California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 18, 2001

Torrance Unified School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 686-01 · Hearing Officer Joseph T. Macaluso

Torrance Unified may move student to a special day class and make a mental health referral, but its transitional offer denied FAPE.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 4 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Torrance Unified School District filed for due process to move a nine-year-old third grader from general education with resource specialist help to a special day class (SDC). The student was eligible for special education due to an emotional disturbance. The District also asked to refer him to the Los Angeles County Department of Mental Health without his father's consent. The father had missed a series of IEP meetings and did not sign the January 25, 2001 IEP. He did not appear at the hearing. The Hearing Officer denied his requests for a continuance and for recusal for lack of good cause.

Applying the four-factor Rachel H. test, the Hearing Officer found that the student was earning D's and F's despite average ability. Resource help and school counseling were not working, and his fights and verbal aggression disrupted classmates. The District won the first two issues: the student could be removed from general education, and he needed an SDC. But the District lost on its actual offer. The IEP would have kept him in general education, with even less resource help, for two to three weeks while staff designed an SDC program. The Hearing Officer held this "transitional placement" did not meet his needs. The District won on the mental health referral. The IEP team had to meet within 30 days to build an SDC program with set elements, including one adult for every seven students, a class of no more than 15, a shadow aide, and a daily counseling plan. The District had 14 days to make the referral.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO handled a district-filed placement case when the parent did not appear. The District proved the student needed a special day class. Its offer still failed because it kept him, with fewer services, in the setting its own witnesses said was not working while staff planned the new program.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. Is the nature and severity of Student's disability sufficient to remove him from the general education environment?

    Applying the Rachel H. factors, the Hearing Officer found the student received little academic or non-academic benefit in general education with supports and had a negative effect on teachers and peers, so removal was appropriate.

  2. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2. Does Student require placement in a special day class (SDC) to receive a free and appropriate public education (FAPE)?

    The evidence showed the student needs an SDC to receive FAPE, but because the District offered no specific SDC program, the Hearing Officer set out the elements an appropriate SDC placement must contain.

  3. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 3. If Student requires an SDC placement, does the District's proposed "transitional placement" from a regular education class with services to an SDC provide Student with FAPE?

    The January 25, 2001 IEP was procedurally proper even though held without the father after repeated notices, but its transitional plan kept the student in general education with fewer resource services and repeated goals and strategies that had already failed, so it did not meet his unique needs or offer FAPE.

  4. Issue 4. Should Student be evaluated for mental health services pursuant to California Government Code § 7576(b)?

    The student met the Government Code § 7576(b) criteria, and school counseling had not met his needs, so the District may refer him to the county Department of Mental Health for assessment without the father's consent.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. IEP team to meet within 30 days of the order to prepare an SDC IEP with goals and objectives for the 2001-2002 school year through January 25, 2002; placement to be in place before the student begins the "2001-2001" school year (likely meaning 2001-2002).
  • Placement ordered. SDC placement must include: a teacher with the skills and knowledge to meet the student's needs; no more than 1 adult per 7 students and a maximum class size of 15; an individualized emotional/behavioral program with daily prompts, cues and rewards and an aide shadowing the student during all non-structured time; an individualized academic program with goals in math, science, English, reading, writing, social studies, art and physical education, presented in small increments; daily positive reinforcement strategies; and a counseling plan with the school psychologist and counselor to meet daily emotional needs.
  • Order that district may assess without consent. District to refer the student to the Los Angeles County Department of Mental Health for an assessment of need for mental health services within 14 calendar days; father to make the student available to DMH and the District for the assessment.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H. (Holland); Union School Dist. v. Smith; Seattle School Dist. v. B.S.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Cal. Gov. Code § 7576(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5; Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56321, 56505(e)

People named in the decision

  • Carrie Padden, general education teacher (second grade), Towers Elementary School, Torrance Unified School District
  • Jane Noble, general education teacher (third grade), Towers Elementary School, Torrance Unified School District
  • Joyce Hallgren, principal, Towers Elementary School, Torrance Unified School District
  • Maura Captain, school psychologist, Torrance Unified School District
  • Gail Bedinger (also spelled Beddinger), special education teacher and resource specialist, Torrance Unified School District
  • Dr. Victoria Estrada, director of special education, Torrance Unified School District
  • Dale Hughes, private psychologist, Private provider
  • Andrew V. Arczynski, attorney for District, Filarsky & Watt LLP

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Joseph T. Macaluso, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Torrance, California, on May 17 and 18, 2001. Appearing on behalf of Petitioner Torrance Unified School District (District) were attorney Andrew V. Arczynski from Filarsky & Watt LLP, and Dr. Victoria Estrada, director of special education for Torrance Unified School District. No one appeared on behalf of Respondent.

The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: Carrie Padden, general education teacher at Towers Elementary School; Jane Noble, general education teacher at Towers Elementary School (Towers); Joyce Hallgren, principal at Towers; Maura Captain, school psychologist for the District; Gail Bedinger, special education teacher and resource specialist for the District; and Dr. Victoria Estrada, director of special education for the District.

Respondent neither called any witnesses nor presented any written evidence at the hearing.

Oral and documentary evidence were received. Following receipt of oral closing argument on May 18, 2001, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On May 16, 2001, at approximately 3:45 p.m., STUDENT’S FATHER called the Hearing Office, spoke with a calendar clerk, and requested a continuance of the hearing. FATHER alleged that on May 5, 2001, he mailed the Hearing Office a motion to continue the hearing and inquired if the Hearing Office had ruled on his motion. The clerk checked the file and was unable to find a continuance motion from FATHER. A second clerk checked the master log for motions received by the Hearing Office during May 2001 and was unable to find a continuance motion from FATHER. The clerk advised FATHER that the Hearing Office had not received the motion. FATHER did not offer to send the Hearing Office a copy of the continuance motion.

FATHER then sought a continuance of the hearing because he needed to be present at Long Beach Superior Court in the morning of May 17, 2001, which was the same time that the due process hearing was set. The clerk inquired which court room and what time the court appearance was scheduled, but FATHER did not have this information. However, FATHER advised the clerk that the court appearance was before a Judge Kalinski regarding a violation of a court order by his ex-wife and that he was pursuing the matter himself in court. FATHER estimated that the case would take two days and thus he would be unable to attend the hearing on May 17 and 18, 2001. The clerk informed FATHER that the motion would be addressed when the matter convened as scheduled the following morning. After the clerk advised FATHER of this fact and tried to obtain further information about the matter in Long Beach, FATHER hung up. The clerk left two additional messages for FATHER but he did not return the calls.

