie Rybaczyk were also present during portions of the hearing.

The District called as witnesses Dr. Paul Alan Dores, private psychologist; Susan Fallon, coordinator of special education for the South Orange County SELPA; and Mary Wuertz. The Student called as witnesses Jessica Postil, clinical director of Autism Spectrum Consultants; Vanessa Jones, home therapist; Melanie Ann Foshee, speech and language therapist; Caroline Cook, occupational therapist; Betty Lee, home therapist; and his parents, PARENTS.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The Student’s written closing arguments were received in the Hearing Office by fax on July 18, 2001, and the District’s closing arguments were received by mail on July 19, 2001. The record was then closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On the second day of hearing, the Student made a request to “adjourn” the hearing in order to seek legal representation. The Student argued that the Hearing Officer was biased in favor of the District. Specifically, the Student asserted that he believed the Hearing Officer’s rulings on motions and objections were incorrect, but he did not have the legal background to determine why. Thus, according to the Student, he needed time to find an attorney to represent him on the allegation of bias and thereafter during the hearing.

The District objected to the Student’s request as untimely. The District argued that the hearing had already begun and that a continuance would result in needless delay of the proceedings. Additionally, the District noted that a decision is needed as to whether it would be allowed to conduct the remaining portions of its assessment, because there would not be much time left to assess the Student prior to the start of the next school year.

Special education due process hearings may be continued for good cause. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56505(f). While California Education Code Section 56505(e)(1) provides that parties to a due process hearing have a right to representation, it is the opportunity to be represented by an attorney that is protected and is not an absolute guarantee that a party may have an attorney present under any circumstance. In this case, the Student had previously been granted a continuance for the very purpose of allowing him additional time to seek legal representation. In spite of having almost a month and a half from the date the hearing in this matter was opened, the Student did not secure the assistance of counsel. Thus, the Student was allowed ample opportunity to obtain counsel, and his failure to do so does not constitute good cause to continue this matter still another time. Additionally, the Student proceeded forward on the first day of hearing without the assistance of counsel. The request to continue, made after completing a full day of hearing, was untimely. Moreover, the Student did not provide any support for his general contention that the Hearing Officer was biased, nor did he make specific allegations as to the perceived bias. Although a party may not agree with the rulings of the Hearing Officer, that disagreement alone does not establish bias or even put the question of bias at issue. Because the Student did not establish good cause to continue the hearing, the request was denied.

ISSUE

May the District complete its reevaluation of STUDENT without his parents’ consent?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The District requests that it be allowed to complete its transitional evaluation of STUDENT.(Footnote 2) Although the vast majority of the assessments have been completed, the District has been unable to observe STUDENT in the home during his discrete trial therapy sessions or at his preschool for any significant period of time. Additionally, the District has been restricted from speaking with STUDENT’s home therapy providers and his private preschool staff. The District states that STUDENT has not had a psychoeducational evaluation since 1999, and that the evaluation was limited only to an observation in the home program and at school. The District contends that observations in the home program and preschool need to be conducted to update the 1999 assessment and to determine how STUDENT is progressing academically. Moreover, because STUDENT receives most of his educational services from the District in these two environments, the District contends it needs to interview STUDENT’s service providers. Thus, the District requests that Dr. Dores, the private psychologist hired by the District to conduct STUDENT’s psychological evaluation, be allowed to observe STUDENT at his preschool for three hours. The District also requests that Sue Fallon, coordinator of special education for the SELPA, and another District person be allowed to observe STUDENT in the home for a period of three hours. Moreover, the District requests that it be allowed to interview the therapy providers and preschool staff. The District also requested that it be allowed to perform the observations and conduct the interviews without the presence or interference of the PARENTS.

The Student contends that the District should not be allowed to conduct those portions of the assessment for three primary reasons. First, he argues that the District was given consent and ample opportunity to conduct its evaluation but the District failed to do so. Second, the Student contends that the uncompleted portions of the assessment are unnecessary because the information to be gathered from the observations and interviews can be found in other ways. Third, the Student asserts that the partial assessments have caused his behaviors to regress and that any further assessments would be detrimental to his well-being.

BACKGROUND FACTS

Student STUDENT is a five-year-old preschool student eligible for special education and related services as a child with autism. The District currently provides STUDENT with 34 hours per week of intensive in-home discrete trial training therapy services and a shadow aide at the private preschool where his parents have placed him. STUDENT also receives occupational therapy, vision therapy, speech and language therapy, and adapted physical education consultation. STUDENT lives at home with his parents and twin sister.(Footnote 3)

In 1999, STUDENT turned three years old and the responsibility for his education transferred from the regional center to the Laguna Beach School District. In preparation for STUDENT’s transition into the District, the District contracted with Dr. Paul Dores, a private psychologist, to conduct a full psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT. For his evaluation, Dr. Dores observed STUDENT in his home-based discrete trial program and at his preschool. According to Dr. Dores, the PARENTS asked to be present for both of the observations, and asked that STUDENT’s school personnel not provide Dr. Dores any information. No other psychological assessments were administered on STUDENT at that time. Based on his evaluation of STUDENT, Dr. Dores recommended that the District provide STUDENT with the intensive home-based program that he is currently receiving.(Footnote 4)

Two years later, in preparation for STUDENT’s possible transition from preschool to kindergarten, the District sought to conduct a full reevaluation of STUDENT’s educational needs.(Footnote 5) As early as January 9, 2001, STUDENT’s IEP team had discussed the need for his reevaluation. On February 20, 2001, Mary Wuertz, director of special education for the District, sent MOTHER a letter requesting any information that she wanted to be considered in the development of STUDENT’s transition plan, such as “current areas of suspected disability, current education[al] performance, and areas of concern” that she would like assessed.

