California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 17, 2001

Laguna Beach Unified School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 996-01 · Hearing Officer Trevor Skarda

Laguna Beach Unified may finish a 5-year-old's triennial assessment with preschool and home observations over parent objection.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Laguna Beach Unified School District filed for due process to finish a triennial assessment of a 5-year-old girl with autism. She attended a private preschool with a shadow aide and received an in-home Applied Behavioral Analysis (ABA) program funded by the District. Her parents first signed the assessment plan on the condition that they be present at all observations. They later withdrew consent, saying the testing was too much and was causing behavior problems. By then, only two pieces were left: observation of the preschool by psychologist Dr. Paul Dores, observation of the home discrete trial program by SELPA coordinator Susan Fallon, and interviews with providers.

The parents argued that the District already had enough information, that both assessors were biased or unqualified, and that more observations would harm their daughter. The Hearing Officer disagreed. California law requires an assessment to include observation in an appropriate setting, and districts may choose their own assessors. Reviewing reports from non-District providers could not replace direct observation. The evidence did not show that Dr. Dores was biased or that the observations caused harm. Other events, such as several tutors quitting, likely contributed to the behavior changes. Ms. Fallon's past role at an earlier program did not disqualify her. The parents offered no reason they needed to attend. The Hearing Officer ordered the parents to allow one preschool observation of up to three hours, one home session of up to four hours, and staff interviews, all without the parents present.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled a parent's withdrawal of consent partway through a reassessment. The Hearing Officer relied on the Education Code requirement to observe the child in an appropriate setting and on the district's right to choose its own assessors. Observations and staff interviews were allowed without the parents present.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1a. Does the District have the right to complete its assessment of Student as follows: May Dr. Paul Dores observe Student in her private school program for up to three hours and interview the preschool staff without Student's parents present?

    Observation in the preschool setting and staff interviews are a necessary part of the triennial assessment; Dr. Dores is qualified and not shown to be biased; he may observe and interview without parents present.

  2. Issue 1b. May Susan Fallon observe Student's in-home discrete trial program for a complete session, up to four hours, and interview the tutors and supervisors without the parents present?

    Observation of the home program is necessary; Ms. Fallon is qualified despite her past role at a prior program; she may observe one full session and interview tutors without parents present.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order that district may assess without consent. Parents ordered to make Student reasonably accessible. Dr. Paul Dores may observe Student at her private preschool for one session, up to three hours, arranged directly with the preschool, with parents not present, and may interview the preschool teachers and shadow aides without parents present.
  • Order that district may assess without consent. Susan Fallon may observe Student's in-home discrete trial program for one complete session of up to four hours, and may interview Student's tutors without parents present, arranging the interviews directly with the tutors.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District (5th Cir. 1995); Vander Malle v. Ambach (2d Cir. 1982); Dubois v. Connecticut State Board of Education (2d Cir. 1984); Amanda J. v. Clark County School District (9th Cir. 2001); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56321, 56322, 56327, 56505

People named in the decision

  • Dr. Paul Dores, licensed clinical psychologist, District-contracted assessor, Autism Partnership (listed on assessment plan)
  • Susan (Sue) Fallon, SELPA coordinator, assessor; former principal of Interagency Assessment Center, SELPA
  • Mary Wuertz, director of special education and student services, Laguna Beach Unified School District
  • Sue Collins, District speech and language specialist, Laguna Beach Unified School District
  • Connie Terranova, occupational therapist, Orange County Therapy
  • Melanie Foshee, speech therapist
  • Dr. Julie Berg Ryan, developmental vision assessor
  • Jessica Postil, service provider (assessor listed in parents' letter)
  • Orange County Therapy, private therapy provider (psycho-motor/OT)
  • Speech Language Connection, private speech-language provider
  • Autism Partnership, private agency associated with Dr. Dores
  • G. Robert Roice, educational advocate for District, Laguna Beach Unified School District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Laguna Beach, California, on July 12 and 13, 2001.

STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by her mother, MOTHER. Also present on behalf of STUDENT at the end of the second day was STUDENT’s father, Dr. FATHER, M.D. The Laguna Beach Unified School District (District) was represented by educational advocate G. Robert Roice. Also present on behalf of the District was Mary Wuertz, the District’s director of special education and student services.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties provided written closing arguments which were received by the Hearing Officer on July 31, 2001. Thereafter, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES(Footnote 2)

1. Does the District have the right to complete its assessment of STUDENT as follows:

a. May Dr. Paul Dores observe STUDENT in her private school program for up to three hours and interview the preschool staff without STUDENT’s parents present?

b. May Susan Fallon observe STUDENT’s in-home discrete trial program for a complete session, up to four hours, and interview the tutors and supervisors without the parents present?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT, age 5, resides within the boundaries of the Laguna Beach Unified School District. At about 24 months of age, she was diagnosed with mild to moderate autism. STUDENT’s twin brother, BROTHER, has also been diagnosed with autism. STUDENT has received special education services from the District since about age three.

In May 1999, the District contracted with Dr. Paul Dores to assess STUDENT. Dr. Dores conducted a record review and observed STUDENT in her private preschool and in her home ABA (Applied Behavioral Analysis) program, as part of the initial assessment. However, because of STUDENT’s age, no tests were administered at that time. As a result of his observation and record review, Dr. Dores recommended a 40-hour-per-week program, including 34 hours per week of ABA at home and a shadow aide in STUDENT’s private preschool program. Testimony of Dores.

In January 2001, at an IEP meeting related to vision therapy, the District informed the PARENTS that “STUDENT was due for a triennial evaluation in May” and that the District would seek the parents’ consent “around 3/1/01.”(Footnote 3) District’s Exh. 4.

In February 2001, the District began the assessment process. On February 20, 2001, Mary Wuertz, the District’s director of special education and student services, sent a letter to Mrs. MOTHER stating that she would request input from the service providers related to the assessment. The letter also requests that the PARENTS provide the District, before March 1, 2001, with any information that they would like to be considered in the development of the assessment plan.(Footnote 4) District’s Exh. 6. Thereafter, on February 21, 2001, Ms. Wuertz sent a letter to all of STUDENT’s services providers requesting information related to STUDENT services. District’s Exh. 7.

On February 22, 2001, Ms. Wuertz sent a letter to Mrs. MOTHER that generally expresses the District’s concerns over restrictions Mrs. MOTHER had placed on observing STUDENT during the current and past school year, including: (1) the District may make only two observations annually, (2) only one District staff member may observe STUDENT at a time, (3) District observations may be made only in the presence of Mrs. MOTHER, (4) District observations are subject to Mrs. MOTHER’s time limitations, and, (5) District staff may not talk to STUDENT’s preschool teacher or director regarding her progress. With regard to Mrs. MOTHER’s refusal to allow the District to talk to the teachers at STUDENT’s preschool, Ms. Wuertz wrote, in pertinent part, as follows:

Most recently (on February 15, 2001), you refused to allow me to contact the preschool staff regarding the development of an assessment plan. Per my phone explanation to you, the information being sought was: (a) current areas of disability apparent in the preschool setting, (b) educational performance, (c) areas of concern that need to be assessed. You refused to allow contact even though I offered to have you included on a conference call when I spoke to the preschool staff. You indicated I could talk, instead, with the aides you hire. However, the preschool teachers have the responsibility for the children’s learning and behavior as well as the functioning of the shadow aides in their classrooms; therefore, the teachers’ input is critical. I am wondering why you don’t want the District to talk to the preschool staff.

District’s Exh. 8.

On March 4, 2001, the District sent a proposed assessment plan to STUDENT’s parents. District’s Exh. 11. The plan includes the following assessments:

Assessment Area Assessor(s)

Academic/Pre-Academic Achievement Special education teacher Social/Adaptive Behavior Dr. Paul Dores/Autism Partnership Psycho-Motor Development Dr. Paul Dores/Orange County Therapy Communication Development District speech therapist/Speech Language Connection Intellectual/Cognitive Development Dr. Paul Dores Health Assessment School Nurse Other [“Observation in all settings where District is funding services”] Dr. Paul Dores Developmental Vision Assessment Dr. Julie Berg Ryan

District’s Exh. 11.

Attached to the proposed assessment plan was a list of the specific tests that were to be administered by each of the assessors. Id. Mrs. MOTHER requested additional information about the purpose of each test “and the information you hope to obtain.” Student’s Exh. K. Ms. Wuertz forwarded the information about the tests to Mrs. MOTHER on March 12, 2001. District’s Exh. 13.