On May 17, 2001, at 9:30 a.m., the hearing convened as scheduled. Neither FATHER nor any one else appeared on behalf of Respondent. The Hearing Officer advised the District and its counsel of FATHER’S motion to continue the prior afternoon. The District objected to a continuance because it had not received a copy of the motion and FATHER had provided no grounds establishing good cause for a continuance. At 9:40 a.m., the hearing officer called FATHER on his cell phone on the record. Since FATHER did not answer his phone, the hearing officer left him a message and telephone number to call at the hearing regarding his motion. The Hearing Officer then went off the record for thirty minutes and waited for FATHER to return the call.

At 10:10 a.m., the Hearing Officer went back on the record. FATHER still had not returned the Hearing Officer’s telephone call. The District then advised the Hearing Officer of its unsuccessful efforts to locate FATHER during the break.(Footnote 1) At 10:15 a.m., the Hearing Officer placed another call to FATHER’S cell phone and again requested that he call the hearing and also attend it.

At 10:30 a.m., the Hearing Officer ruled on FATHER’S motion for a continuance. California Education Code § 56505(f) provides that either party to the hearing may request the hearing officer to grant an extension. The extension shall be granted upon a showing of good cause. Although FATHER alleged he was in court that morning, the court clerk in Department A in Long Beach Superior Court stated that there was no case on calendar involving FATHER. Since FATHER neither called the hearing site advising the Hearing Officer of his whereabouts nor provided the Hearing Officer with any grounds for a continuance, the Hearing Officer denied FATHER’S motion. At 10:30 a.m., the Hearing Officer began the hearing.

At approximately 11:35 a.m., the Hearing Officer received a faxed motion to continue from FATHER. The motion was dated May 16, 2001. FATHER faxed the motion to the hearing office on May 17, 2001, at 6:56 a.m. from Kinkos in Torrance, California. FATHER noted that he had previously sent the Hearing Office a motion on May 5, 2001, but failed to attach a copy. Furthermore, FATHER failed to provide any grounds for a continuance. Thus, the Hearing Officer denied the motion to continue for lack of good cause and advised him to attend the hearing. The Hearing Office advised FATHER of the ruling.

At approximately 1:15 p.m., the Hearing Officer received a faxed motion from FATHER to recuse the Hearing Officer. The motion had originally been faxed to the Hearing Office on May 17, 2001, at 9:32 a.m. from Kinkos in Torrance, California. FATHER alleged that the Hearing Officer had been on a second telephone line and had ex parte communications with him while FATHER spoke to the clerk at the Hearing Office. The District objected to a recusal of the Hearing Officer. The Hearing Officer explained on the record that he had no ex parte communications with him. Since FATHER did not present good cause to recuse the Hearing Officer, the motion was denied and the hearing went forward.

On May 18, 2001, FATHER did not attend the second day of the hearing, nor did he return the Hearing Officer’s two calls from the day before. The Hearing Officer waited until 10:00 a.m. for FATHER to appear. When he failed appear, the Hearing Officer began the hearing. FATHER neither contacted the hearing site nor provided an explanation for his failure to appear.

ISSUES

(1) Is the nature and severity of STUDENT’S disability sufficient to remove him from the general education environment?

(2) Does STUDENT require placement in a special day class (SDC) to receive a free and appropriate public education (FAPE)?

(3) If STUDENT requires an SDC placement, does the District’s proposed “transitional placement” from a regular education class with services to an SDC provide STUDENT with FAPE?

(4) Should STUDENT be evaluated for mental health services pursuant to California Government Code § 7576(b)?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner Torrance Unified School District contends that STUDENT’S placement in the regular education class with resource services is not meeting his unique and individual needs as a child with an emotional disturbance and does not allow him to benefit from his education. The District asserts that STUDENT’S inappropriate behavior during class inhibits his ability to attend to and receive instruction. The District alleges that because of STUDENT’S poor behavior in class, STUDENT has academically fallen behind his fellow students in the third grade and is not prepared to proceed to the fourth grade. Finally, the District contends that STUDENT’S verbal and physical assaults in and outside the class are examples of the behavior that prevents him from building and maintaining satisfactory interpersonal relationships with his peers and teachers.

The District asserts that STUDENT requires an SDC placement in order to succeed both academically and socially. The District alleges that an SDC teacher, unlike a regular education teacher, is specially trained in the behavior intervention and educational techniques that allow the teacher to break down work into incremental steps for students with needs like STUDENT’S, to proceed at a pace which meets their individual needs, and to promote educational confidence and growth. The District contends that an SDC placement will provide STUDENT with the daily counseling and increased psychological services he needs to replace his inappropriate behavior with appropriate behavior and to teach him strategies to promote social growth. Finally, the District contends that an SDC placement will provide STUDENT with the structure and guidance he needs to progress academically and socially.

While FATHER did not appear at the hearing to challenge the District’s proposed change of placement for Respondent from a regular education class with supplemental aides and services to an SDC, FATHER did not sign the January 25, 2001 IEP wherein the written proposal was contained.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a nine-year-old boy with an emotional disturbance. STUDENT’S cognitive abilities fall in the average range. His strengths are in science and art. However, he exhibits deficits in social pragmatics. STUDENT attends Towers Elementary School in Torrance. He currently participates in a regular education third-grade class and receives one-to-one instruction from a resource specialist program (RSP) teacher and instructional aides. STUDENT receives counseling services from both a school psychologist and a private psychologist. The on-campus counseling is pursuant to his current individualized education program (IEP), and the private counseling is pursuant to a Superior Court order resulting from his parents divorce.(Footnote 2)

STUDENT’S initial diagnosis of an emotional disturbance came two months after his eighth birthday. STUDENT attended Tulita Elementary School in Redondo Beach Unified School District for kindergarten, first grade, and the beginning of the second grade. During this period, STUDENT lived with his mother. While at Tulita, STUDENT was referred to the student study team (SST) in June 1999 because of concerns regarding his behavior. STUDENT was reported to frequently hurt other children with words or actions. He seemed angry and unhappy, and did not complete class work; however, STUDENT was not evaluated for special education. STUDENT did see a private counselor once a week at that time. This counseling stopped when he was six-and-a-half years old.

On September 30, 1999, STUDENT enrolled in the second grade at Towers Elementary School in the Torrance Unified School District because he now lived with his father. Shortly after beginning school, STUDENT’S second grade teacher, Ms. Carrie Padden, began to notice problems. With regard to his school work, STUDENT often became angry, crumpled his paper, and refused to finish his assignments. He often sat and did nothing. As a result of his failure to complete work, he received unsatisfactory grades. With regard to his relationship with his peers, STUDENT experienced a lot of conflict. He angered quickly, got into fights with and bullied other students, and was not liked by his classmates. As a result of his actions, STUDENT had time-outs, received detention, and was sent to the principal. STUDENT’S teacher requested an SST meeting in October 1999 because of STUDENT’S academic and social problems. Despite the SST meeting, STUDENT’S behavior problems continued until December 1999.

