California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 25, 1999
San Francisco Unified School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 1340-98 · Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait
San Francisco Unified may place a fifth grader with a learning disability in a special day class and reassess him without guardian consent.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
San Francisco Unified School District filed for a hearing after the student's guardian refused a special day class placement, withdrew consent for all special education services and refused a triennial reassessment. The student was a fifth grader eligible for special education under specific learning disability. He had been in a special day class briefly in 1996-97. At the guardian's request, he then moved to a regular class with resource specialist and speech services. The guardian did not attend the hearing. She asked the Hearing Officer to dismiss the case, calling the District's contacts harassment. The Hearing Officer denied that request. He found that state law allows a district to request a hearing when a parent refuses a proposed program or an assessment.
On the merits, the District won every issue. The resource specialist, the speech-language pathologist, the regular teacher (Susan Clark) and the principal all testified that the student kept falling behind in a class of more than 30 students, even with resource help. The Hearing Officer held that the program in the November 1997 and March 1998 IEPs met the student's needs and was designed to provide educational benefit. He held that Michael Paurowski's small learning disability special day class at Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary was an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment. He ordered the District to implement the program right away and to hold an IEP meeting within 30 days to review the goals. He also allowed the District to reassess the student, including in communication development.
Why it matters
This case shows how SEHO handled a district-filed case when a guardian refused both services and reassessment and did not attend the hearing. The Hearing Officer relied on the student's lack of progress in a regular class with resource support to approve a special day class placement over the guardian's objection.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedDistrict-filed: implement IEP
Issue 1. Is the District's proposed program for STUDENT appropriate and should it be implemented?
The Hearing Officer held that the program in the November 1997 and March 1998 IEPs met the student's unique needs and was designed to provide educational benefit under Rowley. The student kept losing ground in a regular class, with or without resource specialist help. The program may be implemented, but the goals should be reviewed.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 2. Should STUDENT be placed in the special day class of Mr. Michael Paurowski at the Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary School?
The student could not make progress in a regular class even with supplementary services. Mr. Paurowski's small, structured, multi-sensory learning disability special day class, which has 13 students, a teacher and three aides, was an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment.
- District prevailedDistrict-filed: assess without consent
Issue 3. Should the District be allowed to perform a triennial assessment of STUDENT?
The student's triennial reassessment was due by spring 1999, and nothing in the record supported the guardian's refusal. The District may assess in all areas of its assessment plan, plus communication development as the District agreed at hearing.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district's offer may be implemented. The District shall immediately implement its proposed program as set out in the IEPs of March 13, 1998 and "December 18, 1997". The intended date is likely November 18, 1997.
- Placement ordered. The District shall immediately place the student in Mr. Paurowski's special day class at Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary School.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. The District shall hold an IEP meeting to review the student's goals and objectives within 30 days of his placement in Mr. Paurowski's class.
- Order that district may assess without consent. The District shall reassess the student in the areas listed in its assessment plan dated January 19, 1999 (cognitive development/thinking strategies, motor/perceptual development, social/emotional/adaptive behavior, educational/academic), and also in communication development.
