California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 19, 2004

San Dieguito Union High School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 901-04 · Hearing Officer John G. Andersen

San Dieguito Union High School District barred from moving student to a regional SDC without first assessing her behavior; mental health referral allowed.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 2 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

San Dieguito Union High School District filed for due process after a parent refused consent to a March 25, 2004 IEP. The student was a 14-year-old ninth grader at La Costa Canyon High School. She was eligible for special education under emotional disturbance. In general education, she received daily resource specialist help and weekly counseling. Her behavior escalated in high school and led to several suspensions. The District then proposed moving her to a regional special day class (SDC) at Sierra Vista High School, a separate special education campus with a behavior focus. The District also asked to refer her for a community mental health assessment without the parent's consent. The parent left the hearing after the Hearing Officer denied her request to delay it, and the hearing went on without her.

The Hearing Officer found that the SDC offer met the student's needs and could give her some educational benefit, but it was not the least restrictive environment. The District had never assessed her behavior or tried added supports at her home school. Her only behavior service was the same weekly counseling she had received since middle school. A possible link to inconsistent use of her prescribed medication went unexplored. The Hearing Officer blocked the SDC placement. He ordered daily resource services at La Costa Canyon, an IEP meeting within 10 days, a functional analysis assessment, and a follow-up IEP meeting. The District won its request to make the mental health referral without consent.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO applied least restrictive environment rules and California's behavioral intervention regulations of the era. A district had to assess a student's escalating behavior and try supports in the less restrictive setting before removing her to a separate special education campus. The decision also shows the Government Code section 7576 requirements for a mental health referral.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1. Has the District offered a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to Student in the March 25, 2004 Individualized Education Plan?

    The regional SDC offer was designed to meet the student's needs and provide some educational benefit. But it was not the least restrictive environment, because the District never assessed her behavior or tried added supports at her home high school before proposing a more restrictive placement.

  2. Issue 2. May the District refer Student for a community mental health service assessment without parental consent?

    All requirements of Government Code section 7576 and 5 C.C.R. section 60040 were met except parental consent, so the District may refer the student for a community mental health assessment without consent.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • The District shall not implement the regional SDC placement at Sierra Vista High School specified in the March 25, 2004 IEP.
  • Order to provide or change services. Pending further agreement of the full IEP team, the student shall receive one hour per day of resource specialist services at La Costa Canyon High School during the 2004-2005 school year. In all other respects, the services in the March 25, 2004 IEP shall be implemented in her current placement at La Costa Canyon High School.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. The IEP team shall meet within 10 days of the order and amend the March 25, 2004 IEP to conform to the order and reflect continued placement and resource specialist services at La Costa Canyon High School.
  • Order to assess. The District shall conduct and complete a functional analysis assessment within 30 calendar days of the date classes begin at La Costa Canyon High School for the 2004-2005 school year. It must comply with 5 C.C.R. section 3052, except the parental consent requirement.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 7 calendar days after the functional analysis assessment is completed, the IEP team shall meet to consider its recommendations and develop a behavioral intervention plan if the team finds one necessary.
  • Order that district may assess without consent. The District shall refer the student for a community mental health service assessment under Government Code section 7576 and 5 C.C.R. section 60040, without parental consent.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley; Daniel R. v. State Board of Education; Light v. Parkway; Cal. Educ. Code § 56520; 5 C.C.R. §§ 3001, 3052; Cal. Govt. Code § 7576; 5 C.C.R. § 60040; Cal. Educ. Code § 56346

People named in the decision

  • Ryan Gold, special education case manager, La Costa Canyon High School, San Dieguito Union High School District
  • Vangie Birdson, school psychologist, San Dieguito Union High School District (La Costa Canyon High School)
  • Doug Kamon, assistant principal, La Costa Canyon High School, San Dieguito Union High School District
  • Dawn Dully, special education program specialist; District representative and witness, San Dieguito Union High School District
  • Mary Ellen Nest, coordinator of special education; District representative, San Dieguito Union High School District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before John G. Andersen, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Encinitas, California, on May 11, 2004.

Petitioner San Dieguito Union High School District (District) was represented at the hearing by Mary Ellen Nest, the coordinator of special education, and Dawn Dully, a special education program specialist. Respondent (Student) was represented by her mother (Parent) when the hearing first convened. As discussed further in the Procedural Matters section of this Decision, Parent elected to leave the hearing shortly after her arrival and did not participate in the presentation of evidence and argument regarding the disputed issues in the proceeding.

The District offered testimony from the following witnesses: Ryan Gold, Student’s special education case manager at La Costa Canyon High School (LCCHS); Vangie Birdson, the District’s school psychologist assigned to LCCHS; Doug Kamon, the assistant principal at LCCHS; and Ms. Dully.

At the conclusion of the testimony, oral argument in support of the District’s position was presented by Ms. Nest. Thereafter, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

By written notice from the Hearing Office mailed on April 19, 2004, the hearing of this matter was scheduled to commence on May 11, 2004, at 9:30 a.m. Parent did not arrive for the hearing until shortly after 10:00 a.m. and offered no explanation for her tardiness. Thereafter, as the hearing participants began to discuss preliminary matters and clarify the disputed issues, Parent demanded that the Hearing Officer immediately rule upon her written motion challenging the timeliness of the District’s documentary evidence package. After the Hearing Officer explained that the motion would be addressed later in that morning’s proceedings, prior to the Hearing Officer’s receipt of any evidence, Parent made an oral motion for a stay of the due process hearing in order for her to obtain an injunction from the United States District Court. Parent asserted that an injunction was necessary because Student’s constitutional rights were being infringed by virtue of the Hearing Officer’s refusal to rule immediately on the motion challenging the District’s documentary evidence disclosure. Although the Hearing Officer assured Parent that her motion regarding the District’s document package would be ruled upon before any evidence was presented, Parent insisted that a stay of the due process hearing, for the purpose of obtaining an injunction, was necessary because testimony from the District was being received by the Hearing Officer during the preliminary discussions clarifying the disputed issues. The Hearing Officer construed Student’s motion as a request for a continuance of the hearing.

A continuance should be granted only upon a showing of good cause. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(f). Speedy resolution of special education due process hearings is mandated by law, and “good cause” is construed narrowly in light of this mandate. After considering the arguments offered in support of and against the motion, the Hearing Officer found that a delay for a party to seek a Court injunction did not constitute good cause to continue the matter. Moreover, Parent was present in the hearing room and fully capable of proceeding with the hearing as scheduled. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer denied the Student’s request.

After the continuance motion was denied, Parent announced that she intended to leave the hearing room and withdraw from further participation in the due process hearing. Upon inquiry from the Hearing Officer, Parent confirmed on the record that she fully understood the hearing would proceed in her absence. Parent indicated that the contemplated U.S. District Court action for injunctive relief was of paramount concern, and she departed the hearing room at approximately 10:30 a.m.