In December 1999, the Los Angeles Superior Court ordered an initial assessment of STUDENT in order to determine if he was eligible for special education.(Footnote 3) Ms. Maura Captain, school psychologist for the District, conducted the evaluation. Ms. Captain assessed STUDENT for a learning disability. To assess his cognitive ability, Ms. Captain administered the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Third Edition (WISC III). STUDENT’S Full Scale score fell in the average range. To assess achievement, Ms. Captain administered the Woodcock Johnson Psycho-Educational Battery-Revised (WJPEB-R). STUDENT’S academic achievement scores did not differ significantly from his cognitive scores. Achievement was, therefore, commensurate with potential. Adequate sensory motor and auditory and visual processing were also present. Thus, Ms. Captain concluded that STUDENT did not demonstrate evidence of a learning disability.

Ms. Captain also assessed STUDENT’S social-emotional functioning. Ms. Captain first had STUDENT’S teacher complete a teacher report form regarding her observations of STUDENT’S behavior. After reviewing the form, Ms. Captain concluded that no problem behaviors were clinically significant. Ms. Captain next administered the Social Problems and Aggressive Behavior scales. The results fell into the borderline clinical range. Ms. Captain also administered the Children’s Depression Inventory (CDI). STUDENT’S overall score was clinically significant. However, Ms. Captain concluded that STUDENT’S social-emotional functioning appeared adequate for learning, because testing and teacher reports indicated average academic performance. Since the Towers staff had also known STUDENT for less that six months, they had not had sufficient time to observe him. Thus, Ms. Captain concluded that STUDENT did not meet the criteria for emotionally disturbed at that time.

An IEP meeting was held on January 24, 2000. The IEP determined that STUDENT was not eligible for special education.

After the beginning of the new 2000 calendar year, STUDENT’S inappropriate behavior increased both inside and outside the classroom. STUDENT’S teacher reported that his educational progress was negatively impacted by his behavior. Furthermore, STUDENT continued to frequently engage in fights with peers. Thus, on May 15, 2000, Ms. Captain revisited her December 1999 assessment regarding an emotional disturbance. Ms. Captain had STUDENT’S general education teacher fill out the Devereux School Form regarding STUDENT’S behavior. The Total Scale score fell in the very significant range. Ms. Captain also conducted the Children’s Depression Inventory, which fell in the clinically significant range. Ms. Capatin concluded that STUDENT exhibited an inability to maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers, exhibited inappropriate types of behavior and feelings under normal circumstances, and exhibited a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. These problems had now existed over a long period of time (at least six months), existed to a marked degree, adversely affected his educational performance, and were not due to sociocultural factors. Thus, Ms. Captain concluded that STUDENT had an emotional disturbance.

In March, April and May, the District sent FATHER notices of three IEP meetings, and he failed to attend each time. The District noticed a final meeting on May 17, 2000, and again FATHER failed to attend. However, Ms. Beddinger spoke to FATHER and he gave the other members of the IEP team permission to conduct the meeting without him. The IEP team found STUDENT eligible for special education and services because of an emotional disturbance. On May 24, 2000, the team met and reviewed STUDENT’S proposed placement and services. On May 26, 2000, FATHER approved the special education placement for STUDENT(Footnote 4). The placement included a general education class with a resource program, counseling and a behavior plan. The District also recommended a referral to the Department of Mental Health (DMH) for STUDENT. FATHER said he would consider such a referral but never gave the District a reply. The placement was implemented for the last three weeks in May of the 1999-2000 school year, and STUDENT experienced neither academic nor social problems during this time.

In September 2000, STUDENT began the third grade in Ms. Jane Noble’s class. Almost immediately, Ms. Noble began to experience problems with STUDENT. He refused to do his work and he fought with his fellow students. The District noticed an IEP meeting on October 17, 2000. The District members of the IEP team planned on discussing a placement for STUDENT in a special day class (SDC) and a referral for an evaluation by DMH. However, FATHER failed to attend the meeting. The IEP team sent FATHER additional letters to meet and discuss a change in placement for STUDENT, but to no avail. STUDENT continued to do little or no work in class. In October 2000, STUDENT also was suspended for the first time because he continued to fight with his peers.

In November 2000, STUDENT continued to get involved in fights with his peers, which resulted in additional days of suspension. On December 4, 2000, Ms. Captain reviewed STUDENT’S discipline and health records because he had been involved in five fights resulting in nine days of suspensions. Ms. Captain found that there was a nexus between STUDENT’S behavior and his emotional disability and concluded that his misconduct was a direct result of his identified disability.(Footnote 5)

On December 13, 2000, FATHER, Ms. Joyce Hallgren, Ms. Gail Beddinger, and Ms. Jane Noble met at a parent conference. Ms. Noble advised FATHER that STUDENT had fallen behind academically and was receiving grades of D’s and F’s. Furthermore, Ms. Hallgren advised FATHER that STUDENT continued to have social and emotional problems both inside and outside the class.(Footnote 6) They recommended the SDC class and a referral to DMH. FATHER said he would consider an SDC class for STUDENT and would visit one. However, FATHER neither visited the SDC class nor gave the District permission for a DMH referral.

On December 18, 2000, an IEP meeting was scheduled to discuss Ms. Captain’s findings. Although FATHER was given notice of the meeting, he did not appear. On the same day, the District noticed an annual IEP meeting on January 10, 2001. FATHER did not appear. On January 16, 2001, the District noticed an IEP meeting on January 18, 2001. The notice was personally delivered to FATHER’S home. FATHER did not appear. An IEP meeting was noticed on January 25, 2001. Again, the notice was personally delivered to FATHER’S home. FATHER did not appear. Thus, the District members of the IEP team conducted the IEP meeting without FATHER. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT be transitioned from a regular education class with supplemental aids and services into an SDC class. The IEP was mailed to FATHER for review. FATHER never responded. On April 3, 2001, the District requested a hearing regarding the appropriate placement for STUDENT.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Is the nature and severity of STUDENT’S disability sufficient to remove him from the general education environment?

Special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412 (a)(5)(A); Education Code § 56031. The Court in Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education (1989) 874 F.2d 1036, concluded that the law sets forth “a strong preference for ‘mainstreaming’ which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption.” United States Code § 1412(a)(5) sets forth the preference that students with disabilities are provided with an appropriate education within the regular education setting. It provides that, to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, be educated with children who are not disabled, and that special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of the child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplemental aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.