The next day, Ms. Wuertz sent to each of STUDENT’s service providers (with the exception of the preschool staff) a letter also requesting input regarding STUDENT’s assessment plan. Additionally, Ms. Wuertz set forth a chronology for the submission of additional information regarding STUDENT’s educational progress and of proposed goals and objectives for STUDENT, and for the completion of STUDENT’s assessment reports. STUDENT’s service providers were also informed of the scheduled date of STUDENT’s IEP meeting and of their respective roles at the meeting. Because the PARENTS refused the District permission to contact the preschool staff (even by conference call with MOTHER present), Ms. Wuertz did not send any of this information to STUDENT’s preschool staff. Apparently, MOTHER relayed Ms. Wuertz’s request for input on the assessment plan as well as the other information to STUDENT’s preschool staff. MOTHER also requested that they submit their responses to her so that she would forward the information to the District. (Student Exhs. J and N.)

On February 22, 2001, Ms. Wuertz sent to MOTHER a letter expressing concern over the restrictions MOTHER had placed on the District’s ability to observe STUDENT at the Newport Coast Preschool and to communicate with its staff. According to Ms. Wuertz’s letter, MOTHER’s restrictions included: (1) the District could conduct only two observations annually, (2) only one District staff member could come at a time, (3) the observations could be made only in MOTHER’s presence, (4) the observations were to be limited in time, and (5) District staff could not talk to the preschool teacher or director regarding STUDENT’s progress.

Sometime between February 21 and March 5, Ms. Wuertz received the requested information relating to the development of STUDENT’s assessment plan from his public and private speech and language therapists, his home program therapists, his occupational therapist, his adapted physical education specialist, his vision therapist, and his parents. On March 5, Ms. Wuertz summarized this information into a report, indicating what information was needed from STUDENT’s evaluation.

Also on March 5, an assessment plan was faxed to PARENTS for their consent. Pursuant to the assessment plan, the District sought to assess STUDENT in the areas of academic/preacademic achievement, social/adaptive behavior, pyschomotor development, communication development, intellectual/cognitive development, health status, and vision development. Additionally, the District requested that it be allowed to conduct observations of STUDENT in all settings where the District was funding services. Attached to the assessment plan was a list of tests that were to be administered in each of the assessment areas by the District or SELPA staff or by Dr. Dores.

On March 8, MOTHER wrote a letter to Ms. Wuertz requesting information as to the purpose of each of the proposed assessment tests, and requesting that she be able to observe or videotape the assessments. Ms. Wuertz responded on March 12 that the PARENTS were welcome to observe the assessments. Additionally, Ms. Wuertz attached to her letter explanations of each of the assessment tests that were to be administered on STUDENT, with the exception of the tests in the psychomotor development area, which were to be provided at a later date. MOTHER signed the assessment plan on March 14, 2001, indicating her consent for the District to conduct the assessments.

Within a week of the assessment plan being signed, MOTHER contacted Dr. Dores regarding the assessments. MOTHER and Dr. Dores agreed to schedule the preschool observation for March 22. Additionally, Dr. Dores was to go to the STUDENT’s home on April 2 to schedule the remaining portions of the assessment and to discuss STUDENT’s developmental history since the 1999 assessment.

On about March 21, Sara Kummerfeldt, director of the Newport Coast Child Development Preschool where STUDENT attends, sent Mrs. Wuertz a letter indicating that STUDENT and his sister had already been observed at least 15 times that year. However, Ms. Kunnerfeldt did not specify who conducted the observations or whether the observations were made of STUDENT or of his sister. Ms. Kummerfeldt then acknowledged that Dr. Dores had planned to observe the children and that the school had already authorized his visit. Ms. Kummerfeldt requested that STUDENT and his sister not have any other visits until the summer session, unless “extremely necessary.”

According to MOTHER, STUDENT was observed during from September 2000 through May 2, 2001 by clinical supervisor Jessica Postil, APE specialist Jan Collings, District speech pathologist Sue Collins, vision therapist Dr. Ryan, private speech pathologist Melanie Foshee, and SELPA representative Sue Fallon. Ms. Wuertz testified that none of these visits to the preschool were for the purpose of performing an observation of STUDENT as part of the transitional evaluation. Furthermore, each of the classroom visits was made for the purpose of implementing STUDENT’s IEP or to supervising STUDENT’s shadow aide. For example, Ms. Collings visited STUDENT’s preschool to provide APE consultation services as required per his IEP.