As indicated earlier, Student filed a written motion challenging the admission of the District’s documentary evidence on the grounds that it was not delivered in a timely fashion prior to the commencement of the hearing. California law specifies that each party in a special education due process proceeding must provide the opposing party with notice of all documents to be offered into evidence no less than five days before the hearing. As part of her motion, Parent submitted a declaration under penalty of perjury stating that she “received the [District’s] packet on Friday May 7th” and that it should have been delivered one day earlier, on May 6, 2004. Attached to the declaration was a photocopy of the May 7, 2004 letter, faxed to the Hearing Office on Monday, May 10, 2004, by which Parent first registered her objection to the timeliness of the District’s documentary evidence disclosure. The fax letter was typewritten and amended by handwriting. The typed text stated that the District’s evidence package was placed on the porch of the Parent’s home “yesterday” and discovered later “yesterday” afternoon (i.e., May 6, 2004). The handwriting on the fax letter stated that the package was placed on the porch “today on Friday” and discovered on “Friday” afternoon (i.e., May 7, 2004). On the other hand, the original signed copy of the May 7, 2004 letter, received via mail by the Hearing Office on May 10, 2004, did not contain the holographic changes shown on the fax letter. The original May 7, 2004 letter mailed by Parent indicated that the District’s evidentiary package was received one day earlier, on May 6, 2004. Unfortunately, because she elected to withdraw from the proceedings, Parent was not available to clarify the discrepancy in her correspondence regarding the delivery.

At the hearing, the District provided the Hearing Officer with photocopies of the Federal Express air-bills for the evidentiary packages sent to Parent and to the Hearing Office. Those documents indicate that the packages were consigned to the shipping agent on May 5, 2004. The District also provided the Hearing Officer with a photocopy of the Federal Express website shipment tracking report for the delivery to Parent. This document specifies that the package was received by the shipping agent on May 5, 2004, and delivered to the Parent’s home in Encinitas, California at 9:51 a.m. on May 6, 2004. The Hearing Officer also notes that the Hearing Office received the evidence package from the District via Federal Express on May 6, 2004.

Parent’s declaration does not establish that the delivery took place on May 7, 2004. Rather, the declaration only establishes that Parent discovered the package on her porch that day. Additionally, the discrepancy between the faxed and mailed versions of the May 7, 2004 letter undermines Parent’s assertion that delivery did not occur as indicated by the Federal Express business records. Based upon the evidence, the Hearing Officer found that the District had given timely notice of the documentary evidence it intended to use at the May 11, 2004 hearing. Accordingly, Student’s objections to the District’s documentary evidence package were overruled, and the entire package of written materials was received into evidence by the Hearing Officer.

ISSUES TO BE DECIDED

1. Has the District offered a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to Student in the March 25, 2004 Individualized Education Plan?

2. May the District refer Student for a community mental health service assessment without parental consent?

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

Student is a fourteen-year-old ninth grade student at the District’s La Costa Canyon High School (LCCHS) in Encinitas, California. She is eligible for special education and related services under the category of emotional disturbance. At LCCHS, a general education campus, Student has been provided daily resource specialist services in academics and weekly counseling from the school psychologist.

In 1992, when she was three years old, Student was diagnosed with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (“ADHD”). In 1999, when she was ten years old, Student was further diagnosed with depression and bipolar disorder. The documentary record makes some reference to Student’s past receipt of community mental health services, as well as a prior community mental health assessment, but the details and circumstances were not provided through testimony or otherwise explained to the Hearing Officer. Community mental health services have not been provided to Student pursuant to any IEP developed or implemented by the respondent District.

Student was first found eligible for special education by the Encinitas Union School District, under the category of emotional disturbance, at some point in time prior to her enrollment in the respondent District at the commencement of the 2001-2002 school year. (Footnote 1) At the respondent District’s initial IEP meeting for Student on September 10, 2001, the entire team, including Parent, agreed to use the Encinitas District’s March 31, 2000 written IEP as the basis of a thirty-day interim placement, despite the fact that Parent previously had withheld consent to the implementation that program. As such, pending completion of new assessments in all areas of suspected disability, Student’s team agreed that she would receive one hour per day of resource specialist assistance in academics, as well as thirty-minute sessions each of individual counseling and speech therapy, and that she would be placed in a general education, seventh-grade classroom at her home middle school.

On October 8, November 19 and 28, 2001, Student’s IEP team reconvened to review the results of the District’s assessments, develop goals and objectives, and devise a program of placement and services to meet her educational needs. The team agreed to continue the general education middle school classroom placement and to continue providing Student with daily academic assistance and weekly counseling for her emotional and behavior needs. The team also agreed, on the basis of the assessments, that Student no longer required speech therapy services. Finally, although the team agreed that Student’s behavior was not impeding the learning process, the IEP nonetheless stated that a behavior support plan would be developed by the school psychologist. Parent signed the October 8, 2001 IEP document, consenting to its full implementation, as well as the addendums developed in the November 2001 meetings. Since that time, however, Parent and the District have been unable to agree upon any further modifications to Student’s special education placement and services.

During the 2002-2003 school year, Student’s IEP team met on December 6, 2002, and January 31, February 20, and March 19, 2003, in an attempt to complete an annual review. The record reflects that the team was unable to reach an agreement only in the area of Student’s academic assistance strategies and accommodations. (Footnote 2) After Parent failed to appear for a May 22, 2003 IEP team meeting, however, no further attempts were made to reconvene and complete Student’s IEP during the 2002-2003 school year.

In September of 2003, Student matriculated to La Costa Canyon High School (LCCHS). Although the record reflects efforts by the District to convene an IEP meeting for the purpose of an annual review in August 2003, Student’s team did not actually meet until December 15, 2003. By that point in time, Student’s behavior during school had become a significant problem. In general, Student’s school and classroom attendance record was replete with excused and unexcused absences, as well as excessive tardiness. Further, between September 23, 2003 and November 26, 2003, Student was involved in seven separate school incidents which resulted in disciplinary action, including four days of detention, two days of home suspension, and one day of Saturday school. The behaviors at the time were primarily classroom disruptions and disrespect/defiance of school personnel. Moreover, although her cognitive abilities have been assessed in the average to high-average range, Student was receiving failing grades in Spanish and Physical Education and near-failing grades in Algebra and English. The IEP reflects prior reports by the Spanish and remedial math teachers that Student’s class attendance was problem, as well as reports by the English and science teachers that her classroom behavior was a problem. (Footnote 3) The Algebra teacher reported that homework completion was a major factor in Student’s low grade.