In determining whether the placement proposed for the student satisfies LRE requirements, federal appellate courts have considered the following factors: (1) the educational benefits available to the child in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared to the educational benefits of a special education classroom; (2) the non-academic benefits to the disabled child of interaction with non-disabled children; (3) the effect of the presence of the disabled child on the teacher and other children in the regular classroom; and (4) the costs of supplemental aids and services necessary to mainstream the disabled child in a regular classroom setting. Sacramento City Unified School District vs. Rachel Holland (1992) 786 F.Supp. 879 (1992); Adopted by the Ninth Circuit in Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland, (9th Cir. 1994) 14 F.3d 1398; cert. denied.

The above factors are considered below in determining whether the placement proposed for STUDENT by the District satisfies federal and State preferences for mainstreaming, as well as the specific provision of United States Code § 1412(a)(5) allowing removal of a disabled student from the general education environment only when the student’s needs cannot be met in the regular education classroom with supplemental aids and services. (Emphasis added.) Here, the District is proposing to remove STUDENT from his present placement in a general education program with supplemental aids and services at Towers Elementary School to a special day class (SDC) within the District.(Footnote 7) At his present placement, STUDENT receives services from the resource specialist program (RSP) teacher, Ms. Beddinger, and counseling from Ms. Captain. Although not part of his present IEP, STUDENT also has an aide shadow him full-time during noninstructional time to ensure that he does not harm other children. The District contends that STUDENT needs to be removed from the general education environment because the regular education placement with supplemental aids and services has not met STUDENT’S unique and individual needs.

A. STUDENT’S unique and individual needs.

To help determine the appropriate location in which to implement STUDENT’S educational program, it is necessary to understand STUDENT’S unique and individual needs as of January 25, 2001. Ms. Captain testified that her testing revealed that STUDENT did not have a learning disability. However, Ms. Captain testified that her testing revealed that STUDENT had an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers, that he experienced inappropriate types of behavior and feelings under normal circumstances, and that STUDENT experienced a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. Thus, Ms. Captain concluded that STUDENT had an emotional disturbance and continues to have specific needs in all of these areas.

With regard to STUDENT’S emotional needs, Ms. Captain testified that STUDENT needs a program with a strong focus on improving his behavior both inside and outside the classroom. First, Ms. Captain testified that STUDENT needs access to counseling on a daily basis because a counselor can immediately intervene with problem behavior and emotional setbacks. Second, Ms. Captain testified that STUDENT needs strategies for coping emotionally on a day-to-day basis. These strategies are designed to break down and modify STUDENT’S negative behavior patterns. Furthermore, all the District’s witnesses testified that STUDENT needs to continue to have an aide shadow him during all unstructured time such as at lunch and recess.(Footnote 8) Finally, Ms. Captain testified that STUDENT needs to improve his unhappiness and depression, his interpersonal relationships with his peers and teachers, and inappropriate types of behavior and feelings under normal circumstances. All the District’s witnesses testified that these needs cannot be met in a regular education environment.

With regard to STUDENT’S academic needs, the District’s witnesses all testified that STUDENT needs an individualized and restrictive educational environment. First, Ms. Captain and Ms. Estrada testified that STUDENT needs a small class size with a lower student-to-adult ratio. Ms. Estrada pointed out that if STUDENT matriculates to the fourth grade for the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT’S class will have 40 children. The student-to-adult ratio will be fifteen to one. Ms. Estrada said STUDENT will fall further and further behind in such a large class. According to Ms. Estrada and Ms. Captain, STUDENT needs a class with a maximum of fifteen students and more individualized attention. Third, Ms. Captain testified that STUDENT requires an educational program that is tailored to meet his individual needs. Ms. Captain pointed out that STUDENT needs an individualized curriculum, materials, assignments, and expectations. Finally, Ms. Captain testified that STUDENT needs to work at his own pace, to have material presented to him in small steps, to learn to stay on task, to have daily positive reinforcement, to work on transitioning from subject to subject, and to develop a feeling of academic success. Therefore, the District contends that STUDENT’S academic and social needs cannot be met in his regular education placement.

B. The academic benefits to STUDENT of placement in a regular education setting.

The District asserts that STUDENT’S behavior problems prevent him from obtaining any academic benefit in the regular education setting. The District first presented evidence with regard to STUDENT’S negative behavior affecting his ability to learn. Ms. Jane Noble, STUDENT’S third grade teacher, testified that from the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year in September to the present, STUDENT refuses to follow few, if any, directions or prompts she gives to him to do his work. Instead, STUDENT often does what he wants to do and, when confronted, STUDENT growls, glares, threatens and intimidates her. Ms. Noble took numerous photographs of this behavior and presented it at the hearing. When Ms. Noble asks STUDENT questions, he often refuses to answer her. Ms. Noble pointed out that when STUDENT does decide to work, he often becomes angry if he does not quickly understand the concept, which results in his either crumpling his paper or ripping it up. Ms. Noble often has to give STUDENT three to five directions to stay on task, often with no result. Ms. Noble presented additional photographs of STUDENT walking around the class and with his feet on the desk while the other students work. Finally, Ms. Noble testified that at times STUDENT simply refuses to do his work and sticks his head in his desk. Ms. Noble had a photograph to document this fact also. Ms. Noble concluded that while STUDENT is a bright boy, his poor behavior has inhibited his ability to learn.

In further support of its contention that STUDENT’S behavior prevents him from learning in a regular education setting, the District presented evidence that the services and aides in his IEP are ineffective in altering his behavior. Ms. Gail Beddinger, STUDENT’S RSP teacher, testified that her attempt to educate STUDENT three times per week for thirty minutes in class is often fruitless. When she tries to explain concepts to him and give him direction, STUDENT becomes defiant, and either crosses his arms or puts his feet on the desk, and refuses to work. STUDENT also growls at her, which is the extent of the conversation she has with him. Ms. Beddinger observed aides trying to teach STUDENT and having the same result with him. Ms. Beddinger pointed out that they try different teaching techniques with STUDENT, but all to no avail. Finally, Ms. Beddinger testified that she performed the Woodcock Johnson Psycho-Educational Battery on STUDENT, which indicates that he performs at grade level. While STUDENT has the ability to do the work in class, Ms. Beddinger concluded that his behavior prevents him from learning, and ultimately causes him to fall further behind the other students.

In final support of its contention that STUDENT’S behavior prevents him from learning in a regular education setting, the District presented evidence of his failing grades. First, Ms. Noble, STUDENT’S teacher, testified about STUDENT’S lack of progress for the entire 2000-2001 school year. Ms. Noble noted that STUDENT’S grades in every academic subject have either been D’s or F’s. She stated that while the other children in STUDENT’S class have made progress, STUDENT is not performing at a third grade level in any academic area. Again, Ms. Noble pointed out that STUDENT’S poor behavior prevents him from completing any work. Due to STUDENT’S failure to make any progress in the third grade, he is not ready to proceed to the fourth grade. Ms. Noble pointed out that the fourth grade class will have thirty students and the teacher will have even less time to spend with STUDENT.(Footnote 9) Furthermore, Ms. Noble testified that the curriculum in the fourth grade will be more demanding, will require more responsibility on STUDENT’S part, and that he is neither emotionally nor academically ready to take that step. Ms. Noble concluded her evaluation of STUDENT’S inability to learn in a regular education setting with the following insight: from kindergarten to the third grade, a student learns to read and write. From the fourth grade on, a student reads and writes to learn. Because STUDENT had yet to learn to read and write at a third grade level, he is not ready for the fourth grade and his behavior will continue to academically limit him in a regular education setting.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony of those teachers working directly with STUDENT who collect data and draw conclusions regarding STUDENT’S school performance. Their testimony establishes that STUDENT’S behavior prevents him from receiving an appropriate education in a regular education setting with supplemental aides and services.