On March 13, 2001, Mrs. MOTHER telephoned Ms. Wuertz and inquired as to who would be observing STUDENT at the preschool. Ms. Wuertz informed Mrs. MOTHER the same day via facsimile that Sue Collins, the District speech and language specialist, and Dr. Paul Dores would “observe in the preschool setting as part of the assessment process.” The facsimile also indicates that “Susan Fallon from the SELPA will also need to observe a second time. She is part of the IEP team and no one else from the District or SELPA has been allowed to observe on more than one occasion.” District’s Exh. 14.

On March 14, 2001, Mrs. MOTHER signed the assessment plan, and wrote on the assessment form that observations of STUDENT must be “with parent present” and that the parents were “to be faxed/mailed reports (written or verbal) at the same time as the [District]. If verbal reports parent to be conference called.” Student’s Exh. R. This was agreed to by the District. Testimony of Wuertz.

Dr. Dores was scheduled to observe STUDENT at her preschool on March 22, 2001. He did not observe STUDENT on that day, and did not notify the PARENTs until late in the day, because he was involved in an IEP meeting that ran long. Testimony of Dores.

On April 2, 2001, Dr. Dores met with Mrs. MOTHER, gathered a history of the children since his previous assessment in 1999, scheduled observations, and agreed upon the testing times. Testimony of Mrs. MOTHER and Dores.

On April 5 and 6, 2001, Dr. Dores observed STUDENT’s vison therapy, occupational therapy, and her private speech therapy. Testimony of Dores. Dr. Dores and Mrs. MOTHER unsuccessfully attempted to reschedule the preschool observation that Dr. Dores had missed on March 22, 2001.(Footnote 5)

On April 10, 2001, Dr. and Mrs. MOTHER wrote a letter to Ms. Wuertz indicating that they were withdrawing their consent “for any further observations and assessment of our children, BROTHER and STUDENT, until such time as you have provided us in writing a list of the specific testing, observations, and number of hours that Dr. Dores or other providers need to do to complete your evaluation.” The reason stated in the letter is that the “requests” for excessive observations and “marathon testing” had caused great distress to STUDENT and her family, and that her “behaviors have escalated including bolting into the street, verbal stimming, non-compliance, insomnia, tantrums, and crying.” The letter also requests the “dates and number of hours of testing already provided by Melanie Foshee, Sue Collins, Jessica Postil, Orange County Therapy (Caroline and Connie), Sue Collings, Dr. Ryan, Dr. Dores.” Student’s Exh. CC. Ms. Wuertz wrote a letter to Mrs. MOTHER on that same day in which she lists the “time requirements for Dr. Paul Dores to complete the assessment” – one full day of observations at the preschool of both STUDENT and her brother, and an observation of STUDENT’s home discrete trial program for “two to three hours.”

On April 13, 2001, Ms. Wuertz sent another letter to Mrs. MOTHER indicating that she was currently seeking the information requested by Mrs. MOTHER regarding the amount of time each provider had spent evaluating STUDENT. The letter also states that only two District employees had observed STUDENT in her preschool program as part of the 2001 assessment (Sue Collins, the speech and language specialist, and Sue Fallon, the SELPA coordinator). It further requests that Dr. Dores be allowed to observe STUDENT’s home and preschool programs. District’s Exh. 22

On April 24, 2001, Ms. Wuertz forwarded to Mrs. MOTHER the information she had gathered from all of the providers regarding observation times. The data tables indicate, in pertinent part, that Susan Fallon, the SELPA coordinator, had observed STUDENT’s preschool program for thirty minutes on January 23, 2001, and that Ms. Fallon would need to observe STUDENT for one additional hour in the preschool setting. District’s Exh. 23. On April 30, 2001, Ms. Wuertz wrote another letter to Mrs. MOTHER requesting dates on which Dr. Dores could observe STUDENT in her home and preschool programs and “permission for the independent assessor, Dr. Paul Dores, to have unrestricted access to the providers and the preschool teachers.” She also requested that Sue Fallon be allowed to observe STUDENT’s preschool program. District’s Exh. 24. Ms. Wuertz sent a similar letter to Mrs. MOTHER on May 4, 2001. That letter also states, in pertinent part, as follows:

You have placed undue restrictions on the assessment process by not allowing adequate observations of the home program, by allowing only limited observations in the preschool setting by district staff . . . . You have also placed undue restrictions on the assessment process by not allowing the District to gather unbiased information from assessors . . . .

District’s Exh. 25.