When Student’s team met on December 15, 2003, an agreement in principle appeared to have been reached on a new annual IEP. Consensus was reached on three social/emotional goals, as well as a single math goal. The parties also agreed upon resource specialist services for Student in math/algebra, as well as weekly sessions of counseling with the school psychologist. Although the IEP team determined for the first time that Student’s behavior had become a learning impediment, the only support or service offered to address the escalating behavior difficulties was the pre-existing, weekly counseling with the school psychologist. No behavior assessments were suggested or proposed to better understand the conduct at issue. (Footnote 4) No behavior support plan was proposed or developed to eliminate or reduce the conduct at issue. The meeting ended with Parent requesting time for additional review of the IEP document before she consented to its implementation. (Footnote 5) Two days later, however, Parent informed the District by telephone that she did not intend to sign the December 15, 2003 IEP. (Footnote 6) Thus, for the 2003-2004 school year Student’s legally operative IEP remained the November 2001 document, developed when she was a twelve-year-old middle school student. (Footnote 7)

When Student returned to LCCHS in January of 2004, following the winter holiday break, her conduct at school deteriorated further. On January 15, 2004, Student was involved in a lunch-hour altercation in which she was observed kicking another student in the head while the student was on the ground brawling with Student’s twin-sister. The contemporaneous written statements by the witnesses to the altercation all indicate that the incident began as a verbal dispute between Student’s sister and another student, which escalated to a food fight and then to a physical conflict in which the initial combatants had brought each other to the ground. All witnesses described Student’s role as limited to kicking the other student after she was on the ground with Student’s sister. In her written statement regarding the incident, Student concedes that she kicked the student and asserts that she did so to protect her sister. A witness statement from an assistant principal confirms that Student was observed kicking her sister’s opponent in the head. This administrator also described a subsequent near-altercation between Student and a fourth student who was upset that her friend had been kicked in the head. The assistant principal’s statement further indicates that Student was brought to the office for discipline on January 15, 2004, after the subsequent near-altercation, rather than immediately following the altercation involving her twin-sister. Thereafter, Student was arrested by the local police department for assault and also was suspended from school for an additional five days. The District’s January 15, 2004 Notice of Suspension identifies the reason as “Student kicked another student in the head at least twice because she was fighting with Student’s sister.” (Footnote 8) The suspension notice also reflects Student’s arrest.

On January 30, 2004, during the first week back in school following her suspension for the January 15th incident, Student was again suspended for an additional two days as the result of inappropriate behavior with a male student during a physical science class. (Footnote 9) Anticipating that Student’s behavior would trigger additional, future suspensions, the District sought to convene an IEP team meeting and determine whether the behaviors underlying Student’s recent suspensions were manifestations of her emotional disturbance. (Footnote 10) The IEP team initially convened for the purpose of the manifestation determination on February 5, 2004, and then again on February 9, 2004, but was unable to complete the meeting because of antagonistic commentary by Parent, Student and her twin sister. The LCCHS school resource officer, a sworn member of the local police force assigned to the campus, was summoned and Parent, Student and her sister were physically escorted off campus after the February 9th meeting ended.

When the IEP team reconvened to conclude the manifestation determination on February 11, 2004, Parent and Student did not attend. The meeting notes reflect the team’s decision to proceed in the Student and Parent’s absence because of unspecified “safety concerns.” (Footnote 11) At the February 11, 2004 meeting, the team reviewed the written Manifestation Determination Report prepared by Ms. Birdson, the school psychologist, on February 4, 2004. (Footnote 12) In the report, the manifestations of Student’s disability are identified as “inattention, impulsivity, poor decision making, irritability and alternating patterns of emotional highs and lows.” These characteristics were all noted in the report to be associated with her ADHD, depression and bi-polar medical conditions. The report concluded that a nexus exists between Student’s behavior problems and her emotional disturbance-based disability. The report stated that expulsion was not recommended, that Student’s current placement and services were not appropriate, and that she would “benefit from participating in an educational setting that has a behavioral/social-emotional focus.” (Footnote 13)

The District members of the IEP team agreed with Ms. Birdson’s recommendation that Student not be expelled because her behavior was a manifestation of her disability. The notes from the February 11, 2004 meeting indicate the District members of the team believed that, although Student was capable of completing the academic rigors of a general education curriculum, her current placement at LCCHS was “not enough support,” and that she “requires the support and services of an environment which has a behavior support focus.” Accordingly, the meeting notes reflect an offer of “FAPE in a Regional Special Day Class at Sierra Vista High School which is a small environment with a behavior support focus to include DIS counseling 1x a week, transportation offered curb to curb.” (Footnote 14) The notes also state that the District will complete a “Functional Analysis and additional social-emotional assessments,” but the Regional SDC placement offer was not contingent upon the completion or results of such behavioral assessments. Finally, the team recommended a referral for community mental health service assessment.

On February 12, 2004, the District sent Parent a letter summarizing the results of the February 11, 2004 meeting. After stating that Student’s suspensions were a manifestation of her disability, the District advised that is was nonetheless recommending a placement change “due to significant concerns regarding Student’s safety.” The letter also detailed the offer, including the proposed placement at the Sierra Vista SDC, transportation services, and thirty minutes of weekly counseling. The letter makes no mention of extended year services. The letter also proposes a “triennial evaluation of all areas of suspected disability including a Functional Analysis Assessment,” as well as a referral for a community mental health assessment. The documentary record indicates that the Manifestation Determination report, the IEP team meeting notes, the District’s written evaluation plan and a county mental heath assessment referral consent form were forwarded to Parent after the February 11, 2004 meeting. The documentary record also indicates that Parent declined the mental health assessment referral and did not sign or return the consent form for the assessments specified in the District’s evaluation plan. (Footnote 15)

An annual review of Student’s IEP was held on March 25, 2004. Parent, Student and her twin-sister appeared over one hour past the scheduled time of the meeting. The meeting notes and witness testimony indicate that the meeting was tense from the outset. The March 25, 2004 IEP document specified that no assessments were conducted prior to the meeting. The District members of the team determined Student’s present levels of performance and her progress toward the goals and objectives developed at the December 2003 IEP meeting. (Footnote 16) The IEP states that Student made “partial progress” on the Algebra mastery, anger management and compliance goals, but “no progress” on her socialization skills goal. The lack of significant progress toward all four of the December 2003 goals and objectives was due to “excessive absences and tardies,” and Student’s case manager noted that her tardies were the result of being “very social and not aware of the time.” The meeting notes reflect Parent’s disagreement with the District’s evaluation of Student’s progress toward the December 2003 goals and objectives.