C. The non-academic benefits to STUDENT in regular education.

The District asserts that STUDENT’S behavior problems prevent him from fully obtaining non-academic benefit in a regular education program. The District first presented evidence that the counseling provided for in his IEP does not help to improve his behavior in the classroom.(Footnote 10) Ms. Captain testified that she met STUDENT in counseling to discuss working on his feelings, connecting feelings to situations, facial expressions, and tools to cope with his negative feelings. Initially, Ms. Captain pointed out, STUDENT was open to the counseling and talked to her about his feelings and relationships with fellow students in class. However, Ms. Captain noted that his participation over time was inconsistent and started to decline. At the same time, STUDENT started to get involved in more fights during recess and lunch, which resulted in nine days of suspension and an evaluation in December 2000. When Ms. Captain questions STUDENT about the incidents, STUDENT does not tell her what occurs. Ms. Captain said that STUDENT tells her he understands what he does and knows his actions are wrong. However, she testified that she cannot understand why his behavior is the way it is. Ms. Captain stated that while she feels her counseling helped STUDENT at times, it became less effective over time and ultimately did not help him in his social interaction at school.

The District did, however, present evidence that it was able to meet the goals and objectives in his behavior intervention plan (BIP). The plan noted that STUDENT has trouble keeping his hands to himself, and that he kicks, hits and chokes others while in line or lining up. Furthermore, the plan noted that STUDENT harasses other students by calling them names, breathing in their faces, and hitting them. The goals and objectives STUDENT’s BIP call for him to keep his hands and comments to himself while in line. The District’s witnesses all testified to STUDENT’s verbal and physical assaultive behavior, which ultimately led to nine days of suspension. Ms. Captain and Ms. Beddinger testified that once STUDENT was given a full-time aide during recess and lunch, the physically assaultive behavior stopped. However, STUDENT’s relationships with his fellow students has not improved, since he is still verbally abusive. All the District witnesses testified that STUDENT has no friends to date.

The testimony from the District’s witnesses, therefore, establishes that STUDENT has received few non-academic benefits from his involvement in the regular education classroom. While the strategies in the behavior intervention plan are successful in stopping STUDENT’s physical attacks on other students, they have not prevented his verbal abuse of other students. Moreover, STUDENT’s counseling does not help him to improve his negative feelings and to get along socially with others. Thus, more intensive integration strategies are needed to help STUDENT become part of the educational setting and benefit from it socially.

D. STUDENT’s effect upon the teachers and children in the regular education class.

The District asserts that STUDENT’s behavior problems cause him to have both a negative and dangerous effect upon the children and teachers in the regular education class. The District first presented evidence regarding STUDENT’s assaultive behavior. All of the District’s witnesses testified that STUDENT has hit, kicked and chocked numerous students at both recess and in the lunch. Ms. Noble described one incident when she watched STUDENT knock another student down at recess and bang his head on the ground. Ms. Estrada testified that STUDENT has punched other students in the face. Ms. Hallgren testified that she has seen STUDENT in her office on numerous occassions for discipline because of fighting. Ms. Hallgren and Ms. Estrada testified that the result of STUDENT’s assaultive behavior has been twofold: First, STUDENT has been suspended a total of nine days. Second, the District has placed an aide with STUDENT at all times while at recess and at lunch. The aide is present to protect both STUDENT and his fellow students. Ms. Noble testified that since December 2000, the assaultive behavior has stopped because STUDENT has the aide during all unstructured time. However, all the witnesses testified that STUDENT explodes without warning and they must be on a constant alert.(Footnote 11) Thus, the District concluded that STUDENT’s assaultive behavior does not allow him to benefit from a regular education setting and that he poses a danger to both his fellow students and teachers. The District also presented evidence regarding STUDENTs’s verbally assaultive behavior towards his peers in class. Ms. Noble described how in class STUDENT calls other students stupid, growls at them, and thinks he can verbally harass them with impunity. Due to STUDENT’s verbal abuse in class, Ms. Noble stated that his peers at times have difficulty completing their work. Ms. Noble pointed out that STUDENT also tattles on his peers, which does not endear himself to them. Thus, STUDENT’s verbal abuse toward his peers further alienates him in his regular education setting.

Finally, the District presented evidence about STUDENT’s lack of social relationships with his fellow students. Ms. Noble testified that STUDENT has no friends and does not know how to play with his peers at recess. In class, STUDENT does not participate in groups and is noncommunicative. Ms. Beddinger testified that STUDENT also puts his feet on his desk, walks around while others are learning and disrupts them. Ms. Noble presented photographic evidence of these acts. Ms. Noble testified that these actions have caused the other children to become distressed with STUDENT. Outside of class, STUDENT is constantly monitored due to his assaultive behavior. Ms. Noble testified that despite his poor behavior, STUDENT’s fellow student’s try to make friends with him. However, Ms. Noble pointed out that STUDENT’s poor behavior destroys any potential friendships. STUDENT has told both Ms. Noble and Ms. Captain that he has no friends. On a scale of zero to ten, Ms. Noble rated STUDENT’s social skills as a one. Thus, the District concluded that STUDENT’s assaults, both verbal and physical, do not allow him to benefit from regular education and his actions also threaten the safety of other students.

Because the teachers work daily with STUDENT and are able to observe his relationship with peers, their testimony has substantial weight. On the basis of this testimony, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT has a negative effect upon the teachers and children in the regular education class.

E. The costs of mainstreaming STUDENT.

The District did not raise the cost of maintaining STUDENT in his present placement as an issue. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will not consider it as a relevant factor in this case.

The above discussion leads the Hearing Officer to conclude that STUDENT is not appropriately placed at Towers Elementary School and that the District’s request to remove STUDENT from the regular education class with supplemental aids and services is appropriate. The testimony of STUDENT’s teachers in particular has established that with supplemental aides and services STUDENT is unable to receive academic and nonacademic benefit in a regular education classroom. STUDENT also has a negative rather than a positive effect on classmates and teachers. Moreover, the evidence, as discussed above, establishes that STUDENT’s placement at Towers Elementary School is not designed to meet his needs and to provide him with educational benefit. It should be recalled that STUDENT has an average intellectual potential. Since STUDENT’s placement in the regular education setting with aids and services cannot meet his unique and individual needs, the District can remove STUDENT from regular education. Thus, the Hearing Officer shall next determine whether STUDENT requires placement in an SDC to receive FAPE.