On March 22, Dr. Dores was unable to attend his scheduled observation of STUDENT at the preschool. According to Dr. Dores, another student’s IEP meeting that he was attending had run late. On April 2, Dr. Dores went to the STUDENT’s home to schedule his assessment of STUDENT. On the morning of April 5, Dr. Dores met STUDENT and his sister at a vision therapy session to observe their therapy. At 2:00 p.m. that day, Dr. Dores went to the STUDENT’s home and observed STUDENT during his speech and language therapy with Melanie Foshee. The next day, Dr. Dores observed STUDENT during his occuapational therapy (O.T.) session at the O.T. clinic. After the therapy, Dr. Dores went to the STUDENT’s home to administer the WPSSI to STUDENT. After taking a lunch break, Dr. Dores returned to the STUDENT’s home to sit in on the twins’ home therapy program clinic meeting. At the meeting, Dr. Dores listened to the meeting discussions and briefly observed STUDENT’s sister work with her therapist. Dr. Dores’ observation of STUDENT in the preschool was eventually rescheduled to late April. In spite of Dr. Dores’ three visits to the STUDENT’s home, it is unclear whether Dr. Dores and MOTHER scheduled an appointment for the purpose of observing STUDENT’s home therapy program.

By letter dated April 10, the PARENTS withdrew their consent to any further assessments or observations of STUDENT until they received specific information regarding the assessment. Specifically, the PARENTS requested a list of specific tests and observations that Dr. Dores and the other providers needed to complete the evaluation. They also requested an accounting of the dates and number of hours of testing already provided by various service providers and assessors and the number of additional hours needed to complete the assessment. On April 11, Ms. Wuertz sent STUDENT’s assessment team a memorandum notifying them of the PARENTS’ withdrawal of consent, and requested that the information sought by the PARENTS be provided to the District.

Ms. Wuertz provided the PARENTS with the information they requested by letters dated April 10 and 24. In spite of their withdrawal of consent for the assessments, between April 10 and mid-May, the PARENTS allowed STUDENT to be assessed by Jessica Postil, STUDENT’s home program supervisor, Sue Collins, District speech pathologist, Jan Collings, District APE specialist, Karen Hogrebe, El Morro resource teacher, and Dr. Ryan, STUDENT’s optometrist.

In the meantime, at least three of STUDENT’s home therapists resigned. One therapist quit on April 6 following the clinic meeting at the STUDENT’s home. Another two of STUDENT’s home therapists suddenly quit on April 16. According to letters written to the PARENTS, the two therapists quit because they were “uncomfortable working in the environment” and decided that it was time to “move on.” According to Jessica Postil, the supervisor of STUDENT’s home program, one of the therapists discussed with her that the working environment was “difficult.” Although MOTHER contended the therapists left due to the stress related to the District’s assessment, Ms. Postil testified that the therapist she spoke with did not mention the District’s observations as her reason for leaving. Following the departure of STUDENT’s therapists, new therapists were hired and trained to work with STUDENT.

According to FATHER and Ms. Foshee, STUDENT’s behavior noticeably declined during April. Ms. Foshee stated that STUDENT exhibited more stress, was irritable and would come close to tantrumming, wet his pants on one occasion, and had trouble sitting still and complying. Dr. Dores stated that STUDENT’s behaviors dramatically changed around mid-April. FATHER described that STUDENT exhibited lessened awareness of danger, ran into the streets, and made faces indicating that he was stressed.

Still unable to conduct the home and school observations and the interviews with the home therapy providers and preschool staff to complete STUDENT’s reevaluation, Ms. Wuertz again requested specific dates for Dr. Dores to complete his assessment. By letter dated April 10, 13, 24, and 30, Ms. Wuertz requested permission for Dr. Dores and Sue Fallon to perform the remaining portions of STUDENT’s assessments. In the April 30 letter, Ms. Wuertz notified the PARENTS that the District would request a due process hearing to seek a determination allowing it to complete its assessment of STUDENT if consent was not provided by May 4, 2001. On May 2, the PARENTS sent Ms. Wuertz a letter stating that they had cooperated in the assessment process and would not be providing consent for the observations or interviews to be conducted by Sue Fallon and Dr. Dores. On May 4, Ms. Wuertz notified the PARENTS that the District would be requesting a due process hearing on May 10. In response, the PARENTS again refused permission for any observations in the home or school, but allowed Ms. Wuertz permission to contact STUDENT’s preschool teachers by telephone, with the condition that the PARENTS be included in the conference call with the teachers.

On May 10, 2001, Ms. Wuertz requested a due process hearing.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Reassessment of a student with disabilities must be conducted at least once every three years, or more frequently, if conditions warrant. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381; 20 U. S. C. § 1414 (a) (2)(A). In Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1315 (9th Cir. 1987), the Ninth Circuit stated that "if the parents want [their child] to receive special education under the Act, they are obligated to permit such testing." In Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District, 64 F.3d 176, 178 (5th Cir. 1995), the Fifth Circuit concluded that "a parent who desires for her child to receive special education must allow the school district to evaluate the child...there is no exception to this rule." See also Vander Malle v. Ambach, 673 F.2d 49, 53 (2nd Cir. 1983).