Key authorities
Rowley; Education Code section 56346; Education Code section 56501; Education Code section 56381
People named in the decision
- Michael J. Paurowski, special day class teacher (proposed placement), Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary School, San Francisco Unified School District
- Susan Clark, regular fifth grade teacher, Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary School, San Francisco Unified School District
- Margaret Englesbe, resource specialist, San Francisco Unified School District
- Laura Keenan, speech-language pathologist, San Francisco Unified School District
- Katharine McCauley, counsel for District, San Francisco Unified School District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
Case Number: SN 1340-98 Case Year: 1998 Petitioner: SAN FRANCISCO UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT Issue: Assessment Placement CDS Code: 38-68478 District: San Francisco Unified Disability Type: Specific Learning Disability
Case Details This matter came on for hearing on January 21 and February 25, 1999, in San Francisco, California, before Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law.. Petitioner San Francisco Unified School District was represented by Katharine McCauley. Respondent STUDENT did not appear at the hearing and was not represented during the hearing. The hearing began on January 21, l999, without the appearance of Respondent. The hearing was continued to February 25, l999, so that Petitioner could provide additional notice of the issues to be heard and the placement recommended for STUDENT. The hearing was also continued in order to make additional efforts to encourage STUDENT'S's guardian to attend the hearing. STUDENT's guardian, notified the Special Education Hearing Office on February 18, 1999, that she would not attend the hearing. On February 22, l999, the Special Education Hearing Office received a letter from GUARDIAN requesting that the case be dismissed.That request was denied, as discussed below under Procedural Matters. On February 25, l999, the hearing proceeded without GUARDIAN in attendance. Oral and documentary evidence was received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision. ISSUES 1. Is the District's proposed program for STUDENT appropriate and should it be implemented? 2. Should STUDENT be placed in the special day class of Mr. Michael Paurowski at the Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary School? 3. Should the District be allowed to perform a triennial assessment of STUDENT? PROCEDURAL MATTERS On February 18, l999, STUDENT's guardian wrote to the Special Education Hearing Office stating that she did not want STUDENT placed in special education programs and asking that the District's request for hearing be dismissed. She stated that "the incessant letters, meeting, and phone calls have not only taken a toll on my nephew's state of mind, but truthfully speaking I feel that it has also bordered on emotional harassment. I would like it to stop." Education Code Section 56340 provides: Each district, special education local plan area or county office shall initiate and conduct meetings for the purposes of developing, reviewing, and revising the individualized education program of each individual with exceptional needs. In this case, the District conducted a number of IEP meetings to formulate an appropriate program for STUDENT, who had been determined to be an individual with exceptional needs. During those meetings, the District proposed placement of STUDENT in a special day class for the learning disabled. District personnel believed that such a placement would be the appropriate setting for addressing STUDENT's significant needs. Far from harassment, these meetings, letters and phone calls were a reflection of the District's intent to serve STUDENT and to comply with the State and federal laws concerning the education of disabled students. Education Code Section 56346 requires a district to request a hearing if it determines that the program it proposes is necessary to provide a free and appropriate public education to the pupil where a parent has refused to consent to the program. Section 56346 also provides that when such a hearing is conducted, the hearing officer's decision is final and binding on all parties. Education Code Section 56501 provides that a hearing can be initiated when: (1) There is a proposal to initiate or change the identification, assessment, or educational placement of the child or the provision of a free appropriate public education to the child. (2) There is a refusal to initiate or change the identification, assessment, or educational placement of the child or the provision of a free appropriate public education to the child. (3) The parent refuses to consent to an assessment of the child. In this case, STUDENT's guardian not only refused to allow the placement of STUDENT in a special day class, but also refused to allow the provision of any special education services to STUDENT. She also refused to allow STUDENT to be assessed. Therefore, the request by the District for a hearing relating to STUDENT's placement, program and assessment is in accordance with the law and should not be dismissed. STUDENT's guardian's request to dismiss the hearing is denied. BACKGROUND FACTS STUDENT will turn eleven years old in March 1999. He is currently attending the regular fifth grade class taught by Ms. Susan Clark at the Robert Louis Stevenson elementary school and, at the insistence of his guardian, is not receiving special education services. From the beginning of his schooling, STUDENT has failed to develop his skills at the same rate as his peers. In June of l994, after a full year of kindergarten, STUDENT was not able to write his name. He repeated kindergarten and was conditionally promoted to first grade. During the l995-96 year, while STUDENT was enrolled in second grade, a student study team was convened to review his progress. In the Spring of l996, STUDENT was referred for an assessment because of his poor academic achievement. The assessment, dated May 13, l996, concluded that even though STUDENT had average cognitive abilities, his academic achievement was two to three years below his current grade placement. He was determined to have "a specific learning disability as reflected in the psychological processes of sensory motor integration." The assessment concluded that STUDENT was eligible for special education services and recommended that he be placed in a special day class. An IEP meeting was held on September 12, l996, to review the assessment of STUDENT. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT was eligible for special education services and developed a specific plan for his educational program. It included goals and short-term objectives in the areas of sensory-motor integration, reading skills, math skills, and expressive and receptive language. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT be placed in a special day class and that he receive sixty minutes of speech and language services each week. The IEP team agreed that he would be integrated with regular students for physical education, recesses, school assemblies and "other as appropriate." STUDENT's guardian approved the September 12, l996 IEP. At the beginning of the l996-97 school year, STUDENT was placed in a special day class at the Lawton Elementary School. In January l997, STUDENT's guardian requested that STUDENT be removed from the special day class and placed in a regular third grade class. The IEP was revised on January 1, l997, to implement this request. STUDENT's special day class teacher objected to STUDENT's placement in a regular class, stating: "I do not agree with the decision to demit STUDENT from special education due to significant delays in academic areas. His current placement is an appropriate setting." In February l997, STUDENT transferred from Lawton Elementary School to Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary School. He was placed in a regular third grade class. An IEP meeting was conducted on May 6, l997, during which it was agreed that STUDENT would receive resource specialist services for 200 to 300 minutes per week and speech and language services for 60 minutes per week. District personnel believed that a special day class was the appropriate placement but agreed to provide resource specialist services rather than have him receive no special education support. STUDENT's guardian agreed to the new IEP, which also contained new goals and objectives. The IEP provided that STUDENT's progress would be reviewed in November l997. The IEP team next met on November 18, l997, to review STUDENT's progress. The team concluded that STUDENT was not making adequate progress in the resource specialist program. Achievement testing performed prior to the IEP demonstrated that while STUDENT had made progress in reading he was still one to two years behind grade level. The testing also showed that he was still performing at the first grade level in spelling and math. A review of STUDENT's progress on his goals and objectives revealed that he had completed 100% of the goal related to decoding and 75% of the goal relating to vocabulary and fluency. The IEP team formulated a new goal to improve reading comprehension. STUDENT had made no progress toward meeting the written language goal. The IEP team developed two new written language goals in the areas of composition and editing skills. STUDENT had met 70% of one math computation goal and had made no progress on the other computation goal. The IEP team continued the math goal on which he had not made progress and added a new goal relating to money skills. The team also approved a goal to improve language skills with four short-term objectives. The IEP developed on November 18, l997, continued speech and language services twice a week for a total of 60 minutes. The team determined that while STUDENT was a friendly and kind young student, "he struggles to work independently and has a tendency to wander off into fantasy play. It is also difficult for him to work in groups and to assume responsibility for tasks." The District members of the IEP team concluded that STUDENT could not make appropriate progress while placed in a regular class with over 30 other students. The IEP team concluded that he needed small-group instruction with a small teacher-student ratio with lots of opportunity for one-to-one attention. The team believed that STUDENT should be returned to a special day class setting in order to achieve necessary progress. Because STUDENT's guardian refused to approve the November 18, l997 IEP, the District continued to provide the program called for in his prior IEP, including resource specialist and speech and language services. STUDENT's IEP team met again on March 14, l998, in an attempt to reach agreement with STUDENT's guardian. District members of the team again strongly urged STUDENT's guardian to agree to placing STUDENT in a special day class. The IEP team also further refined the description of activities in which STUDENT would participate with his nondisabled peers. These included physical education, electives for 30 minutes per day, lunch, and school assemblies. STUDENT's guardian again refused to sign the IEP and STUDENT continued to receive the services provided for in the May 6, l997 IEP. STUDENT was enrolled in a regular fifth grade class in August l998, with continued resource specialist and speech and language services. On September 17, l998, STUDENT's guardian requested that all special education services be discontinued. The District discontinued the resource specialist and speech and language services but continued to encourage STUDENT's guardian to visit special day classes and consider placing him in one of them. On September 21, l998, the District filed a request for a hearing to determine the appropriate program and placement for STUDENT and to request a reassessment of him. On January 22, l999, the District sent a letter to STUDENT's guardian proposing Mr. Paurowski's special day class at Robert Louis Stevenson as an appropriate placement for STUDENT and requesting her approval of a triennial assessment of STUDENT. A copy of the assessment plan was enclosed with the letter. The assessment plan provided for assessment of STUDENT in the following areas: cognitive development/thinking strategies, motor/perceptual development, social/emotional/adaptive behavior, and educational/academic. STUDENT's guardian did not approve the placement or the assessment plan. LEGAL ANALYSIS 1. Is the District's proposed program for STUDENT appropriate and should it be implemented? Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) as amended in 1997, children with disabilities are entitled to receive a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) with special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs. 20 U.S.C. 1401 (8) (A-D) & 1401 (25). A FAPE must be provided in conformity with the child's individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. 1401 (8) (D). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. 458 U.S. 175, 200. To determine whether the program proposed by the District for STUDENT was appropriate, it is necessary to address two issues: Was the proposed program designed to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs? Was the proposed program designed to provide educational benefit? Was the District's proposed program designed to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs? The IEP dated March 13, l998, is a continuation of the IEP of November 18, l997. During the November 18, l997 meeting, the IEP team reviewed the assessment done by the District in the spring of l996, which concluded that there was a significant discrepancy between STUDENT's ability and his academic performance. (The l996 assessment concluded that STUDENT was two to three years below his grade level in all areas of academic testing.) Based upon that assessment and the observations of the team members, it was concluded that STUDENT was eligible for special education because of his learning disability. Also reviewed at the November meeting was other, more recent testing which demonstrated some progress in reading recognition. He performed at a third grade level, although this was still one year below his grade level. The team also reviewed STUDENT's performance during the first quarter of the l997- 98 school year. His teacher had graded him "needing improvement" in the areas of reading, written language, listening and speaking, social science and mathematics. His regular classroom teacher had noted the "STUDENT's difficulties with organization and focus cause difficulties in a class of this size (32)." The IEP team considered STUDENT's progress on the goals and objectives that had been drafted in May l997. They found that he had met his objectives in decoding and had partially met his goals in vocabulary and fluency and one of his math goals. He had failed to meet his short- term objectives in another math goal and in composition skills. The IEP team developed new goals and objectives in the areas of reading comprehension, written language composition, editing skills and math skills and retained one of the math goals from the May l997 IEP. The team also provided for continued speech and language services for a total of sixty minutes per week. The IEP provided that STUDENT would participate in physical education, assemblies and lunch with his nondisabled peers. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT could not make sufficient progress in a regular class of 30 or more students even if he received resource specialist services. The team concluded that he should be in a small special day class with a low student-teacher ratio and the opportunity for much one-to-one attention. STUDENT's guardian attended the November 18, l997 IEP meeting, but refused to approve the program. All of the witnesses during the hearing concluded that the program proposed by the District in November l997 and March 1998, is appropriate for STUDENT and addresses his unique and individual needs. The principal of the Robert Louis Stevenson school testified that STUDENT needs far more than resource specialist services. He needs a structured, small-group environment with lots of opportunity for one-to-one assistance. Margaret Englesbe, the resource specialist who provided services to STUDENT, testified that she did not believe that resource specialist services is enough to address STUDENT's significant needs. Laura Keenan, the speech and language pathologist who worked with STUDENT, testified that STUDENT needs daily small-group instruction with the lessons broken down into small pieces and lots of repetition. Susan Clark, STUDENT's regular education teacher, testified that STUDENT's needs are many and that he can succeed if he has enough one-on-one attention. Michael J. Paurowski has reviewed STUDENT's IEP and believes that his special day class can accommodate STUDENT's needs. He did note that the goals and objectives were formulated over a year ago and that it would be appropriate to review those goals sometime after STUDENT enrolls in Mr. Paurowski's class. All of the evidence supports the conclusion that the the District's proposed program was designed to meet STUDENT's unique individual needs, although STUDENT's goals and objectives should be reviewed to determine whether they are still appropriate for STUDENT given the time that has elapsed since they were developed. Was the District's proposed program designed to provide educational benefit? In this case, the principal disagreement between the District and STUDENT's guardian is whether STUDENT can make progress in a regular class, with or without resource specialist services, or whether STUDENT needs a small special day class setting in order to achieve academic progress. Therefore, it is appropriate to review STUDENT's progress in the regular class, without resource specialist support and with such support. Since STUDENT's guardian did not approve the November