ISSUE NO. 2: Does STUDENT require placement in a special day class (SDC) to receive a free and appropriate public education (FAPE)?

The District’s witnesses testified that STUDENT requires placement in an SDC to receive FAPE because his placement in the regular education environment with supplemental aids and services has not met his unique and individual needs. With regard to STUDENT’s emotional needs, Ms. Captain testified that an SDC offers STUDENT daily access to a counselor who can help him resolve any emotional problems he may have. Without this daily counseling in an SDC, according to Ms. Captain, STUDENT will continue to emotionally fall further behind his peers. Moreover, Ms. Captain testified that the availability of daily and immediate counseling in an SDC will also be supplemented by her individual counseling with STUDENT in all areas of emotional need. Finally, Ms. Captain pointed out that STUDENT will have an SDC teacher in class at all times who is trained in strategies to modify STUDENT’s negative behavior patterns. The SDC teacher will be able to immediately identify an emotional problem and implement an appropriate strategy to replace the negative behavior with positive behavior. The totality of these elements in the SDC setting will, according to the District’s witnesses, provide STUDENT with the help he needs to successfully integrate into the classroom setting and ultimately have the nonacademic benefits of interaction and friendship with his peers.

With regard to STUDENT’s academic needs, Ms. Estrada testified that an SDC will provide STUDENT with a smaller class size and a higher adult-to-student ratio. In an SDC class, there will be a maximum of fifteen students whereas the fourth grade class in the regular education setting will have 40 students. While the student-to-adult ratio in the regular education class will be 15 to 1, the student-to-adult ratio in an SDC will be only 7 to 1. Ms. Estrada testified that this smaller class size will provide STUDENT with the individualized attention he needs to succeed academically. Furthermore, Ms. Estrada testified that the SDC will be taught by an SDC teacher who possess the specialized training, skills and understanding to educate STUDENT. A general education teacher does not have the requisite background to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs. Finally, the District’s witnesses testified that an SDC can tailor an educational program to meet STUDENT’s needs. The SDC will provide STUDENT with an individualized curriculum, materials, assignments, goals and objectives. Furthermore, the SDC setting will allow STUDENT to work at his own pace, to have material presented to him in small increments, and will help STUDENT to stay on task and transition from subject to subject as required. Thus, the District’s witnesses concluded that the totality of these academic elements in an SDC setting, which are not available to STUDENT in the regular education setting with supplemental aids and services, will provide STUDENT with a more personal and structured learning environment that will provide him with the foundation to succeed academically.

The testimony from the District’s witnesses, then, establishes that STUDENT’s unique and individual emotional and academic needs cannot be met in regular education. Furthermore, the evidence established that STUDENT requires placement in an SDC to receive FAPE. However, the District neither offered a specific SDC placement at the IEP on January 25, 2001 nor presented a specific SDC program at the hearing. Therefore, the Hearing Officer is unable to conclude that the District offered STUDENT an appropriate SDC placement. However, the evidence the District presented was persuasive in establishing that STUDENT needs an SDC placement. Pursuant to the evidence presented by the District, the Hearing Officer will review the elements that an appropriate SDC placement for STUDENT must contain.

Pursuant to the District’s witnesses testimony, the SDC placement should contain the following elements: First, the SDC placement should include a teacher who has the requisite skills and training in special education. This teacher will then be able to meet STUDENT’s special behavioral and academic needs. Second, the SDC placement should have a small class size no larger than fifteen students and a student-to-adult ratio of 7 to 1 to provide the more individualized attention that STUDENT requires. Third, the SDC placement should be tailored to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The IEP team should create a program for STUDENT in the SDC setting which has an individualized curriculum, materials, assignments, goals and objectives. Furthermore, the SDC program, according to the District’s witnesses, should allow STUDENT to work at his own pace, to have material presented to him in small increments, teach him to stay on task, to work on transitioning from task to task, and to have daily positive reinforcement. If the SDC placement include these elements, the SDC placement will be formulated to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs.

The District witnesses testified that even if an SDC placement is designed and implemented to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs, the success of the placement will also depend upon STUDENT receiving counseling from the Department of Mental Health. As indicated above, this issue has been discussed with FATHER from May 25, 2000, to the present, but with no success. Ms. Captain testified that she can only provide a certain level of counseling to meet STUDENT’s emotional needs. In order for an SDC program to succeed, Ms. Captain noted that STUDENT requires the concurrent and more intensive counseling that DMH can provide him. Finally, all the District’s testified that without the DMH referral, the District cannot fully meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. The Hearing Officer found the District’s witnesses testimony convincing on the critical need for a DMH referral for STUDENT in order for him to succeed both emotionally and academically in an SDC setting. The District’s request for a DMH referral is discussed more fully below in issue number four.

Thus, the Hearing Officer shall now determine whether the District’s proposed “transitional placement” from a regular education class with supplemental aides and services to an SDC provides STUDENT with FAPE.

ISSUE NO. 3: If STUDENT requires an SDC placement, does the District’s proposed “transitional placement” from a regular education class with services to an SDC provide STUDENT with FAPE?

Between December 6, 1999, and January 10, 2000, the District assessed STUDENT. On May 17, 2000, the IEP meeting took place. On May 26, 2000, FATHER signed the IEP. The next annual review of STUDENT’s IEP was scheduled on January 10, 2001. The annual review occurred on January 25, 2001. At the meeting, the District offered STUDENT a placement in the regular education class with supplemental aids and services while at the same time preparing to transition STUDENT to an SDC for the remainder of the 2000-2001 school year. The SDC placement was to continue into the 2001-2001 school year through January 25, 2002.

Under both State law and the federal Individual with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Huson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the students’ abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley, 458 at 207-208. Thus, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the individual child. Seattle School District v. B.S. (9th Cir. 1996) 82 F.3d 1493; Union School District v. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519, cert. denied 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994). Furthermore, the focus of the inquiry is not on whether the student may obtain greater benefit in a placement that is preferred by one of the parties. Rather, a placement is adequate if it is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student. Gregory K. v. Longview School District (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307.

In Summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student’s unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, and conform with the IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et. seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.

A. Procedural Compliance

California Education Code § 56343(d) provides that an individualized education program team shall meet at least annually, to review the pupil’s progress, the individualized education program, including whether the annual goals for the pupil are being achieved, and the appropriateness of placement, and to make any necessary revisions. In this matter, the IEP meeting was scheduled on January 10, 2001, which was in compliance with Education Code § 56343(d).