Student’s prior disciplinary incidents were discussed at length during the March 25, 2004 IEP team meeting. The meeting notes reflect the District’s concern that Student’s offensive racial beliefs and comments were creating an unsafe environment for her at LCCHS. (Footnote 17) The case manger further specifically noted to the team an additional incident where Student made comments regarding the “gay community” which the case manager found offensive. The meeting notes also state that Parent disagreed with any change in Student’s placement. Parent advised the team of her belief that Student could be successful on the LCCHS campus, but that she “may require more adult supervision to control the behaviors in the classroom.” The notes reflect that the District’s response to this contention was to point out that Student had been offered counseling services, but that she had been unwilling to attend. (Footnote 18) The notes also reflect that Parent advised the team of her opinion that Student required “smaller group instruction.” The meeting notes indicate the District’s response to this contention was to point out that individual math instruction was available, but that Student did not want to access such individual support.

At the March 25, 2004 meeting, the District reiterated its prior offer of placement at the Sierra Vista Regional SDC, with weekly individual and weekly group counseling services, as well as round-trip transportation. In addition, for the first time, the District proposed to deliver special education and services during the 2004 extended school year. The notes reflect that the District again proposed a community mental health service assessment referral, as well as a written plan for assessments by District personnel. The IEP document states that the mental health assessment referral, the District’s assessment plan and the Regional SDC placement were all declined by Parent. The March 25, 2004 meeting was adjourned early, again because of antagonistic comments by Parent, Student and her sister, including alleged racist statements directed to certain District members of the IEP team. Once again, the school resource officer’s presence was required to ensure the meeting participants’ safety after the adjournment.

On April 19, 2004, the District filed a petition with the Hearing Office seeking a due process hearing regarding its proposed change in placement for Student, as well as the proposed community mental health service assessment referral.(Footnote 19) That same date, the Hearing Office mailed written notice to the parties of the May 11, 2004 due process hearing. The following day, April 20, 2004, Student was suspended from attending class at LCCHS for five additional days after she was arrested for on-campus possession of marijuana. As a result, yet another manifestation determination meeting was scheduled by Student’s IEP team for April 29, 2004. Neither Parent nor Student attended the April 29, 2004 meeting. (Footnote 20) Once again, however, the team proceeded with the meeting “due to safety issues and the need for a timely IEP.”

At the April 29, 2004 IEP meeting, the team again found expulsion inappropriate by virtue of the nexus between the drug possession incident and Student’s qualifying emotional disturbance. Once again, the District recommended the Regional SDC placement, weekly counseling from the school psychologist, and a referral for community mental health services. At the April 29, 2004 meeting, for the first time, the IEP team also proposed a written “Behavior Support Plan for Behavior Interfering with Learning of Student or Peers.” The testimony and documentary evidence do not indicate whether this support plan was intended for implementation at LCCHS or the Sierra Vista SDC, but there is no dispute of the fact that it was never implemented.

Student has not returned to LCCHS since the time of her arrest and suspension as a result of the April 20, 2004 marijuana possession incident. In this matter, the District seeks permission to implement the March 25, 2004 IEP and place Student in the Sierra Vista Regional SDC.

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The District asserts that Student’s escalating behavior problems as a ninth-grader at LCCHS place both her and the other LCCHS students at increased risk of physical harm. The District contends that, under the present circumstances, Student now requires a level of supervision, support and services that can only be provided through a placement in the Regional SDC at Sierra Vista High School. Accordingly, the District seeks a ruling that the proposed placement and services at Sierra Vista High School constitute an offer of a free appropriate public education (FAPE), as well as an order that the March 25, 2004 IEP reflecting the proposed placement and services be implemented without parental consent. The District further contends that, because her behavior is impeding educational progress and because the counseling services provided at school are not meeting her educational needs, Student likely requires community mental health services. As such, the District also seeks an order allowing a community mental health services assessment referral without parental consent.

Because Parent elected not to participate in either the discussions of the disputed issues or the evidentiary presentation at the hearing, Student’s precise contentions and assertions could not be directly determined by the Hearing Officer. The documentary record only reveals that Parent has refused to provide consent for either the March 25, 2004 IEP or the community mental health services assessment referral, and that Parent believes Student’s educational needs can be met on the LCCHS campus with the benefit of additional adult supervision and small group instruction.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. Has the District offered a free appropriate public education to Student in the March 25, 2004 Individualized Education Plan?

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C.§ 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 5600. The term "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that are available to the student at no cost to the parents, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student's individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). "Special education" is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25). The term "related services" includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401(22). California Education Code section 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of possible related services are psychological services other than for assessment and development of the IEP, parent counseling and training, health and nursing services, specially designed vocational education and career development, and counseling and guidance. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(b).

In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S.C. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirement of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student's IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student's abilities. Id., at 198 - 200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a "basic floor of opportunity" that consists of access to specialized instructional and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201.

In addition to requiring that special education students receive a program of services designed to meet their unique needs and to provide some benefit, the law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). The IDEA states:

To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are to be educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment should occur only when the nature or severity of the disability of the child is such that education in regular education classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.

20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); see also Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. The requirement that disabled children be educated to the maximum extent appropriate with non-disabled children is often referred to as “mainstreaming.” The law demonstrates a “strong preference for ‘mainstreaming,’ which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption.” Daniel R. v. State Board of Education, 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45 (5th Cir. 1989).

Parents also have the right not to consent to all or part of a recommended IEP. "No pupil shall be required to participate in all or part of any special education program unless the parent . . . consents, in writing, to all or part of the" IEP. Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(a). If the parent does not consent and the district determines that the program is necessary to provide a FAPE, the District must institute a due process hearing. Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(b).

To summarize, therefore, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District's proposal to remove Student from LCCHS and place her in a Regional SDC at Sierra Vista High School must meet the following four requirements in order to constitute a free and appropriate public education: (1) the offered placement and services must been designed to meet Student's unique needs; (2) the placement and services must be reasonably calculated to provide Student with some educational benefit; (3) the placement and services must comport with her IEP; and (4) the services must be provided in the least restrictive environment.

(a) Student’s unique educational needs

There is no dispute that Student qualifies for special education under the category of emotional disturbance. The triennial reassessment completed by the District in November of2001 indicates that Student has average to high-average cognitive abilities. Although Student’s visual-motor integration subtest results indicated average processing abilities, the assessor stated that Student’s actual level of ability was probably higher, attributing her poor performance on easier test activities to a lack of effort and inattention. These results were found to be fully consistent with assessment results obtained in 1998 by the Encinitas Union School District. The witnesses at the hearing all agree that Student is “bright.”

The November 2001 assessment states that Student demonstrated “clinically significant” and “at risk” levels of maladjustment, aggression, depression, hyper-activity, locus of control, anxiety, conduct problems and attention problems in the behavioral testing conducted by the District as part of the 2001 triennial reassessment. The 2001 assessment report noted that these findings were fully consistent with her medical diagnosis of ADHD, depression and bi-polar disorder. The 2001 report also states that, as a result of her medical conditions, Student has difficulty organizing her school work, staying focused on assignments and learning independently from instruction. Finally, the 2001 assessment concluded that Student’s condition causes her to exhibit behavioral difficulties, including impulsiveness, loss of control, poor decision-making and a significant inability to maintain relationships with peers and adults.