While the law provides that a school district has the right and obligation to conduct these reassessments, parental consent for an evaluation of a child is required before a school district can assess the child. Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(c); 20 U. S. C. § 1414(a)(1)(A)(i). However, a local educational agency can override a lack of parental consent if it establishes the need to conduct such an assessment at a due process hearing. California Education Code § 56321(c), § 56505(e), and 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(A)(ii). Therefore, for the district to be allowed to conduct its assessment, it must establish that consent for the assessment has been withheld and that the assessments are necessary to provide the student with a free appropriate public education.

Withdrawal of Parental Consent and Inability to Complete Assessment

In this case, the District is seeking to complete the three remaining portions of STUDENT’s transitional evaluation. Specifically, the District requests that it be allowed to have Dr. Dores observe STUDENT in the preschool environment for three hours, to have Sue Fallon observe STUDENT in the in-home discrete trial therapy program, and to have Dr. Dores interview STUDENT’s in-home therapy providers and his preschool staff. STUDENT’s parents acknowledge that consent for the assessments was withdrawn on April 10, 2001, and that they continue to refuse the District consent to complete these portions of the assessments. However, the Student argues that the District had consent for the assessments for almost a month and had ample time and opportunity to conduct its assessments prior to the withdrawal of consent. Such contentions are not supported by the evidence. Rather, the evidence established that the District has attempted to complete those portions of the assessment, but that the PARENTS have either withheld their consent or has placed undue restrictions on the District’s ability to complete those assessments.

With regard to the observation of STUDENT’s participation in the classroom, it is undisputed that Dr. Dores was given consent to observe STUDENT at his preschool for four hours on March 22, but he missed the appointment because an IEP meeting he was attending ran late. Although the observation was rescheduled to April, MOTHER cancelled the rescheduled observation. When Dr. Dores tried to reschedule the observation again, MOTHER offered a date when Dr. Dores could only observe for an hour. Determining that the offered time slot was not long enough to complete his observation, Dr. Dores declined the offer and sought in vain to find agreeable dates for the observation. MOTHER contended that the offer of the one-hour time slot provided the District with the opportunity to perform the observation. However, this contention is unavailing because the opportunity to observe would not have resulted in the completion of the entire observation. Although MOTHER asserts that the observations were rescheduled to April 11 and 18, Dr. Dores disputes that those appointments were made. Regardless, even if those dates had been agreed to by both parties, the dates fell after the date that the PARENTS withdrew their consent for the assessments. Hence, Dr. Dores would not have had the opportunity to assess STUDENT on those dates. In spite of the District’s multiple requests to reschedule the observation after the withdrawal of consent, those requests were not granted by the PARENTS.

While it is unfortunate that Dr. Dores missed the March 22 appointment to observe STUDENT at the preschool, Dr. Dores’ actions were not ill-intended. Because the IDEA envisions collaboration between school districts and parents in the development and implementation of the student’s educational program, it is reasonable to expect STUDENT’s parents to cooperate with the District in finding an appropriate time for the observation, despite the one missed appointment. Furthermore, although difficulty scheduling STUDENT’s assessments may account for some of the problems MOTHER and Dr. Dores had scheduling the observations, it does not explain the PARENTS’ withdrawal of consent for the assessments or their refusal to reschedule the observations.

With regard to the observation of the home program and the interviews with the home therapists, the Student contends that Dr. Dores visited the home on April 2, 5, and 6, and had adequate opportunity to observe the home program and talk to the therapists. However, MOTHER acknowledged that the home visit on April 2 was scheduled for the purpose of, and was predominantly spent, scheduling dates for the remainder of the assessments. Dr. Dores testified similarly, and stated that the home visit was spent scheduling appointments and discussing the twins’ developmental history with MOTHER. Thus, the April 2 visit to the home was not for the purpose of observing STUDENT. On April 5, Dr. Dores visited STUDENT’s home to observe STUDENT’s speech and language therapy with Melanie Foshee. Because STUDENT was receiving speech services at that time, Dr. Dores did not observe him during his discrete trial therapy program. On April 6, Dr. Dores attended a “clinic meeting” with the home therapy providers of STUDENT and his sister. At the meeting, Dr. Dores listened to the discussions of the home therapy team and briefly observed the therapists working with STUDENT’s twin sister. He also did not have an opportunity to observe STUDENT in therapy to any meaningful extent at that time.

Although the Student argues that Dr. Dores could have somehow observed the home therapy or talked with the providers at any of these times, the appointments were for set times and were for other purposes. According to Dr. Dores, because the appointments were scheduled for specific purposes, he thought he would also be given the opportunity to do his observations at a later time. However, that opportunity never arose. In summary, the evidence indicates that Dr. Dores did not have a reasonable opportunity to observe STUDENT during his home therapy for any significant time.

Dr. Dores also was not able to talk freely with the home therapy providers at that time, because MOTHER also restricted the District’s discussions with the home therapy providers. According to Dr. Dores, MOTHER told him not to talk to STUDENT’s therapists, supervisors and preschool staff without her being present. Additionally, when Dr. Dores attempted to ask one of STUDENT’s service providers a question, MOTHER intervened by answering the question for him.

Finally, the evidence established that the District’s ability to communicate with STUDENT’s preschool staff was also severely limited. According to Ms. Wuertz, the PARENTS refused the District permission to talk with the preschool staff from as early as February. Although MOTHER claimed that she did not restrict the District’s access to STUDENT’s preschool staff, she acknowledged during her testimony that she only allowed the District to communicate with them by relaying messages through her. According to MOTHER, she did this to act as a “buffer” between the District and the preschool staff because the preschool staff was distressed by the wide scope of the District’s assessment of STUDENT. Additionally, MOTHER wanted to guard against the District releasing “confidential information” to the preschool staff. As noted in Mrs. Wuertz’s letter dated May 14, access to the preschool staff was not granted until May 9. Even then, the access was limited to a conference call with MOTHER present. Even though MOTHER apparently invited the preschool staff to the IEP meeting, she also indicated that they did not plan to attend. Furthermore, Dr. Dores testified that after he contacted the preschool to ask about the school calendar to schedule an observation, MOTHER requested that he refrain from contacting the preschool. In light of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that District never had free access to talk with STUDENT’s preschool staff. While the record indicates that the PARENTS were sufficiently cooperative regarding the assessment of STUDENT’s related services, the PARENT’s resistance centered on the assessments involving the home program and the preschool. Although the parents agreed to the assessment plan, they did not provide the District meaningful opportunity to conduct the assessments, then later withdrew their consent for the assessments. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District never had a meaningful opportunity to assess STUDENT and currently lacks consent to assess him. The Hearing Officer turns next to whether the uncompleted portions of the assessments are necessary.

Necessity of Assessments

Both California and federal law requires that no single procedure can be used to determine the student’s educational program. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(2)(B); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(e). Federal law requires districts, in conducting an evaluation, to “use a variety of assessment tools and strategies to gather relevant functional and developmental information… that may assist in determining… the content of the child’s individualized education program, including information related to enabling the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum or, for preschool children, to participate in appropriate activities.” 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(2)(A). Additionally, the districts must use “assessment tools and strategies that provide relevant information and directly assists persons in determining the educational needs of the child.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(j). Pursuant to California Education Code Section 56327, persons who assess a pupil must prepare an assessment report that includes the relevant behavior noted during the “observation of the pupil in an appropriate setting,” and the relationship of that behavior to the pupil’s academic and social functioning. The credible and persuasive testimony of Dr. Dores, Mary Wuertz, and Sue Fallon established that the home program observation, the preschool observation, and the interviews with STUDENT’s therapy providers and preschool staff are necessary to make recommendations regarding his educational placement and services.

As noted above, the District is seeking this assessment to develop STUDENT’s educational program and to determine whether he can transition to kindergarten. Dr. Dores testified that the observation of the preschool is important to obtain information as to how STUDENT is gathering information from the environment and how he performs in a group. Moreover, the observation of the home program is important to see how STUDENT responds to instructions during his discrete trial therapy. Dr. Dores also testified that interviews of STUDENT’s teachers are important to obtain information about how the child functions in a school environment, what he needs in order to learn, and how the child learns. Furthermore, he stated that interviews with STUDENT’s home program providers would provide information as to their long-range goals for STUDENT, how the goals are implemented, and how STUDENT responds to the programs. According to Dr. Dores, all of this information is necessary to evaluate the appropriateness of STUDENT’s current educational program and to make recommendations regarding his placement and services. Lastly, Dr. Dores testified that the only portion of the psychology assessment he has been able to complete is the WPPSI, and that the observations in the home and at school would complete the observational portion of the assessment.

Mary Wuertz also testified that these remaining portions of the assessment are necessary in order to develop STUDENT’s educational program. Ms. Wuertz testified that Dr. Dores had already observed STUDENT during his speech and language and occupational therapy, and the District needed the observations in the home and school to provide a global view of STUDENT’s functioning in all environments. Additionally, she testified that the observations needed to be at least three hours long so that STUDENT could be observed across settings and activities. Ms. Wuertz testified that the observation in the school would provide information as to STUDENT’s peer interactions, compliance with teachers, ability to follow directions, academics, and gross motor ability. Furthermore, Ms. Wuertz testified that the observations and interviews are necessary because STUDENT’s 1999 psychological evaluation is outdated and limited in scope due to STUDENT’s young age at the time of administration. The 1999 assessment only included observations of STUDENT in the home and at school.

Sue Fallon testified that the preschool observations were a necessary part of the assessment to determine what teaching strategies have been effective at the preschool level, how STUDENT interacts with staff and students in the environment, how STUDENT generalizes his skills, and what his behavioral needs are. Ms. Fallon also stated that the observation in the home is necessary to see how STUDENT is progressing and how he interacts with others in his home environment. Moreover, the interviews with the home therapists and preschool team are necessary to determine if they have any suggestions regarding STUDENT’s educational needs.