On May 14, 2001, Ms. Wuertz wrote another letter to Mrs. MOTHER. In that letter, she acknowledges that while Dr. Dores had observed STUDENT during speech therapy, occupational therapy and vision therapy, Dr. Dores had not yet observed STUDENT’s preschool program or her home program. District’s Exh. 26.

All assessments have been completed save for the District’s proposed observations of the preschool program by Dr. Dores and of the home program by Sue Fallon and the service provider interviews. Testimony of Mrs. MOTHER and Ms. Wuertz. The District requested the present due process hearing on May 10, 2001, to obtain consent to assess.

CONTENTIONS

The Student contends that the District has already obtained sufficient information to conduct an IEP meeting and that no further observations are needed. Additionally, the Student contends that Dr. Paul Dores is not qualified to assess STUDENT’s preschool program because he is biased. The Student similarly contends that Sue Fallon is not appropriately qualified to assess STUDENT because of her relationship with a previous program that was discontinued.(Footnote 6) Finally, the Student argues that there have already been too many assessments, and one additional assessment in the home and in the preschool setting will harm STUDENT.

The District contends that it has an obligation to assess STUDENT, including observations and interviews of the service providers in the home and preschool, without interference from STUDENT’s parents.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Does the District have the right to complete its assessment of STUDENT as follows:

a. May Dr. Paul Dores observe STUDENT in her private school program for up to three hours and interview the preschool staff without STUDENT’s parents present?

b. May Susan Fallon observe STUDENT’s in-home discrete trial program for a complete session, up to four hours, and interview the tutors and supervisors without the parents present?

As developed above, the issue for hearing involves the question of whether the District may complete the assessment it developed, and largely completed, during the spring of 2001. The PARENTS initially agreed to the assessment plan, but later revoked their consent. The only portions of the assessment which have not been completed are the observations of the preschool program and the home program, along with teacher/instructor and director interviews.

The law provides that no assessment of a student shall be conducted by a school district without first obtaining written consent of the parent, unless the district establishes the need to conduct such an assessment at a due process hearing. California Educ. Code §§ 56321(a), 56505(e). Pursuant to California Education Code § 56322, the “assessment shall be conducted by persons competent to perform the assessment, as determined by the school district, county office, or special education local plan area.” The assessment report must include, in part, “the relevant behavior noted during the observation of the pupil in an appropriate setting.” California Educ. Code § 56327(b). [Emphasis added]. With regard to the personnel selected to assess the student, the courts have consistently affirmed a district's right to choose who it wishes to conduct an assessment. See: Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District (5th Cir. 1995) 64 F. 3d 176, 178 [no exception to the rule that a school district has the right to reevaluate a student using its own personnel]; Vander Malle v. Ambach (2nd Cir. 1982) 673 F.2d 49, 53 [the school is entitled to have student examined by qualified psychiatrist of their choosing]; Dubois v. Connecticut State Board of Education (2nd Cir. 1984) 727 F. 2d 44, 47 [school system may insist on evaluation by qualified professionals who are satisfactory to them].

It was not seriously disputed that STUDENT requires an assessment; indeed, the bulk of the agreed-upon assessment has already been completed. It was also not disputed that STUDENT’s parents no longer consent to the remaining portions of the District’s assessment plan, including the observations of Dr. Dores and Sue Fallon at the preschool and home programs, and the provider interviews. The central dispute is whether the observations of STUDENT in her home and preschool programs, and the interviews of the service providers in both environments, are an appropriate part of an assessment for STUDENT.

As discussed above, an appropriate assessment report must include relevant behavior observations in appropriate settings. California Educ. Code § 56327(b). It must also include a statement of the relationship of the behavior to the student’s academic and social functioning. California Educ. Code § 56327 (c). In the present case, the weight of the evidence established that observations of STUDENT in the home and preschool by Sue Fallon and Dr. Dores, respectively, as well as interviews with the service providers, are an appropriate part of the assessment for STUDENT. Dr. Dores, a licensed clinical psychologist specializing in developmental disorders, has worked in the area of autism for approximately 30 years. He presented as an excellent witness. Dr. Dores testified persuasively that observations of both the home and preschool program are necessary to gain an overall picture of how STUDENT is functioning in her home and preschool programs. He explained that examining data collected by other people is not an adequate substitute for direct observations. Dr. Dores further explained that it is necessary to observe an autistic child in order to see a variety of activities in different environments -- this allows the assessor to get an overall picture of how the child is functioning. He also testified that reviewing progress reports and discrete trial data books is not an adequate substitute for direct observations.(Footnote 7) Finally, Dr. Dores and Ms. Wuertz testified generally that interviews with all of the service providers are needed to obtain an overall picture of STUDENT’s current functioning and the appropriateness of her current program.