While the overall number of Student’s school conduct problems has remained fairly consistent over the past three school years, the severity of her behavior has dramatically escalated since her arrival at LCCHS from middle school. According to the District, disruptive and defiant outbursts have now progressed to bigotry, lewd acts, criminal assault and possession of illegal drugs on a public school campus. In light of these behaviors, Ms. Birdson, the school psychologist, Mr. Kamon, the assistant principal, Mr. Gold, the special education case worker, and Ms. Dully, the program specialist, all testified that Student’s aggression, coupled with her racist comments and attitudes about the Hispanic pupil population, had created a situation where her physical safety and the safety of other students has now become a concern of the IEP team. According to Mr. Kamon, Student needs to be “away from all the people she has offended.”

Although Student’s academic performance, particularly in mathematics, is adversely impacted by her disabling condition, the record and testimony do not indicate any specific areas of disability beyond her serious emotional disturbance. However, the evidence is un-controverted that, as a result of her emotional disturbance, Student learns at a slower pace and recently has experienced significant difficulty functioning in the environment of a general education high school classroom and campus with only academic resource specialist assistance and weekly thirty minute sessions of counseling with a school psychologist. As such, Student currently has both academic and social/emotional needs which must be addressed by her special education program. Academically, Student has the need for accommodations that will allow her additional time to learn and master concepts, including modified homework assignments and test taking procedures. Student also has the need for individual and small group instruction in subject matters, particularly Algebra, where her disability interferes with her ability to learn at the pace of the general education classroom. Socially/emotionally, Student has a need for supports and structures that will improve her classroom attendance problems, as well as supports, structures and services to reduce her disruptive and defiant school behaviors.

(b) Is offered program designed to meet needs and provide some educational benefit?

The District has offered Student a placement in a Regional SDC at Sierra Vista High School in Vista, California, with curb-to-curb transportation from her home in Encinitas, California. The offer also includes weekly, thirty minute sessions each of group counseling and individual counseling with a school psychologist. The March 25, 2004 written IEP reflecting this proposed program of placement and services sets forth four separate goals and objectives, targeting Algebra competency, compliance, socialization and anger management. The March 2004 IEP also proposes various modifications and accommodations that afford Student additional time for task completion and instructor feed-back. (Footnote 21)

Ms. Dully, the District’s program specialist, was the only witness who offered specific testimony regarding the appropriateness of the Sierra Vista SDC placement and related services offered to Student. Mr. Kamon, Mr. Gold and Ms. Birdson only testified in general terms that Student required placement in a small group setting which provides more adult support and a behavioral/emotional focus, that her current placement at LCCHS did not meet those requirements, and that the Regional SDC provided more behavior supports than available at LCCHS. Ms. Dully, however, was the District representative who coordinated with the SELPA on the Sierra Vista SDC placement proposal in conjunction with the February 2004 manifestation determination. As such, Ms. Dully gave more specific testimony regarding the Sierra Vista SDC.

Ms. Dully explained that Sierra Vista High School is a dedicated special education facility with only twelve SDC classrooms and less than three-hundred total students who all demonstrate behavior problems during transitions and unstructured time periods. Ms. Dully explained that the SDC at Sierra Vista proposed for Student is focused on both academics and behavior. Ms. Dully also testified that the SDC proposed for Student would have no more than ten students, with one credentialed teacher and one or more special education classroom aides.

Ms. Dully testified that the four goals and objectives specified in the March 2004 IEP appropriately targeted Student’s academic and social emotional needs. Ms. Dully also testified that Student’s academic needs would be addressed by the small-group size and academic focus of the Sierra Vista SDC. Ms. Dully further testified that Student’s social/emotional needs would be served by the high level of structure and low student-adult ratio in the SDC classroom, as well as the school’s overall focus on improving social skills and behavior. Finally, to more specifically address Student’s social/emotional needs, Ms. Dully testified that the March 2004 IEP also provides for weekly sessions of both group and individual counseling with the school psychologist at Sierra Vista.

Mr. Gold, Mr. Kamon, Ms. Birdson and Ms. Dully all testified that Student will not make educational progress unless she is placed in a more controlled school environment with additional adult supervision and an emotional/behavioral focus. These witnesses also testified that they believe Student is receiving little educational benefit from her current placement in the general education student population at LCCHS, because of inadequate supports and services. Further, the witnesses testified that Student is unwilling to seek out individual academic support in her current placement on the LCCHS campus, despite the fact that the special education resource specialist is available for such support under her currently operative IEP dated November 21, 2001. Finally, the District witnesses testified that the placement in the Sierra Vista SDC will allow Student to benefit from her special education program and make progress on the goals and objectives set forth in the March 25, 2004 written IEP.

Accordingly, based upon the un-controverted testimony and the documentary evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that the program of placement and services offered to Student in the March 25, 2005 IEP is designed to address her current areas of educational need and is reasonably calculated to provide Student with some educational benefit.

(c) Does the offer of placement and services comport with the March 25, 2004 IEP?

The District has offered to place Student at Sierra Vista High School in a Regional SDC with an emotional/behavioral focus. Weekly individual and group counseling with the school psychologist, as well as door-to-door transportation services, were offered in conjunction with the Sierra Vista SDC placement. The proposed placement and services are fully consistent with and reflected in the March 25, 2004. Because Parent has not consented to the implementation of the March 25, 2004 IEP, it is unnecessary for the Hearing Officer to make any determination of whether Student actually has received placement and services which comport with that IEP.

(d) Has the District offered placement in the least restrictive environment?

Although the Hearing Officer has determined that the District’s offer of placement and services is generally designed to meet Student’s unique educational needs and reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit, as stated earlier, the also law requires that students with disabilities be educated in the least restrictive setting that can meet their needs. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031; see also Daniel R., 874 F.2d at 1044-45. Under federal and state law, school districts are obligated to evaluate and implement supplementary aids and services for a student with disabilities in the least restrictive environment possible based upon each student's unique needs. Generally, a district may only remove a pupil to a more restrictive environment if the supplementary aids and services prove to be ineffective in a less restrictive setting. In the present matter, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has not fulfilled its obligation to evaluate and implement aids and services for Student so as to maintain her in the least restrictive educational environment.

There is no dispute that the Sierra Vista SDC placement proposed for Student in the March 25, 2004 IEP is a more restrictive educational environment than her current, general education placement at LCCHS. Indeed, Ms. Dully testified that Student will have no opportunity to receive any part of her education with non-disabled students at Sierra Vista. The restrictive nature of the proposed Regional SDC placement is amplified further by the requirement of daily round-trip transportation services to the distant Sierra Vista campus. Because the placement is not in her home school, and because she will be required to spend considerable, additional time traveling to and from the proposed placement, Student will have even less opportunity to spend significant time with non-disabled peers in her home neighborhood or other non-school settings.

In California, specific legislation has been enacted to ensure that students with disabilities are not placed in an overly restrictive environment based upon behavior problems before less restrictive alternatives are explored. See Cal. Educ. Code § 56520; 5 C.C.F. §§ 3001 and 3052. In establishing mechanisms for developing behavioral interventions, the Legislature intended to “ensure a pupil's right to placement in the least restrictive educational environment.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56520 (b)(1). As such, behavior interventions must be “designed to provide the individual with greater access to a variety of community settings, social contacts and public events; and ensure the individual's right to placement in the least restrictive educational environment as outlined in the individual's IEP.” 5 C.C.R § 3001(d).

Before the Regional SDC placement was recommended here, however, the only service or support ever offered to Student for her behavior difficulties at LCCHS was the same weekly counseling session with the school psychologist that she had been receiving since the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year when she was in middle school. These counseling services were implemented to address Student’s social/emotional needs at a time when she was in the fifth grade and her IEP team did not believe that her behavior was impeding the learning process. Nonetheless, when the her defiance and disruptions escalated during September, October and November of 2003, no change in Student’s supplementary aids and services was proposed or undertaken. Although a number of Student’s teachers had expressed concern in December of 2003 that poor attendance was negatively impacting her academic performance, no strategy or support plan was developed or implemented to address Student’s attendance difficulties. Despite the IEP team’s specific determination on December 15, 2003, that Student’s behavior was interfering with her education, she was offered only the existing, weekly session of counseling with the school psychologist. Then, after a serious behavior incident occurred in January of 2004, the District simply proposed the same weekly counseling in a highly restrictive Regional SDC placement. (Footnote 22)

Rather than proposing a more restrictive environment to address Student’s obviously changing social/emotional needs, the District first should have sought to assess Student and determine whether her needs could be addressed at LCCHS with additional supports and services. The Hearing Officer is particularly concerned by the considerable evidence that Student has not been following her Aderol and Prozac medication regimen. This fact was noted to the IEP team by Parent in December of 2003, and was again noted to the team by the school psychologist at the Manifestation Determination meeting on February 11, 2004. Further, a March 23, 2004 report from her resource math specialist notes that Student was having difficulty focusing on her work because she had not taken her medications. (Footnote 23) These medications are prescribed by Student’s medical doctors to control the symptoms of her ADHD, depression and bi-polar disorder. The behaviors which precipitated the February 2004 and April 2004 manifestation determinations, as well as the resulting proposed Regional SDC placement, all occurred during a time period when the District was aware that Student was not regularly using medication intended to control the medical conditions which give rise to her emotional disturbance. The potential link between the behavior problems and Student’s medication irregularities is unmistakable, but unexplored. It may be quite possible to educate Student in a less restrictive environment simply by taking steps to identify, understand and appropriately respond to situations where she may be experiencing behavior problems because of a medication irregularity, as well exploring techniques to maximize her voluntary compliance with the medication regime. (Footnote 24)

The District made no effort to assess Student or determine the origin of her escalating behavior problems at LCCHS before proposing the Regional SDC placement. Although the District proposed a triennial re-assessment and a functional analysis assessment (FAA) (Footnote 25) at the manifestation determination IEP meeting on February 11, 2004, neither have been undertaken, and the District has not requested a due process hearing to override Parent’s refusal of consent. According to the District’s witnesses, the FAA and triennial re-assessment will be pursued after Student is in the Sierra Vista SDC. The Hearing Officer agrees with the conclusion of the District IEP team members, reached on February 11, 2004, that Student’s assaultive behavior on January 15, 2004 necessitates an FAA. (Footnote 26) However, as noted earlier, the District is obligated to evaluate and implement supplementary aids and services for Student in the least restrictive environment possible. As such, Student’s behavior must be assessed before she is placed in a more restrictive environment, not afterward. (Footnote 27)

Although the District has demonstrated that Student’s unique needs could be met through a placement in the Regional SDC at Sierra Vista, the testimony and documentary evidence do not support a finding that the proposed placement is the least restrictive environment in which those needs can be appropriately addressed. As a practical matter, the District’s failure to assess Student and determine the genesis of her serious behavior problems precludes the Hearing Officer from making any finding that Student’s needs cannot be addressed satisfactorily in a less restrictive environment through the use of additional supplementary aides and services.

Finally, the Hearing Officer is unpersuaded by the witness testimony that Student cannot benefit educationally from a placement that is less restrictive than the Sierra Vista SDC. The fact of the matter is that Student is earning passing grades in some of her classes at LCCHS. Indeed, she has continued to earn solid “B” level grade in the physical science class where she is also has exhibited many negative behaviors. The fact that weekly counseling alone has failed to correct Student’s behavior problems at LCCHS does not demonstrate that Student’s needs can only be addressed in the highly restrictive Regional SDC placement. Moreover, the witness opinions regarding Student’s ability to function in any less restrictive environment must be viewed with considerable skepticism because no measures have been considered or implemented to provide her with any additional behavioral supports or services in the face of her obvious difficulty with the transition from middle school to high school.

Simply put, the District has been aware of Student’s defiant and disruptive school behaviors since the start of the 2003-2004 school year, yet it has never taken action to obtain permission, via a due process hearing, to conduct the necessary assessments so that the behaviors could be properly addressed through an appropriate behavior support plan. The evidence presented at the hearing only establishes that Student’s current program of placement and services is not fully meeting her needs. No persuasive evidence has been presented demonstrating that Student can only receive educational benefit from her special education and related services if she is placed in the highly restrictive environment of the Regional SDC at Sierra Vista. * * * * In summary, although the District has demonstrated that the March 25, 2004 IEP is designed to meet Student’s needs and provide some educational benefit, the District has not shown that a FAPE has been offered in the least restrictive environment. Because appropriate behavioral assessments, supplementary aids and services were not considered for Student at LCCHS to address her escalating behavior problems, the District has not demonstrated that it has exhausted the continuum of less restrictive placement options. Student’s behavior must be formally assessed, and a behavioral support plan must be developed from that assessment, before she can be removed from her current placement. Further, in order to ensure that her academic needs are met pending such behavior assessments and behavior supports, Student’s existing resource specialist services at LCCHS must be maintained to provide her with support and make progress on the Algebra mastery goal in her March 25, 2004 IEP. (Footnote 28)

2. May the District refer Student for community mental health service assessment without parental consent?

The District contends that, based upon the results of its psycho-educational assessment in November of 2001 and in light of recent behavior problems at school, Student likely requires community mental health care services in order to benefit from her special education program and services. Accordingly, the District seeks to refer Student for a mental health assessment by the community mental health service. Parent, however, will not provide consent for the assessment referral. The California Education Code, at section 56321, states that "No assessment shall be conducted unless the written consent of the parent is obtained prior to the assessment except pursuant to subdivision (e) of Section 56506." Where such consent is not forthcoming, the remedy available to a public education agency is to "prevail[] in a due process hearing relating to the assessment" and thereby obtain permission to conduct the assessment. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56506(e) and 56321.