The Student disputes that the observations in the home and preschool are necessary because the information derived from the observations could be obtained from home-therapy logbooks, from the documents already in his educational file, and from speaking with his home-therapy providers and preschool teachers. The Hearing Officer does not find the Student’s arguments persuasive for the three reasons set forth below. First, although the logbooks are voluminous and set forth the tasks that STUDENT is presented within his program, they are merely one aspect of the collection of information needed to develop STUDENT’s educational program. While the information from the logbooks is important, it does not replace observations in the home by an assessor for evaluation purposes in this case. Moreover, the information from the logbooks is limited because it would only contain notations made by the therapists and would not contain other information that could be found in observing the program. Second, in spite of the general allegation that the information sought by the District already exists, the Student did not specify where in the educational file the information sought by the District could be found and did not otherwise provide support for the allegation.

Third, the home-therapy providers and preschool staff provide STUDENT with his educational services. There is no evidence that any of these persons conducted a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT and could provide information related to a psychoeducational assessment. Additionally, as STUDENT’s home therapy supervisor Jessica Postil testified, outside assessments could be helpful because the person would have a fresh perspective and could see things that may be overlooked by the current service providers. Furthermore, the Student’s argument that the District could get the information from asking the service providers is disingenuous at best in light of the restrictions his parents have placed on such communications. Even if speaking with STUDENT’s service providers could elicit all of the information sought by the District, STUDENT’s parents have placed restrictions on the District’s ability to talk freely with these providers, as stated above.

In conclusion, the great weight of the evidence established that the observations and interviews requested by the District are necessary for the development of STUDENT’s educational program. Dr. Dores, Ms. Wuertz, and Ms. Fallon all testified persuasively that the observations and interviews would provide information regarding his functioning that cannot be found elsewhere. The District’s request to perform observations and conduct interviews as part of STUDENT’s assessment is also consistent with federal and State law, as described above. Because the District’s current completed portions of the psychological assessment include only the administration of the WPSSI, the use of observations and interview data would satisfy the law’s requirement that no single procedure be used to determine the student’s educational program. Additionally, the observations and interviews would satisfy the requirement in the law that a variety of assessment tools and strategies be used “to gather relevant functional information to determine the child’s ability to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum or, for preschool children, to participate in appropriate activities.”

The Student argues that the observations should not be allowed even if they are necessary because they would detrimentally impact his behaviors.(Footnote 6) FATHER testified that STUDENT’s behaviors dramatically declined during mid-April.(Footnote 7) Melanie Foshee testified that STUDENT exhibited stress during April and for about a month afterwards. Ms. Foshee attributes his stress to changes in his routine, but could not determine whether the stress resulted from the assessments or from the changeover of his three home therapists (which occurred during mid-April). She also testified that STUDENT’s behaviors were fine during the actual assessments.

Even though the record indicates that STUDENT did exhibit some stress at about the time of the assessments, there is no specific and persuasive indication that the he would be affected by the observations of him at home and at school. In any case, over three months have passed since any part of the District’s evaluation was last administered. It also has been over four months since Dr. Dores or Ms. Fallon was involved in STUDENT’s assessment. Thus, a significant time has passed for STUDENT to readjust to his routine, and any stress that STUDENT may have exhibited as a result of the District’s assessment months before cannot act to indefinitely bar future assessments of STUDENT. Additionally, STUDENT’s parents allege only generally that his behaviors were caused by the assessments. The only testimony specifically linking the assessments to the negative behaviors came from Ms. Foshee, who stated that STUDENT may have reacted to the changes in his routine. The observations, however, would not require that STUDENT’s routine be changed. The District is asking to be present only during STUDENT’s normal school and home therapy schedule. According to Dr. Dores, Ms. Foshee, and Ms. Postil, STUDENT did not appear bothered by their observations of him. Hence, any stress caused by the observations would only be minimal. Even assuming that STUDENT suffered stress from the assessments, the Student provided no legal support, and the Hearing Officer does not know of any, for the proposition that the general effect of testing would bar all future testing. While it is plausible that the effect of testing on the child must be considered in choosing testing instruments and in determining the validity of the assessment, the law requires that the child must be assessed at least every three years and in all areas of suspected disability.

In any event, the Hearing Officer notes that the assessments overall were not a significant contributor to STUDENT’s behaviors. Both FATHER and Ms. Foshee testified that STUDENT’s behaviors changed noticeably in April. However, a large portion of STUDENT’s assessments was conducted during the month of March. By all accounts, STUDENT acted appropriately during his assessments and did not exhibit any significant negative behaviors. According to FATHER, STUDENT’s behaviors during March were a “normal variance” of his behaviors, sometimes good and sometimes bad. Additionally, some of the negative behaviors that FATHER described, such as STUDENT’s bolting into the streets, occurred a couple of weeks prior to the hearing convening in July. Therefore, some of the behaviors occurred approximately two months after the last assessments were administered. Concurrent with the period that FATHER and Ms. Foshee noticed large changes in STUDENT’s behavior, three of STUDENT’s home therapists were replaced. Because STUDENT has less than ten therapists, a changeover of three tutors represents a significant change to STUDENT’s routine. Unlike STUDENT’s assessments, which were last administered in mid-May, the replacement of the home therapists was a lengthy process, involving interviews and extensive training. Thus, the changeover of therapists could have continued to affect STUDENT long after the District’s assessments were last administered and could explain his more recent behaviors.