The Student argues that the observations are not necessary because the information can be obtained by the service providers, almost all of whom are not District employees.(Footnote 8) In other words, the PARENTS argue that the District should simply rely on the information that the shadow aides, preschool teachers and the home program providers relay at the IEP meeting, in lieu of formal observations by Dr. Dores and Sue Fallon. The Student’s argument is unavailing. As discussed above, the California Education Code requires that any assessment include observations of STUDENT in the appropriate settings. Here, the appropriate settings are where STUDENT receives the bulk of her special education services – the home program and the preschool program. The law also provides that the District may choose the assessors. Requiring the District to rely simply on the observations of the non-district service providers circumvents the District’s right to have its own personnel observe STUDENT.(Footnote 9)

The Student also argues that the observations will harm STUDENT. In support, Dr. FATHER testified that he witnessed increased negative behaviors about the time that STUDENT was being assessed by the District. Mrs. MOTHER testified that STUDENT was “out of control” after one of the therapy sessions observed by Dr. Dores. Dr. Dores testified that he tested STUDENT for approximately 60 minutes and observed STUDENT during occupational therapy, vision therapy and speech therapy. He did not witness STUDENT exhibit negative behavior because of his presence during the various therapy sessions or during his testing. Connie Terranova, an occupational therapist, and Melanie Foshee, a speech therapist, both testified generally that they did not witness increased behaviors while Dr. Dores observed their therapy sessions. There was also testimony that about the time of the increased behaviors, several of STUDENT’s tutors had unexpectedly quit.(Footnote 10) The loss of several long-term tutors undoubtedly contributed to STUDENT’s increased behavioral problems reported by her parents. The Hearing Officer finds that there is insufficient evidence supporting the Student’s contention that the necessary assessments -- two observations by District personnel, will harm STUDENT. The parents argument is not persuasive.

The Student argues further that Dr. Dores is not qualified to assess STUDENT because he is biased.(Footnote 11) In support, the student argues that Dr. Dores stated in 1999 that discrete trial training programs typically last only two years. Thus, the Student argues, Dr. Dores has predetermined what his recommendation to the IEP team will be -- that STUDENT’s discrete trial training program should end. Dr. Dores testified that he could not recall making this statement. He also testified that his recommendations would be based on his assessment, including his observation of STUDENT in the preschool setting, and were not predetermined. The Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Dores was the individual who recommended STUDENT’s current program based on his assessment in 1999. The Hearing Officer finds, based on the weight of the evidence, specifically, the testimony of Dr. Dores, that he is not biased and has not predetermined an outcome.(Footnote 12) Moreover, as discussed above, Dr. Dores is a licensed clinical psychologist with substantial experience assessing autistic children. As such, he is appropriately qualified to assess STUDENT.

The Student generally argues that Sue Fallon, the current SELPA coordinator, is not qualified to observe STUDENT in her home program because she was employed as the principal of Interagency Assessment Center (IAC) at the same period of time that STUDENT attended the IAC and STUDENT’s “autism was exacerbated.” The Student’s argument is unavailing. There was no evidence linking the purported failure of the IAC program to Sue Fallon’s qualifications to assess STUDENT. There was evidence, on the contrary, that Sue Fallon has significant experience working with autistic children both as a teacher and an administrator. Sue Fallon is qualified to assess STUDENT.

The remaining question is whether the District may conduct its preschool observation, as well as all of the service provider interviews, without the parents being present. The District presented evidence that Mrs. MOTHER interfered with an observation of a clinic meeting for STUDENT.(Footnote 13) Furthermore, Ms. Wuertz testified generally that, in order to assure candid responses from the interviewees, it would be necessary to interview the service providers without Mrs. MOTHER being present. The Student failed to present evidence or explain why the parents presence is required during Dr. Dores’ preschool observation, or during any of the interviews. As such, the Hearing Officer finds that the District may conduct the preschool observation and all of the service provider interviews without the parents being present.