California Education Code § 56341.5(f) provides that if neither parent can attend the meeting, the district shall use other methods to ensure parent participation, including individual or conference telephone calls. California Education Code § 56341.5(g) provides that a meeting may be conducted without a parent in attendance if the district is unable to convince the parent that he or she should attend. In this event, the district shall maintain a record of its attempts to arrange a mutually agreed-upon time and place, as follows: (1) Detailed records of telephone calls made or attempted and the results of those calls. (2) Copies of correspondence sent to the parents and any responses received. (3) Detailed records of visits made to the home or place of employment of the parent and the results of those visits.

In this matter, the District timely noticed the annual review of STUDENT’s IEP on January 10, 2001. Furthermore, the District properly provided FATHER with notice of each of the three scheduled dates for the annual review of STUDENT’s IEP. The District also used other proper methods to ensure FATHER’s participation at the meeting. After the District made three valid attempts to obtain FATHER’s attendance at the annual review meeting and FATHER did not appear, it was proper to conduct the annual review meeting of STUDENT’s IEP without FATHER in attendance.

B. STUDENT’s Unique Needs

As discussed above in the first issue, STUDENT’s unique and individual needs are both emotional and academic. With regard to STUDENT’s emotional needs, STUDENT needs a program with a strong focus on improving his behavior both inside and outside the classroom. With regard to STUDENT’s academic needs, he needs an individualized program which will focus on his specific needs. All the District’s witnesses testified that STUDENT’s needs can only be met in the more restrictive setting of an SDC.

C. Program Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Needs

The District contends that STUDENT should be removed from the general education environment and placed in an SDC because the regular education placement with supplemental aides and services has not met STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. To meet STUDENT’s needs, the District offered at the January 25, 2001 IEP meeting a placement that will keep STUDENT in his present regular education setting with services for “two to three weeks.” During this two-to-three-week period, the IEP team will prepare the goals, objectives and other elements of the SDC placement. After the elements of the SDC placement are formulated by the IEP team, STUDENT will then transition to the SDC class.

However, the “transitional placement” which the District offered in its January 25, 2001 IEP has six critical flaws: The transitional placement provides the same or even less services than the May 25, 2000 placement which failed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. First, the May 25, 2000 IEP provided STUDENT with RSP services three times per week for thirty minutes. However, the transitional placement only provides STUDENT with RSP services one to two times per week for thirty minutes. Although Ms. Beddinger admitted that the RSP services in the May 25, 2000 failed to meet STUDENT’s individual needs, the transitional placement now provides STUDENT with even less RSP services. Second, the transitional placement will keep STUDENT in the general education environment where his grades have been no better than D’s and F’s. Third, the accommodations, reinforcement and intervention strategies in both the May 25, 2000 IEP and the January 25, 2001 IEP are almost exactly the same. For example, the January 2001 IEP proposed using prompts, rewards, and positive comments, all of which were also in the May 2000 IEP. The District witnesses testified that these accommodations and strategies did not work. Fourth, the academic, social, and pre-vocational goals and objectives in both the May 2000 and January 2001 IEPs have very similar strategies, objectives and goals. For example, both IEPs concentrate on classroom assignments and putting work away. Again, the District’s witnesses all testified that these goals and objectives in May 2000 IEP could not be met. Fifth, the counseling goals and objectives in the January 2001 IEP deal with the same problems such as transitioning, choosing alternate behavior, and feelings which Ms. Captain admitted could not be dealt with in the general education environment. Finally, every District witness testified that STUDENT’s needs could not be met and were not met in the regular education setting with supplemental aides and services.

Although every district witness testified how STUDENT needs could only be met in an SDC setting, the District did not offer an SDC placement. Instead, the District was willing in January 2001 and will still be willing at the beginning of STUDENT’s fourth grade year in September 2001, to place STUDENT back in the regular education setting for two to three weeks while the IEP team conducts new assessments, creates new goals and objectives, and prepares STUDENT for transition to an SDC. The fatal flaw with this plan is that while the IEP team creates the plan for the SDC placement, STUDENT will continue to receive no educational benefit at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year. Additionally, the District’s transitional placement assumes that the IEP team will timely agree on the goals and objectives it creates for STUDENT in the SDC. If the IEP team is unable to agree on the goals and objectives for STUDENT, the anticipated two or three weeks in the transitional IEP plan in the fourth grade could be much longer. As time passes, STUDENT may linger on in a transitional placement which admittedly provides him with no educational benefit! Thus, the transition plan fails to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and thus fails to provide him with FAPE.

D. Designed to Provide Educational Benefit

Because the Hearing Officer finds that the transitional placement fails to met STUDENT’s unique needs, it is unnecessary to determine whether the transitional placement provides STUDENT with educational benefit.

ISSUE NO. 4: Should STUDENT be evaluated for mental health services pursuant to California Government Code § 7576(b)?

California Education Code § 56321 provides that “No assessment shall be conducted unless the written consent of the parent is obtained prior to the assessment except pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 56505.” Where such consent is not forthcoming, the remedy available to a public education agency is to “prevail in a due process hearing relating to the assessment” and thereby obtain permission to conduct the assessment. California Education Code §§ 56505(e) and 56321.

The District requests that STUDENT be referred to the Los Angeles County Department of Mental Health for an assessment for mental health services pursuant to California Education Code § 7576(b), despite FATHER’s lack of consent. The District attempted to obtain FATHER’s consent for such a referral at the IEP meeting on May 24, 2000. IEP team member and school psychologist Ms. Captain spoke of the benefits to STUDENT from the referral–principally, help for him in learning ways to cope with his behavior problems both inside and outside the class room. When she encouraged FATHER to sign the referral, FATHER stated that he needed to think about it and would provide the District with an answer. FATHER never gave the District a response. Thereafter, the District made numerous additional attempts to obtain FATHER’s permission for a DMH referral for STUDENT, but all to no avail.

Assembly Bill (AB) 3632/882, which is codified at California Government Code §§ 7570-7588 (Chapter 26.5), describes interagency responsibilities for providing services, including mental health services, to children with disabilities. Pursuant to Government Code § 7576, mental health referrals may be initiated for “an assessment of a pupil’s social and emotional status” by a “local education agency, individualized education program team, or parent” for any child who has been determined eligible for special education and “who is suspected of needing mental health services...” This referral is appropriate where the child satisfies the following key criteria:(Footnote 12)

(3) the pupil has emotional or behavioral characteristics that:

(A) Are observed by qualified educational staff in educational and other settings, as appropriate.

(B) Impede the pupil from benefitting from educational services.

(C) Are significant as indicated by their rate of occurrence and intensity.

(D) Are associated with a condition that cannot be described solely as a social maladjustment or a temporary adjustment adjustment problem, and cannot be resolved by short-term counseling.