Because it was found above that the assessments requested by the District are necessary for developing STUDENT’s educational program, and because the Student has not asserted any persuasive basis for denying the District’s request to conduct its assessments, the District may perform the assessments over the PARENTS’ refusal of consent. Accordingly, the District is entitled to perform its observation of STUDENT in his home program and at his preschool and conduct its interviews of STUDENT’s home therapy providers and preschool staff.

Parameters of Assessment

Regarding the parameters of the observations and interviews, the District requests first that Dr. Dores be the person to observe STUDENT at his preschool, that the observation be for a duration of three hours, and that observation be done without the PARENTS’ presence or interference. The District also requests that the observation of STUDENT in the home be performed by Sue Fallon, that it be for three hours, and that it be done without his parents’ interference. Additionally, the District requests that either Dr. Dores or Ms. Fallon be allowed to interview STUDENT’s home therapy providers and preschool staff without the presence or involvement of STUDENT’s parents. The Student opposes the District’s requests generally, and specifically opposes the use of Dr. Dores for the assessments. The Student argues that Dr. Dores is biased because he has predetermined that STUDENT should be educated entirely in a group setting and, therefore, he would not perform an independent evaluation of his needs. The Hearing Officer will address each of the District’s requests below.

There is nothing in either California or federal law that requires districts to agree to parentally imposed conditions of assessment. A school district has the legal authority to choose who will conduct an assessment as long as the person is qualified to conduct the assessment under the law. Similarly, a school district has discretion to determine how the assessment will be conducted. (See: SN 1549-99; Doe. v. Phillips, 20 IDELR 1150, 1151 (N.D. Cal. 1994); Andress, supra at 178-179; Vander Malle, supra at 53.) The Student's parents have not cited any specific provision in the law or any other basis that allows parents to prescribe conditions of assessment.

With regard to the observation of the preschool, there is no persuasive evidence that Dr. Dores is biased or has preconceived notions regarding STUDENT’s needs. The PARENTS base their contention on the allegation that Dr. Dores stated, prior to starting his evaluation of STUDENT, that STUDENT should typically be educated in a group setting rather than his one-to-one home therapy program because autistic children should not be provided home therapy for longer than two years.(Footnote 8) However, Dr. Dores disputes that he ever made this comment or that he even has an opinion about how long a child should stay in a discrete trial therapy program. Assuming for the sake of argument that Dr. Dores made this comment, this fact alone would not establish that he could not perform an unbiased assessment. According to his testimony, his recommendations regarding a child’s program would be determined from his assessment as to the child’s abilities and needs. Moreover, Dr. Dores was the very person to recommend the intensive discrete trial therapy program that STUDENT is currently receiving. Thus, he clearly has the opinion that such a program could be appropriate if the needs of the child warranted it.

The Hearing Officer notes also that Dr. Dores is qualified to conduct the assessment. California Education Code ' 56320(g) states that the assessment must be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the student=s disability. California Education Code ' 56322 also requires that the assessments be conducted by persons competent to perform the assessments. Dr. Dores is a licensed psychologist who, in the past, has worked as part of the Autism Project at the University of California, Los Angeles. Dr. Dores has conducted many assessments of autistic children, both as part of his private practice and for school districts requesting his services. He also has been hired for consultation purposes by school districts and other agencies providing home therapy programs for autistic children. Aside from his background in working with children with autism, Dr. Dores is knowledgeable of STUDENT’s disability because he conducted a psychological evaluation of STUDENT in 1999. In light of the District’s discretion to chose its assessors, Dr. Dores’ qualification to conduct STUDENT’s assessment, and the Student’s failure to establish why Dr. Dores is not qualified to perform the assessments, Dr. Dores may perform the observation of STUDENT at his preschool.(Footnote 9)

With regard to the request for the preschool observation to last a minimum of three hours, this decision is also within the District’s general discretion. In any case, the evidence also indicates that the three hours is needed for the observation. According to Dr. Dores, the observation would entail observing STUDENT in many situations and environments, and over time. Similarly, Ms. Wuertz testified that three hours would enable the District to observe STUDENT over time and across different educational situations during his school day. Accordingly, the District may observe STUDENT for three hours at his preschool.

With regard to the request that the preschool observation be without STUDENT’s parents’ presence or interference, this request is granted. As stated above, districts have the discretion to determine how to conduct their assessments and are not required to agree to parentally imposed conditions of assessment. According to the District, the purpose of the observation is to see STUDENT’s progress and behaviors during a normal school day. The PARENTS have not established any reason why they must be present during the observations. Accordingly, the PARENTS are not to be present or to interfere with the observation in any way. The observation by the District in the preschool must be in accordance to the rules of the private preschool regarding observation of its students.