Under California law, mental health care through a community mental health service must be provided to students with disabilities who require mental health care to benefit from their special educational services. Cal. Govt. Code § 7572, et seq. Accordingly, based upon the results of a student’s social emotional status assessment, an IEP team may refer a pupil with exceptional needs to a community mental health service if it suspects that the pupil requires mental health care. Cal. Govt. Code § 7576; 5 C.C.R. § 60040. Under California law, a special education student can only be referred for community mental health services after: (1) the pupil has been assessed by school personnel in all areas of suspected disability pursuant to California Education Code section 56320, et seq.; (2) the local educational agency (LEA) has obtained written parental consent for the referral, for the release and exchange of information between the LEA and the community mental health service, and for the observation of the pupil by qualified mental health professionals in an educational setting; (3) the pupil has been found to have significant emotional or behavioral characteristics, that have been observed by qualified educational staff in educational and other settings, impede the pupil from benefitting from educational services and cannot be described solely as social maladjustment or a temporary adjustment problem; (4) the pupil has been found to possess cognitive function sufficient to enable the pupil to benefit from mental health services, and; (5) that the pupil has previously been provided counseling services, and the IEP team has determined that the services are clearly inappropriate or not meeting the pupil’s educational needs. See Cal. Govt. Code § 7576; 5 C.C.R. § 60040.

The evidence and testimony persuade the Hearing Officer that all pre-requisites for a mental health service assessment referral under Government Code section 7576 have been met, with the exception of parental consent. First, Student was fully assessed by the District in all areas of suspected disability during her October 2001 triennial reassessment. These assessments, as well as the testimony of the witnesses, further indicate that Student possesses average to high-average cognitive abilities and, therefore, would be able to benefit from community mental health services. Second, the documentary record also demonstrates that Student has been provided counseling services through the District for the past three school years. The fact that the defiant and disruptive school behaviors escalated over the past three years, rather than diminished, confirms the testimony of Ms. Birdson, Mr. Gold and Mr. Kamon that the IEP team has determined the counseling services from the District are not meeting Student’s needs at the present time. Third, the testimony and documentary evidence previously discussed at length also demonstrate that Student’s behavior is presently impeding her ability to benefit from her educational services through the District. Finally, the testimony of Ms. Birdson, the school psychologist, establishes that Student’s problematic behaviors at school stem from her impulsiveness, loss of control, poor decision-making and a significant inability to maintain relationships with peers and adults, all of which are characteristics of Student’s ADHD, depression and bi-polar disorder. As such, Student’s behaviors are not associated with a temporary condition or social maladjustment.

Under the circumstances of this matter, the Hearing Officer concludes that a referral for Student to a community mental health service for a mental health assessment is appropriate. Accordingly, in order to comply with its legal obligation to assess Student and provide appropriate special education services, the District is allowed to make a community mental health service assessment referral.

ORDERS

1. The District shall not implement the Regional SDC placement at Sierra Vista High School specified in Student’s March 25, 2004 IEP. Further, to address her academic needs at LCCHS during the 2004-2005 school year pending further agreement of her full IEP team, Student shall receive one hour per day of resource specialist services. In all other respects, however, the program of services specified in the March 25, 2004 IEP shall be implemented for Student in her current placement at La Costa Canyon High School. Finally, Student’s IEP team shall meet within ten (10) days of the date of this order and amend the March 25, 2004 IEP to conform with this order and reflect her continued placement and resource specialist services at LCCHS.

2. The District shall conduct and complete a functional analysis assessment of Student within thirty (30) calendar days of the date of classes begin at LCCHS for the 2004-2005 school year. With the exception of the parental consent requirement, the District must comply with the requirements of 5 C.C.R. § 3052 in the preparation of the functional analysis assessment.

3. Within seven (7) calendar days of the completion of the functional analysis assessment, the IEP team shall meet to consider the recommendations of the assessment report and to develop a behavioral intervention plan for Student, if determined necessary by the IEP team.

4. The District shall refer Student for community mental health service assessment, as provided in California Government. Code section 7576 and Title 5, section 60040 of the California Code of Regulations, without parental consent.

PREVAILING PARTY FINDINGS

Pursuant to California Education Code Section 56507(d), the following findings are made as to the prevailing party on each issue submitted for resolution:

Issue No. 1

Has the District offered a free appropriate public education to Student in the March 25, 2004 Individualized Education Plan?

Student prevailed on this issue.

Issue No. 2

May the District refer Student for community mental health services without parental consent?

The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. Any such appeal must be made within ninety (90) days of receiving this decision.

Dated: August 19, 2004 ____________________________ John G. Andersen, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. No written records regarding Student’s placement, services or assessments in the Encinitas District were provided to the Hearing Officer in this proceeding.

2. The documentary record reflects a dispute regarding strategies and accommodations to address Student’s poor performance in math and algebra classes, although there was no dispute that Student required special education resource specialist services to address academic needs in math and algebra. Further, the written record reflects agreement regarding Student’s need for DIS counseling services, as well as the appropriateness of her continued placement in a general education middle school classroom. Finally, although Student had been disciplined for defiant and disruptive behavior on numerous occasions resulting in three days of suspension, the draft IEP for the 2002-2003 school year specifically indicates that Student’s behavior problems were not interfering with her learning or the learning of other pupils.

3. The IEP indicates that Student was receiving a B+ grade in remedial math, and a C+ grade in science.

4. Parent did note to the team that Student was experiencing problems in reaching a stable dosage mix for her Adderol and Prozac, the psychoactive medications prescribed to treat her ADHD, depression and bi-polar disorder.

5. Parent’s agreement in principle to the December 2003 IEP is reflected by her initials at various appropriate sections of the form.

6. The nature of Parent’s objections regarding the December 15, 2003 IEP document were not revealed during the hearing, or in the documentary record. The IEP document does make reference to Parent asserting that Student has an unidentified learning disability, but also indicates that Parent declined an offer to conduct further psycho-educational testing to identify any such learning disability.

7. Although she did not sign the December 2003 IEP, the documentary record nonetheless also reflects an “understanding” by Parent that “accommodations are moving forward.” This otherwise undefined understanding is consistent with the fact, discussed infra, that the IEP team used the goals and objectives from the December 2003 IEP in their determination of Student’s progress at the subsequent, March 2004, annual IEP meeting.