California Government Code § 7576(b)(3)

It is clear from the undisputed testimony in this case that STUDENT meets these criteria. Testimony on the frequency and intensity of STUDENT’s behaviors, as well as the manner in which they impede his academic progress,(Footnote 13) has been discussed above. In addition, all District witnesses who observed or worked with STUDENT, starting in the second grade, testified about his need to participate in counseling beyond that which the District has provided and can provide STUDENT. Specific areas identified for counseling were anger management in school and anger that might be a result of his parents divorce (Ms. Captain); peer relationships (Ms. Noble, Ms. Beddinger, Ms. Halgren, and Ms. Estgrada); behavior impulse control and responsibility for behavior (all the District’s witnesses); and family counseling (Ms. Captain). The persistence and escalation of these problems over the last two years indicate that STUDENT is not experiencing a purely social or temporary adjustment problem.

STUDENT meets the additional criteria for a mental health referral. In January and May 2000, Ms. Captain assessed STUDENT in accordance with Education Code § 56320. At that time, she concluded that STUDENT had an emotional disturbance, and the special education team found him eligible for special education services pursuant to her finding. The District did not obtain FATHER’s consent for the Department of Mental Health referral and thus was required to raise it as one of the issues in this hearing. Furthermore, testimony on STUDENT’s cognitive functioning and whether it is at a level sufficient to enable him to benefit from mental health services has been discussed above. Finally, Ms. Captain testified that she has provided counseling to STUDENT since May 2000 and has not been able to meet his educational, social and emotional needs. All the District’s additional witnesses testified to the same facts. The Hearing Officer notes that, should Mental Health fail to provide counseling services pursuant to the referral, the District is still obligated to address STUDENT’s unique emotional needs. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT shall be referred for an evaluation for mental health services pursuant to California Government Code § 7576(b)(3), despite FATHER’s lack of consent.

ORDER

1. The IEP team shall meet within thirty (30) days of the date of this order to prepare an IEP for STUDENT in an SDC setting forth goals and objectives for the 2001-2002 school year through January 25, 2002, the date of the next annual IEP review. The placement, with appropriate goals and objectives to meet STUDENT’s unique emotional and academic needs, shall be in place prior to STUDENT beginning the 2001-2001 school year.

2. The placement in the SDC shall include the following elements:

(a) An SDC teacher who has the requisite skills and knowledge to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs;

(b) The SDC class shall have an adult to student ratio of no more than one (1) adult to every seven (7) students. The maximum class size should be no more than fifteen (15) students.

(c) The IEP team shall tailor an educational program to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual emotional needs. The program shall include goals and objectives emphasizing positive choices with appropriate prompts and cues and reinforcing them on a daily basis with appropriate rewards. Furthermore, the program shall include an aide at all times to shadow STUDENT during all non-structured time and reinforce positive choices.

(d) The IEP team shall tailor an education program to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual academic needs. The program shall include goals and objectives in math, science, English, reading, writing, social studies, art and physical education. The academic program shall contain an individualized curriculum, materials, assignments, and expectations. The academic material shall be presented to STUDENT in small increments and at a pace which will allow him to stay on task and transition from task to task as required.

(e) The IEP team shall create daily positive reinforcement strategies for STUDENT in order to meet both his emotional and academic needs.

(f) The IEP team shall create a counseling plan with both the school psychologist and counselor in order to meet STUDENT’s daily emotional needs.

3. The District shall refer STUDENT to the Los Angeles County Department of Mental Health for an assessment of his need for mental health services. The referral shall be made within fourteen (14) calendar days of the date of this order.

4. FATHER shall make STUDENT available to the Los Angeles County Department of Mental Health and to the District for the purpose of conducting an assessment of his need for mental health services.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

1. The District prevailed on the first issue.

2. The District prevailed on the second issue.

3. The Respondent prevailed on the third issue.

4. The District prevailed on the fourth issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED:_____________________ ________________________________ Joseph T. Macaluso, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1.Ms. Estrada called MOTHER at home. MOTHER advised Ms. Estrada that she was not scheduled to be in court that morning. Mr. Arczynski called FATHER at his home but received no answer. Mr. Arcyzinski next called the court clerk in Dept. A at Long Beach Superior Court, where Judge Kalinski presided. The court clerk advised Mr. Arczynski that there was no case on calendar on May 17, 2001, in Department A involving MR. and MRS. PARENT. Finally, Mr. Arczynski called FATHER’S work. FATHER’S supervisor advised Mr. Arczynski that he had seen FATHER that morning at work 2.Pursuant to an order of the Los Angeles Superior Court dated September 24, 1999, if the mother and the father cannot agree on educational matters regarding STUDENT, the father’s decision shall prevail. 3 The Los Angeles Superior Court made the order in conjunction with STUDENT’S parent’s divorce. 4.The placement was in effect until January 10, 2001.

5.Ms. Captain also reported that STUDENT received counseling one time per week from a private psychologist named Dale Hughes. During the Month of November, Mr. Hughes saw STUDENT twice per week. Upon Mr. Hughes’s referral, STUDENT saw a psychiatrist. Mr. Hughes noted that STUDENT made some progress clinically but seem stressed in his general education classroom placement. Ms. Captain noted that STUDENT might be taking medication. 6.The problems resulted in the District appointing a full-time aide to shadow STUDENT in order to protect both himself and other students. 7.While the District has yet to offer a specific SDC class in the District, the District proposed three sites to Respondent’s father. One site, Anza Elementary School, is located in the vicinity of STUDENT’S home. 8.The District’s witnesses testified that STUDENT needs a shadow-aide in both the transitional placement and also in an SDC. 9.STUDENT’S present class has only fifteen students.

10.STUDENT’s IEP provides for counseling two to three times per month with the District psychologist. 11:The District’s witnesses testified that STUDENT has had few assaultive outbursts in class. However, they noted that STUDENT is quite explosive and must be monitored constantly. Footnote 12:Additional criteria for a mental health referral, as set forth in Government Code Section 7576(b), are as follows: (1) the pupil must have been assessed by the school in accordance with Education Code § 56320; (2) written parental consent for the referral has been obtained by the local education agency; (4) the pupil’s functioning, including cognitive functioning, is at a level sufficient to enable the pupil to benefit from mental health services; and (5) the local education agency has provided counseling, psychological, or guidance services to the pupil pursuant to § 56363 and the IEP team has determined that the services do not meet the pupil’s educational needs, or, in cases where these services are clearly inappropriate, the IEP team has documented which of these services were considered and why they were determined to be inappropriate. Footnote 13:Ms. Noble testified that STUDENT receives only Ds and Fs in all of his subjects due to his poor behavior, lack of concentration, and inability to complete any work.