With regard to the home observation, the District may elect to have Ms. Fallon observe the home program. Ms. Fallon has supervised home and school programs for autistic children. She has observed home discrete trial therapy programs for approximately 55-60 children. She has also worked in the state diagnostic school, where she taught autistic children. Accordingly, Ms. Fallon is qualified to perform the observation. Additionally, the observation may be for three hours and shall be without the interference of STUDENT’s parents, for the same reasons set forth above. As the observation will be at STUDENT’s home, his parents are entitled to be present in the home. However, they must maintain a distance from and be out of the view of STUDENT.

The request for an additional person to be present with Ms. Fallon during the observation is denied. The District requests another person to be present in order to “ensure objectivity” as to what is observed during the observation. This request stems from the District’s concern that it and STUDENT’s parents have disagreed regarding events that have occurred in the past few months. Because the second observer is not part of and necessary to the assessment, the request is denied. Aside from STUDENT, STUDENT’s therapist will also be present in the room to confirm what was observed.

Finally, regarding the interviews of the home therapy providers and preschool staff, the District is entitled to interview these persons about STUDENT’s educational needs without the interference or involvement of the PARENTS. The manner of the interview is within the District’s discretion, and the interviews may occur without the presence or participation of the PARENTS. Either Dr. Dores or Ms. Fallon may conduct the interviews.

****

In summary, STUDENT is due for a reevaluation to determine his readiness to transition from preschool to kindergarten. As found above, the observations of STUDENT in the classroom and in-home program and the interviews with STUDENT’s in-home providers and preschool teacher are a necessary part of his reevaluation. On the basis of the above, the District may assess STUDENT despite the withdrawal of parental consent, as delineated below.

ORDER

1. Laguna Beach Unified School District is entitled to perform the observations of STUDENT in his in-home discrete trial therapy program and at his preschool. Additionally, the District may interview STUDENT’s home therapists and supervisor and his preschool staff. The District may utilize Dr. Dores to perform the observation at the preschool, and may utilize Sue Fallon to perform the observation in the home. The observations may be for the duration of three hours each. Either Dr. Dores or Ms. Fallon may conduct the interviews of the home providers and the preschool staff, and those interviews may, at the District’s discretion, be with or without the presence or participation of STUDENT’s parents. The PARENTS are ordered not to interfere with the observations or interviews in any manner and may not be present at the preschool observation. Furthermore, if the PARENTS are present in the home during the home therapy observation, they are ordered to maintain a distance from STUDENT and be at a location out of his view.

2. STUDENT’s parents shall make him reasonably available for the District to conduct the remaining portions of his transitional evaluation.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code ' 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on the issue decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code ' 56505(i).

DATED: August 17, 2001 ____________________________________ Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1. Please note that the Hearing Office has recently changed its format for numbering cases. The case number now begins with the year the case was filed and is followed by a five-digit reference number. 2. As is noted below, STUDENT was last assessed in 1999 when he was two or three years old. The District calls the current evaluation a “transitional evaluation” because STUDENT is now five years old and is at the age where he may transition to kindergarten. 3. The District is also seeking to reevaluate STUDENT’s twin sister. Because the twins receive many of the same educational services, many of their assessments were conducted by the same persons and were scheduled close together in time. Thus, many of the exhibits presented by the parties also reflect limited information about STUDENT’s sister. 4. It is unclear from the record at what point STUDENT was assessed for and provided occupational therapy, speech and language therapy, and adapted physical education consultation. STUDENT was provided vision therapy pursuant to his January 9, 2001 IEP. 5. MOTHER argued that the assessment sought by the District could not be a “triennial assessment” because it has not been three years since the prior 1999 assessment. As discussed below, because the law allows districts to reassess a child whenever “conditions warrant,” the determination as to whether the assessment can be called a triennial assessment is unnecessary to the ultimate resolution of this matter. 6. The Student also alleges that the District’s assessment would also negatively impact STUDENT’s sister. However, the record indicates that STUDENT and his sister are not in the same preschool classroom or in the same room during the home therapy. Thus, it is found that observations of STUDENT would not negatively impact his sister, because she would not be present for the observations. 7. Although MOTHER maintained throughout the hearing that STUDENT’s behaviors declined as a result of the District’s assessment, when given the opportunity to testify, she did not testify with any specificity as to STUDENT’s behaviors. She testified only that the assessments impacted her health by causing her a severe migraine. 8. The PARENTS also allege that Dr. Dores stated to them during the 1999 assessment that STUDENT’s sister’s biggest problem is that she is a “brat.” Because the statement referenced STUDENT’s sister and not STUDENT, and because the statement was allegedly made two years ago, the Hearing Officer finds that this statement would not support the allegation that Dr. Dores is biased regarding STUDENT’s needs. 9. If the Student’s parents disagree with the District’s assessment, they may obtain an independent educational assessment and seek reimbursement for that assessment. However, a District may initiate a due process hearing to show that its assessment is appropriate. If it is determined at the due process hearing that the District’s assessment was appropriate, the parent still has the right to an independent educational assessment, but not at public expense. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).