In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the observations and interviews requested by the District are necessary, and the proposed assessors – Dr. Dores and Sue Fallon – are appropriately qualified. Additionally, the District may conduct its preschool observation and service provider interviews outside the presence of the parents.

ORDER

1. The PARENTS are ordered to make STUDENT reasonably accessible so that the District may complete its assessment of STUDENT as follows:

a. Dr. Paul Dores is authorized to observe STUDENT at her private preschool for one session, up to three hours. Dr. Dores will arrange the observation directly with STUDENT’s preschool. STUDENT’s parents shall not be present during the observation.

b. Dr. Paul Dores may interview STUDENT’s private preschool teachers and shadow aides without STUDENT’s parents being present. Dr. Dores will arrange the interviews directly with the teachers and aides.

c. Susan Fallon is authorized to observe STUDENT’s in-home discrete trial program for one complete session, which may last up to four hours.

d. Susan Fallon may interview STUDENT’s tutors without STUDENT’s parents being present. Susan Fallon will arrange the interviews directly with the tutors.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The Petitioner prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

DATED: August 17, 2001 _____________________________________ Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. Please note that the Hearing Office has recently changed its format for numbering cases. The case number now begins with the year the case was filed and is followed by a five-digit reference number. 2. The issues differ slightly from those noticed by the District prior to the hearing. Changes were made to reflect the discussion held at the beginning of the hearing and for purposes of clarity. 3. The January 2001 IEP also indicates that STUDENT’s mother requested a “psychological” assessment at the meeting. 4. Ms. Wuertz attached an agenda for the post-assessment IEP, scheduled for April 30, 2001. 5. Mrs. MOTHER’s account of the discussions regarding rescheduling of the preschool observation differed substantially from that of Dr. Dores. For instance, according to Mrs. MOTHER, three different observation dates (April 10, 12 and 18) were scheduled in early April, but Dr. Dores “canceled” each one. Testimony of Mrs. MOTHER. According to Dr. Dores, the April 10 date was not agreed upon, the April 12 date was restricted in length due to an Easter party at the preschool and therefore was not a viable date, and the April 18 date was not offered. District’s Exh. 28. Dr. Dores also testified that he tried to schedule several dates in early April with Mrs. MOTHER and each date was declined because someone else was visiting on that same date or the observation would be “too intrusive.” Id. 6. The Student submitted a sixty-four page, single-spaced closing statement. The document is replete with alleged facts which were not part of the record and were therefore not considered in reaching this decision. 7. The characteristics that differentiate autism from other developmental disorders include “behavioral deficits in eye contact, orienting one’s name, joint attention behaviors (e.g., pointing, showing), pretend play, imitation, nonverbal communication, and language development.” See, Amanda J. v. Clark County School District (9th Cir. 2001) ---F.3d. ---, 2001 WL 902125. These behavioral characteristics are best assessed through direct observation by a qualified professional. 8. Sue Collins has observed STUDENT as part of her speech and language assessment. Additionally, as noted above, Sue Fallon briefly observed STUDENT’s preschool program in January 2001. Other than those two observations, the District has not directly observed STUDENT in her home or school programs. 9. The Student makes the related argument that the observations of the vision therapist, private speech therapist and occupational therapist are sufficient and Dr. Dores’ and Sue Fallon’s observations are therefore not necessary. This argument is also not persuasive. Those individuals are not District personnel. Moreover, the above individuals assessed STUDENT in their specific areas of expertise. Dr. Dores and Sue Fallon seek to assess STUDENT’s overall functioning and psychoeducational needs 10. . MOTHER argued that they quit because of the excessive testing. The Student submitted two resignation letters from tutors who quit about this time. Neither resignation letter mentions the reason for the resignation, and neither tutor testified at the hearing. 11. It was not seriously disputed that Dr. Dores has the appropriate qualifications as a clinical psychologist specializing in the field of autism to conduct a psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT. 12. The Student also argued that Dr. Dores is “unprofessional” and that he has divulged “confidential information” to third parties and, on that basis, he is not qualified. The Student argued further that Dr. Dores is biased because, essentially, the District is paying him for his services. These arguments were similarly not supported by persuasive evidence. 13. Mrs. MOTHER admitted that she answered a question at a clinic meeting that Dr. Dores had posed to one of therapists at the clinic meeting. She explained in her closing brief that she answered the question because she was trying to “clarify” the information sought by Dr. Dores from the therapist.