8. Mr. Kamon testified and prepared a disciplinary summary stating that the five-day suspension on January 15, 2004, was also based upon a January 13, 2004 written classroom assignment by Student which included “inflammatory racist comments.” However, the Notice of Suspension only mentions the January 15, 2004 altercation, and Student’s LCCHS disciplinary record does not reflect any written referral for discipline on January 13, 2004, relating to racist comments.

9. Student was observed laying on top of a male classmate engaging in what the instructor characterized as inappropriate sexual behavior.

10. Although a manifestation determination is not required until a pupil is suspended for a total of ten days, the notes of the February 5, 2005 meeting state that “the purpose of today’s meeting is to conduct a manifestation determination because Student is close to 10 days of suspension (9 days).” The February 4, 2004 Manifestation Determination Report similarly describes the behavior necessitating the manifestation determination as “Student has incurred 9 days of suspension this year.”

11. The notes from the prior, February 9, 2004, meeting indicate concern for the “safety of District team members” as the reason the school police officer was summoned, as well as the reason the officer would be invited to the rescheduled conclusion of that meeting.

12. The meeting notes state that this written Manifestation Determination Report by Ms. Birdson was not reviewed at the meetings on February 6 or 9, 2004, when Student and her mother were in attendance.

13. None of the form written notices of the meeting indicated that expulsion was being considered. Rather the forms state that the purpose of the meeting was to conduct a manifestation determination and consider a placement change.

14. The Regional SDC is a special day class operated by the special education local planning agency (SELPA) where students from the SELPA’s numerous member school districts, including the Petitioner, receive specialized education and services unavailable in the schools directly operated by the member Districts.

15. No copy of this written assessment plan was provided to the Hearing Officer in the District’s documentary evidence package, and the specific assessments proposed in the written plan were not the subject of any oral testimony from the District’s witnesses.

16. Parent did not object to the use of the December 2003 goals and objective at the March 2004 IEP meeting. As discussed supra, although Parent declined to sign the December 15, 2003 annual IEP, she had an understanding that Student would receive services consistent with that IEP.

17. The only incident of Student’s racial insensitivity previously identified in the written record or by the witnesses was that of January 13, 2004, when she wrote what Mr. Kamon characterized as an “inflammatory racist comment” on an in-class, written assignment. A copy of the assignment was provided to the Hearing Officer. The instructor’s assignment was to student to articulate his/her understanding of a political cartoon depicting the President George W. Bush welcoming an illegal immigrant crawling under a fence and holding back a Border Patrol officer, with the caption “Whoa, Officer! This is no illegal alien. This looks like a voter to me.” Student’s written response to the politically provocative cartoon-based assignment repeatedly utilized a racial slur reference to Hispanic persons and expressed a belief that all Hispanics should return to Mexico and should not interact with “white people.” Student received zero points, out of a possible ten, on the assignment. In his testimony, Mr. Gold characterized Student’s work on this written assignment as a “hate crime.”

18. After the February 9, 2004 IEP team meeting, Parent sent a letter to the District revoking consent to Student’s receipt of further counseling from District personnel.

19. Neither in its original April 19, 2004 petition, nor in any subsequent filing, has the District sought permission to proceed with any of the assessments it had proposed for Student, including the triennial re-assessment and the FAA first proposed in February 2004 in conjunction with the first manifestation determination.

20. The District members of the IEP team were aware that written notice of the meeting was sent out late and that the notice would not have reached Parent prior to April 29, 2004.

21. The documentary record reflects that the goals, objectives, modifications and accommodations set forth in the March 25, 2004 IEP are identical in every respect to those set forth in the IEP developed on December 15, 2003, when Student’s team proposed a general education placement at LCCHS with daily resource and weekly counseling services.

22. Although Ms. Birdson prepared and presented a written behavior support plan (BSP) at the April 29, 2004 manifestation determination IEP meeting, the BSP was prepared long after the Sierra Vista SDC placement was recommended in February of 2004. Further, the meeting at which Ms. Birdson presented the BSP was held in Student and Parent’s absence.

23. The report further stated that Student had called her mother on the phone and that Parent had arranged for the medications to be brought to the school and delivered to Student.

24. The Hearing Officer is not suggesting that Student ever be forcibly medicated.

25. An FAA is a complex and lengthy behavior assessment procedure. An FAA may only be conducted by a person with documented training in the area of behavior analysis. 5 C.C.R. § 3052(b). In conducting an FAA, the assessor must gather information regarding the student from three sources: direct observation; interviews with significant others; and a review of all available educational data. Id. An FAA assessor also must document, define and describe the consequences of the subject behavior and analyze the ecological settings of the behavior. Finally, an FAA assessor must review the student’s medical and health records for factors which may influence the behavior. Id. Thereafter, an FAA assessor must prepare a detailed written report documenting, defining and describing such matters as the frequency, duration and intensity of the problem behavior, as well as the immediate antecedents events associated with the behavior. Id.

26. California law requires that an FAA be conducted and a written behavior intervention plan (BIP) be developed based on the FAA, in instances of “serious behavior problems.” 5 C.C.R. §§ 3001, 3052. The term “serious behavior problems” is defined as “behaviors which are self-injurious, assaultive, or cause serious property damage and other severe behavior problems that are pervasive and maladaptive for which instructional/behavioral approaches specified in the student’s IEP are found to be ineffective.” Id., at § 3001 (aa). After an FAA is completed, the pupil’s IEP team is required to meet and develop a detailed written behavior intervention plan (BIP) which seeks to alter the identified antecedent events, seeks to prevent the occurrence of the negative behaviors, seeks to teach alternative and adaptive behaviors, and which spells out appropriate responses when negative behaviors occur. Id., at § 3052(c),(d) and (e).

27. The Hearing Officer finds that no compelling circumstances have been shown presently justifying Student’s placement in the Sierra Vista SDC pending completion of the necessary assessment and behavior support plan. The witness opinions that Student is a danger to herself and others on the LCCHS campus are not persuasive and do not over-ride the District’s obligation to evaluate and implement services for Student in the least restrictive environment. Further, no showing has been made that any dangerous or violent behavior is likely to recur and, therefore, pose reasonable future risk of harm. Moreover, in the event that circumstances change and immediate danger to Student or other students can be demonstrated, a school district may initiate judicial proceedings and seek a court order allowing removal of a dangerous student from the school environment. Light v. Parkway, 41 F.3d 1223 (9th Cir. 1995).

28. No testimony or evidence was presented indicating that Student required additional academic assistance, or that the existing daily RSP services at LCCHS were insufficient to meet her academic needs in relation to the Algebra goal. The RSP services were not offered in the March 25, 2004 IEP because the small class size of the Region SDC provided the necessary academic support.