1997 IEP, the District continued to provide resource specialist and speech and language services during the l997-98 school year. On March 13, l998, the IEP team met again to review STUDENT's progress. His report card for the second quarter of the l997-98 year reflected continuing academic difficulties. His teacher stated in the report card that "STUDENT continues to require one-to-one supervision in order to complete most assignments." The IEP team again proposed placing STUDENT in a special day class. STUDENT's guardian again refused to agree. By the end of the l997-98 school year, STUDENT was falling further behind. In his report card for the fourth quarter, his teacher noted, "STUDENT's difficulty in keeping up with the 4th grade curriculum has increased as the year has progressed." During the l998-99 school year, no special education services were provided because STUDENT's guardian had withdrawn consent. During the first two quarters of this year, STUDENT has continued to lose ground. By the end of the second period, STUDENT's report card reflected that he needed improvement in all academic areas. His teacher wrote that "the spark STUDENT demonstrated first quarter is fading rapidly. He seems to be struggling with his daily assignments in all areas." During the hearing, all of the witnesses for District testified that STUDENT could not make appropriate progress in a regular class with over 30 other students. Even with resource specialist services, he continued to lose ground. All agreed that what STUDENT needed was a small class with a small teacher-student ratio and lots of one-to-one instruction. They agreed that STUDENT should have a multi-sensory program with lots of repetition. Based on this evidence, it is concluded that the District's proposed program for STUDENT as set out in the IEPs dated March 13, l998, and November 18, l997, which provides for placement in a special day class which can provide a small class with a small teacher-student ratio, lots of one-to-one instruction, a multi-sensory program, with lots of repetition, is designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT. Because the District's proposed program for STUDENT is designed to meet his unique and individual needs and is likely to provide educational benefit it is concluded that the District's program is appropriate and should be implemented by the District. 2. Should STUDENT be placed in the special day class of Mr. Michael Paurowski at the Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary School? Federal law provides that: To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular educational environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. Section 1212(a)(5)(A). As concluded above, the appropriate placement for STUDENT is a small special class with a low teacher- to-student ratio and much one-to-one instruction. STUDENT was not able to make appropriate progress in a regular class with or without resource specialist services. All of the witnesses at the hearing testified that a special day class for the learning disabled was the appropriate placement for STUDENT in the least restrictive environment. STUDENT's IEP does provide for him to participate in physical education, recess, assemblies, lunch and electives with his non-disabled peers. However, the evidence supports his need for a small, structured class to address all of his academic needs. Mr. Paurowski's special day class at Robert Louis Stevenson School has all of the attributes called for by STUDENT's IEP. His class is a combined third-through-fifth-grade class for the learning disabled. There are 13 students with the teacher, Mr. Paurowski, and three adult aides. Mr. Paurowski testified that he designs each student's program to accomplish the program set out in the student's IEP. He testified that he had reviewed STUDENT's IEP and believed that he could provide STUDENT's program in his class. He said that STUDENT's goals and objectives are similar to those of many of his other students. He said that his class is highly structured and that there is much opportunity for one-to-one instruction. He uses a multi-sensory approach with lots of repetition. Mr. Paurowski said that STUDENT's guardian had visited his class and told him that she was impressed with the classroom and the work being done. Mr. Paurowski further testified that it is crucial that STUDENT begin receiving appropriate instructional services before he moves to middle school next year. The Hearing Officer was impressed with Mr. Paurowski's experience, skill, and dedication. Based upon the evidence presented during the hearing, especially the testimony of Mr. Paurowski, it is concluded that Mr. Paurowski's class is a proper setting to implement STUDENT's IEP and, therefore, would be an appropriate placement for STUDENT. 3. Should the District be allowed to perform the triennial assessment of STUDENT? California Education Code Section 56381 provides that a reassessment of a pupil must be conducted at least every three years. In this case, STUDENT was last assessed in the Spring of l996. Therefore, a reassessment is required by the spring of l999. The District sent STUDENT's guardian an assessment plan as required by Section 56321 of the Education Code. It proposed to assess STUDENT in the areas of cognitive development, motor/perceptual development, social/emotional/adaptive behavior, and educational/academic. The assessment plan did not provide for assessment in the area of communication development. During the hearing, the District stipulated that STUDENT should also be assessed in this area, given his past need for speech and language services. STUDENT's guardian did not consent to the reassessment. Education Code section 56501 specifically provides that a hearing may be requested by a District if a parent refuses to consent to an assessment of a child. STUDENT's guardian did not attend the hearing or explain why she has refused to consent to STUDENT's reassessment. There is no evidence in the record of the hearing which would support her refusal to agree to the triennial reassessment. Therefore, it is concluded that the District should be allowed to perform an assessment of STUDENT in all areas set out in the assessment plan and in the area of communication development. ORDER 1. The District shall immediately implement its proposed program as set out in the IEP's of March 13, l998, and December 18, 1997. 2. The District shall immediately place STUDENT in Mr. Paurowski's special day class at the Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary School. 3. The District shall convene an IEP meeting to review STUDENT's goals and objectives within 30 days of STUDENT's placement in Mr. Paurowski's class. 4. The District shall perform a reassessment of STUDENT in the areas set out in its assessment plan dated January 19, 1999, and, in addition, will perform an assessment in the area of communication development. PREVAILING PARTY Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: The District prevailed on all issues. RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of the receipt of this decision. Education Code section 56505(I). Dated: Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnotes
